The Mike McCarthy Question

[cowboyec]

Only way Big Mike gets a new deal is if Jerry is happy.

Jerry doesn’t look happy.

he never looks happy.

 

[cowboyec]

Let’s be fair…

KMoore had the #1 offense in Dallas.

when he left, we got Big Mikes Basic offense.

and we won the same number of super bowls...0.

 

[KMY_Amber]

Mike won't be back. The injuries won't save his job. He hasn't proven his worth well enough in the Big Games.

JJ and the Cowboys are moving on...

 

[RonWashington]

I know he wont
Im just making the point that there are no good options with Mccarthy
Id just let him walk

I would too

 

[KingCorcoran]

No I’m saying what I think Jerry will do not what I would do let’s not mix things up here King . I’ve been on record in numerous threads that this team should hire a young NFL OC as the next coach . Too many instances lately of young OC coming into franchises and offenses perk up and playoff wins even SB wins start happening . ( see Rams 49ers Vikings Browns if they ever get a QB ) .

When I say MM would only accept 3 yrs that’s how I think a Jerry offer would play out.

As to Siriani if the Eagles lose in its first playoff game then yes he’s fired . Too many unmet expectations . And head to head with MM he has not proven to be superior just hasn’t .

He’s 3-4 vs. McCarthy and the Eagles have prevailed in three of the last five games with Dallas. Neither is “superior” to the other. What is significant is Sirianni is on a hotter seat than MM. The advent of the Commanders return to success makes the NFCE a greater challenge than it’s been in recent years. I’ll bet Washington beats the Eagles tomorrow.

 

[RonWashington]

He’s 3-4 vs. McCarthy and the Eagles have prevailed in three of the last five games with Dallas. Neither is “superior” to the other. What is significant is Sirianni is on a hotter seat than MM. The advent of the Commanders return to success makes the NFCE a greater challenge than it’s been in recent years. I’ll bet Washington beats the Eagles tomorrow.

Should be a good game . Quinn hasn’t done too bad his first yr back as HC

 

[Chasing6]

I've seen and heard a lot of talk recently about Mike McCarthy's job status... and while I think most of us thought he was on the Green Mile after Dak went down, they've rattled off a couple of wins against less than stellar competition and a lot of talk is about keeping him.

I'm not a fan of this and I'll tell you why.

I don't think Mike can get the job done in the playoffs and beyond. Do you?

To add to that, he seems like too much of a kiss butt for the Jones and doesn't challenge them enough to make the necessary improvements. (Look at this past offseason)

And finally: The Five-Year Rule: No team has ever started the same quarterback under the same head coach for more than five years and seen that duo win its first championship.

This conversation might all be for not as I also think we lose out here to finish the season and I think it will take care of itself. But I'd love to hear, who you want to be the next HC and who you think we'll get.

I don't believe there is Coach alive that can get the job done with GM Jethro. Hanging out at the rim is max.