We're not winning the division this year. We're no where close to being on the Eagles level. We might get 2nd somehow, mainly because of injuries on the Giants and Red Skins, but right now we are the 3rd best team in the East. We have to earn 2nd.
But yeah, people are missing the point why people are upset. You got some people yucking it up that people are "giving up" the third game in the season. But those are short term thinkers, like you are explaining. It's not about making the playoffs; it is about how we most likely perform if we do get there. Week 1, deer-caught-in-headlights look in the season opener against what should be an easy win. Week 3, in a game where both sides of the ball start a comeback to win a game many of us marked as an Loss before the season started, you have a no guts, no glory move to throw the ball away, which cost us the game. That kind of leadership is not going to help us if we do somehow manage to squeeze into the playoffs.
It's people who look at the short term versus people who look at the long term. If I look in the short term, yeah its only game 3. If i look towards the long term, the defense hasn't improved from last year, we have puppet coaches, and the quarterback is not an on the field leader that could handle the pressure of the playoffs.