The Blue Print to paint the Big Blue Black and Blue

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
"Whoever gets the mismatch gets the ball with us," Bennett said. "I think it's a great tool and a great weapon we showed." Martellus Bennett dead panned.

Personally, I think this may have been the definition of tipping your hand, but then again, I think most defenses in this league expect the mismatches to get picked on. And then, to take that a step further, how will defenses applying that information use it against us? Honestly?

Here's what opposing defenses, provided our weapons can stay healthy, are up against?

Wide Receivers

Roy Williams (6'3" 215): I think we can, at least, all agree he is a clutch possession receiver. Though, I have to say, that Touchdown early in the second half looked alot like the Touchdown Larry Fitzgerald scored late in the Super Bowl last season. Romo throws a beautiful rope hitting Roy in stride, effortlessly pulling in a ball that would break hands off.

Patrick Crayton (6'0" 204): He has often been regarded as having the best hand's on the team. But after that 80 + yard touchdown against the Bucs, I'd say his offseason work added quite a bit to his explosion and overall speed.

Miles Austin (6'3" 214): Speed has never been a concern. It's what earned him a look from the Cowboys in the first place. But last year, when he turned up field rather than keeping his orginal direction allowing the defense to thrwart his otherwise touchdown against Green Bay, we all saw why he was still a work in progress. But against the Bucs, he showed the speed and the moves to complement him, as he took a 40+ catch in for a Touchdown, making two players miss one shortly after the first, to take the lead shortly before the end of the 1st half.

Sam Hurd and Kevin Ogletree (6'2" 208 & 6'0: 192): Unless one of the above see injury, it's unlikely we see much of either this year. But as a quick reminder, Hurd was the receiver who arguably had the best training camp of all the receivers making acrobatic catch, one after another and Kevin Ogletree played the best in preseason, unseating a fairly rooted 3rd year receiver Isaiah Stanback who was much better in Special Teams than Kevin; that mean's the coaches must have thought alot of Kevin to drop Isaiah, considering the 5th receiver spot typically goes to the Special Teams standout.

Tight Ends

Jason Witten (6'5" 263): He won't wow you with speed or explosion, but he find's the soft spots in coverage and does not drop balls, as a general rule. He is also a fairly dominant lead blocker out of the backfield and from the standard TE lineup. Furthermore, he is Romo's favorite target. That speaks volumes to Witten's reliability.

Martellus Bennett (6'6" 265): Big mouth. Big personality. But he is all business on the field. He, too, has displayed the ability to make some clutch catches, even when contested by a would-be defender. This teamed with his wide receiver like speed, makes him extremely dangerous after the catch.

John Phillips (6'5" 255): Think Jason Witten in the early years. Of course, rather or not he can maintain intensity through severe adversity, such as a deabilitatant injury, remains to be seen, but in terms of his hands and his ability to block, he certainly seems to have the tools to be described as Witten-esqe.

Running Backs

Marion Barber (6, 0" 222): Has proven on a fairly consistent basis that he is a reliable target out of the backfield. If we are being honest, we haven't really seen the Barbarian like play, a moniker earned in the 2007 season, but he is still solid and can typically pick up 3 to 4 yard's after the 1st contact with the opposition.

Felix Jones (6'0" 218): The first thing you notice is his explosion. In space, he can turn a check down from Cowboy's 5 yard line to a touchdown 95 yards down the field in about 10 seconds. After his initial explosion, you might notice that second gear he hit's when turning the corner. If you don't know what I'm talking about look for Romo on a pitch to Jones on 4th and 3 against the Bengals on youtube or google it. If you can, watch it in slow motion; when he turn's the corner watch as seem's as though for a brief moment he is running in real time while everyone around him is still moving slow. Lastly, there is his vision. The ability to set up the next defender while making the 1st defender miss. It's a rare ability that among Cowboy great's, only Emmitt Smith had and, though I'm not sure on this, perhaps Tony Dorsett. But outside of those two, I don't think any RB's had vision that rivals that of Felix.

Tashard Choice (5'10" 212): A combination of Felix and Marion, is the best way to describe him. And, yes, he too can be threat out of the back field in screen and check down situations.

Deon Anderson (5'10" 245): His colleague's describe him as a devastating lead blocker. Considering his compact size and, yet, considerable weight, I don't doubt it. But I've also seen him be pretty reliable in catching situations, as well. So, he is something else an opposing defense has to think about.

Now, let's think of the above as a big odd number that a team has to find a common denominator to divide the Cowboy's by utilizing the combination of size and weight and the respective talents of their own defensive players. Quick note: some players, regardless of size, play big, so you can't always just compare size and say it's a mismatch. How do they match up to the various looks the Cowboys can create utilizing the above weapons? I feel a series coming on.
Let's take a look at our next week opponents the Giants starting unit in the secondary.

Corners

Cory Webster (6'0" 202): Clutch, but by no means what you would consider a lockdown corner. So Roy Williams and company, with precise route running, will have opportunities.

Terrell Thomas (6'0" 199): A second round pick by the Giants from 2008, you could say he's on Mike Jenkins and Orlando Scandrick's level, which means, once again, Roy Williams and company will have opportunities.

Aaron Ross (6'0" 197): According to the injury report, Aaron has a hamstring injury and is definitively out for next week's game. Though, it would not be the first time Coughlin had a player miracously recover from an injury to play afterall.
Bruce Johnson (5'11" 182): Who? Oh, that undrafted rookie free agent. Not much can be said, other than he beat out the rookies DeAndre Wright and Stoney Woodson drafted in the 6th and 7th rounds respectively to make the 53 man roster.

Linebackers

Danny Clark (6'2" 245): A 10 year veteran, he is solid, particularly against the run, but I can't see him running with any of our TE's down the seem.

Antonio Pierce (6'1" 238): A 9 year veteran, same issue as Danny Clark.

Bryan Kehl (6'2" 237): Logged the least amount of tackles in his first year with the Giants last year, despite starting all 16 games. If a Safety doesn't move up to cover our TE's, he will likely be the unlucky soul charged with the responsbility.

Safeties

Kenny Phillips (6'2" 210): He's my favorite Giant, in a weird "I still hate you because of the team you represent" kind of way. Not only is he good in coverage, but he can still lay the wood like the orginal prototypical SS. Think 1st and 2nd year Roy Williams, with the coverage ability of Gerald Sensabaugh.

Michael Johnson (6'2" 207): I don't know much about him, but looking at his stat's, I'll say he is, at least, solid. I would expect nothing less from a Coughlin staffed defense.

Four corners, with one definitely out for the game and the other an undrafted rookie, 3 safeties, and 4 linebackers. That is the price the Giants paid to win battles at the line of scrimmage. But for that ideaology to be effective, they have to win every battle at the line and, honestly, I don't think they can do that against the Cowboys, particular when the Cowboys show the 12 formation (i.e. two receivers, two TE's and one RB). Considering the aforementioned, we will likely see a much more effective version of the Bucs defensive gameplan. The Giants are going to force us to beat them deep, which also means the Cowboys offensive line is going to have to give Romo time; and that, admittedly, considering the talent and depth on the Giants defensive line, is going to be a tall order. I said it of the Bucs game, and I'm sticking to this philosophical belief, the Cowboys will also need to employ some screens to back off that blitz, but I would not be suprised if Jason Garrett didn't come out of the gate wanting Romo to sling it deep to test that very thin secondary.

Now for the fun part. Consider the above described 12 formation. Webster and Thomas will likely pick up RW and Crayton. Brian Kehl will likely pick up either Bennett or Witten, dependent on their alignment. Who pick's up the other TE, particularly if they get motioned out wide? The Safety. What does that leave? Either Crayton or William's in a one on one situation. Are we getting the picture? All of our receivers last Sunday displayed the ability to beat single-coverage. It come's down to protecting Romo long enough to take advantage of the obvious mismatches: The receiver in single coverage and/or the TE matched up with Kehl. Pretty simple, actually. I could do this all day, but I hope most of my reader's can read the above and imagine the amount of different alignment's the Cowboy's can do that will create several different undesirable situations for the Giant's defense.

The other side of the ball is a different question entirely. Given the Cowboy's performance last week and considering the above, one could surmise that Sunday could turn into a shoot out. I seriously doubt it, though. It will be a close game, that will likely be decided by Special Teams and the turnover ratio.

Prediction: Cowboys 24 Giants 20







 

CM Duck

I'm breaking the 4th wall...
Messages
1,012
Reaction score
8
After reading the title of this thread I want to watch the movie "Old School"
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
Good write up.

Except Phillips has better coverage than Gerald Sensabaugh. That guy is a breakout star waiting to happen.
 

sonnyboy

Benched
Messages
7,357
Reaction score
0
Outstanding and Insightful.

Have to admit when I read your title I was thinking more mindless crap we already know. "We have to stop the run and get after Manning"
I just love those nuggets of brilliance.;)

But this was great. I agree with your view on the staff's opinion of Ogeltree. Not likely to keep a 5th WR with so little special teams impact, unless they really think he's got the goods.

But I don't agree with your view on how the Giants plan to defense us. TB strategy was one of desperation. The Giants are too talent and too smart for that. We will see plenty of cover 2 and little blitzing. The will rely on their outstanding DL to get after Romo on it's own for the most part.
The trick for us is to make them pay for that with excellent pass protection and oodles of time for Romo to find his 3rd and 4th option when he has to.

Ordinarily my confidence isn't easily shaken. But I have to admit, Sunday's run stopping effort has me 2nd guessing what I thought this defense was.

I HOPE TO GOD I'M WRONG. Good thing is we couldn't get a better week 2 draw to see just where we are with our run defense.

BTW-The Giants almost CAN'T beat us without an effective running game.

All teams, all offenses operate better and more efficiently when the run game is working. Most good teams don't lean on it, they don't need it. Teams like the Giants and Panthers absolutely need it.
 

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
I liked pretty much everything in there...but Phillips is nowhere even remotely anywhere somewhere close to Jason Witten except in blocking. Can he catch a 5 yard curl, yeah, but 90% of TEs can.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
sonnyboy;2945071 said:
Outstanding and Insightful.

Have to admit when I read your title I was thinking more mindless crap we already know. "We have to stop the run and get after Manning"
I just love those nuggets of brilliance.;)

But this was great. I agree with your view on the staff's opinion of Ogeltree. Not likely to keep a 5th WR with so little special teams impact, unless they really think he's got the goods.

But I don't agree with your view on how the Giants plan to defense us. TB strategy was one of desperation. The Giants are too talent and too smart for that. We will see plenty of cover 2 and little blitzing. The will rely on their outstanding DL to get after Romo on it's own for the most part.
The trick for us is to make them pay for that with excellent pass protection and oodles of time for Romo to find his 3rd and 4th option when he has to.

Ordinarily my confidence isn't easily shaken. But I have to admit, Sunday's run stopping effort has me 2nd guessing what I thought this defense was.

I HOPE TO GOD I'M WRONG. Good thing is we couldn't get a better week 2 draw to see just where we are with our run defense.

BTW-The Giants almost CAN'T beat us without an effective running game.

All teams, all offenses operate better and more efficiently when the run game is working. Most good teams don't lean on it, they don't need it. Teams like the Giants and Panthers absolutely need it.
Thanks for the kudos!

I say that they will make us beat them deep because I'm speculating they believe they can get to Romo before he has an opportunity to throw deep. As I said referencing the 12 formation, the TE's will require Safety help; there is no way there Linebackers get matched up on both of our TE's on a regular basis. When that happen's, that leave's one of our WR's in a one on one situation. From the feedback I got from A Giant's fan, that will likely be Roy Williams who will be shadowed by Corey Webster. Corey Webster may win that battle the majority of the day, but as we saw against the Bucs, it only takes one mistake to lead to a game changing touchdown.

Listening to Demarcus Ware, Keith Brooking, and Bradie James, I'm at least encouraged that they are taking accountability for the breakdown and are committed to fixing it. Furthermore, after the concussion Demarcus Ware suffered, he wasn't his usual dominating self. I think we see a different defense out there Sunday night. Furthermore, the weather won't be so abrasive given it's here in September at night. I'd imagine for the New Yorkers, they will still think it's hot!

I'd like to see another offensive coordinator performance like we saw last week. He did a great job of keeping the Bucs off balance; I think we are capable of doing the same thing to the Giants.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,471
I think it's all going to come down to the guys you didn't mention, the guys in the trenches. After we sacked Eli eight times last year, and after what we showed last week, I think they'll try to run it down our throats, especially with Jacobs (who didn't play last December).

And like sonnyboy said, I am worried about it. Not just because of what we saw last week -- actually that may help our preparation this week -- but because the Giants are just a great running team. They absolutely steamrolled the Ravens D last year, and everyone loves them.

BTW, it's funny, I don't know when Corey Webster became Deion Sanders. But reading Mosley and others, he did.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
Future;2945127 said:
I liked pretty much everything in there...but Phillips is nowhere even remotely anywhere somewhere close to Jason Witten except in blocking. Can he catch a 5 yard curl, yeah, but 90% of TEs can.
He actually made several clutch catches throughout preseason, and as you admitted, was a good blocker. But just so I'm clear, I'm not saying he's Jason Witten of today or Jason Witten of the last 5 years. I said he reminds me of Jason Witten as a Rookie and Sophmore player. I further stated that the jury is still out on rather or not he can man up through injury.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
Chocolate Lab;2945628 said:
I think it's all going to come down to the guys you didn't mention, the guys in the trenches. After we sacked Eli eight times last year, and after what we showed last week, I think they'll try to run it down our throats, especially with Jacobs (who didn't play last December).

And like sonnyboy said, I am worried about it. Not just because of what we saw last week -- actually that may help our preparation this week -- but because the Giants are just a great running team. They absolutely steamrolled the Ravens D last year, and everyone loves them.

BTW, it's funny, I don't know when Corey Webster became Deion Sanders. But reading Mosley and others, he did.

I expect the Giants will have some success running after all they are very strong at running the ball. Dallas just can't allow the Giants to have a big day running the ball.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
Chocolate Lab;2945628 said:
I think it's all going to come down to the guys you didn't mention, the guys in the trenches. After we sacked Eli eight times last year, and after what we showed last week, I think they'll try to run it down our throats, especially with Jacobs (who didn't play last December).

And like sonnyboy said, I am worried about it. Not just because of what we saw last week -- actually that may help our preparation this week -- but because the Giants are just a great running team. They absolutely steamrolled the Ravens D last year, and everyone loves them.

BTW, it's funny, I don't know when Corey Webster became Deion Sanders. But reading Mosley and others, he did.
Due to popular demand (okay so I had 1 request to do this), I'm going to write another piece matching there offense against our defense. Mistakes will be made, they are in every game, the Giants will score, but I am more concerned about Ahmad Bradshaw than I am Brandon Jacobs. Granted, in goalline situations it's almost a definite touchbown for him. But in most cases, it's take time for him to accelerate. And since getting penetration is something the Cowboys are actually get at (wrapping up is the issue), as long as we can slow him up before he get's a full head of steam, he's fairly pedestrian as a RB, in my opinion. Take a look at the Commanders game...he averaged 2.9 yards per carry on 16 touches.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
SLATEmosphere;2944916 said:
Boley will be starting. Not Kehl. But ya I get what your saying. Can't cover them all!
See, NFL.com list Kehl as the starter. I just checked the team website and Chase Blackburn is the starter. Furthermore, Michael Boley not even mentioned on their depth chart. I'm going from the information I have access to online.
 

Tobal

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,336
Reaction score
328
Pierce is smart and a warrior, Phillips is a stud safety, I'd trade both are starting safeties for him today. (that might be unfair to Sensabaugh, not enough info yet)

That front line is deep and relentless.... Canty might be a much better DT in thier scheme than he was a DE in ours.... I'm giving the Giants front office the benefit of the doubt I never saw him as that much, but he was compared to Lett when he came out of college. Lett was a very disruptive DT.





,
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,471
Don't worry, Canty is no Leon Lett. Not even close. I'm surprised anyone would even make that comparison.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
Tobal;2945756 said:
Pierce is smart and a warrior, Phillips is a stud safety, I'd trade both are starting safeties for him today. (that might be unfair to Sensabaugh, not enough info yet)

That front line is deep and relentless.... Canty might be a much better DT in thier scheme than he was a DE in ours.... I'm giving the Giants front office the benefit of the doubt I never saw him as that much, but he was compared to Lett when he came out of college. Lett was a very disruptive DT.





,
Not sure if you read my entire post, but I admitted that Phillips is an awesome Safety and Pierce is great, but I still say he's a mismatch waiting to be exploited trying to cover either of our TE's.

I also admitted that their DL was strong, which is why their secondary has suffered, in terms of depth; particulary now that Aaron Ross is injured.

It is due to these admissions of their overall defensive strenth that I say that this is going to be a close game, but if the Cowboy's shore up the issues that were exposed against the Bucs, I see the Cowboys winning the field position battles with our new and improved Special Teams and the turnover ratio, now that Romo has committed to preventing turnovers via fumble and interceptions.
 

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
Chocolate Lab;2945778 said:
Don't worry, Canty is no Leon Lett. Not even close. I'm surprised anyone would even make that comparison.
Agreed. If he were Leon Lett, he would be starting.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
Nice read.

I'd only argue that Webster is in fact a lock down CB(he is the best Cb in the division) and Terrell Thomas is NOT on Jenkins and Scandrick's level.

Jenkins can be beaten but he attacks the ball as his reversed Pick and near pick showed last week. Scandrick may not be the same type ballhawk but plays with better technique and is more physical.

The Giants have a good all-around D but Dallas enough weapons to get people open and make big plays eventually.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
Chocolate Lab;2945628 said:
I think it's all going to come down to the guys you didn't mention, the guys in the trenches. After we sacked Eli eight times last year, and after what we showed last week, I think they'll try to run it down our throats, especially with Jacobs (who didn't play last December).

And like sonnyboy said, I am worried about it. Not just because of what we saw last week -- actually that may help our preparation this week -- but because the Giants are just a great running team. They absolutely steamrolled the Ravens D last year, and everyone loves them.

BTW, it's funny, I don't know when Corey Webster became Deion Sanders. But reading Mosley and others, he did.

Look up his stats on football outsiders or any other site that does CB metrics. He is top notch.

Also check how well he played Santana Moss last week. The guy is stellar.
 

gmoney112

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,589
Reaction score
15,694
Webster and Phillips are great. Only problem is, that's all they have. Boley is back and no one's sure exactly how he's going to play after missing so much time, even then a LB on Witten or Bnasty is a mismatch. Antonio Pierce can not cover.

They don't have enough weapons in their secondary to challenge us, point blank. This is a major mismatch that no one is talking about in the media but I think we'll see Romo have a huge game.

How many yards did Randle El pick up in the slot?

Webster was great on moss in single coverage, is he going to be as good on a receiver 5 inches taller? Moss is tiny and he had Campbell throwing to him. Roy is a large WR and has Romo. Webster won't get beat often but when he does it'll be big.

Crayton will have a huge game in the slot, barber will spend more time on the field for pass protection and he'll catch a few great screens. Felix will have a good run, choice will come in and catch some passes. Roy won't have a HUGE game but he'll get his fair share.

Our run defense will be fine. The Giants are arguably the best running team in the NFL, we're going to give up some yards. There's a reason why they are the best and people are delusional if they think any team in the NFL is going to be able to just completely shut down the Giants running attack. What will happen though is Eli will not be able to throw. His only out will be able to hand the ball off because that's all he will have. Commanders secondary was awful last game and Eli still looked mediocre. Once we are ahead by 7+ Eli will be forced to throw and the game will turn into a rout.

Neither Jacobs or Bradshaw are Cadillac, we got great penetration against the Bucs it was just in the wrong places. Cadillacs first cut is insane and there's a reason why he dominates when he's healthy, Ward is also a 1,000 yard back. Jacobs will have a subpar day, as I honestly think Bradshaw will start to the majority of the carries when Jacobs struggles.

It will be a close game, if we can get up 10 in a decent amount of time it will turn into a rout.

I'm predicting 34-24
 
Top