The new NFC East is a power house.

clayman

New Member
Messages
272
Reaction score
0
Sam Madison is a huge upgrade for the Giants.....I don't think you could call him aging and washed up yet people here are fine with signing McGinest....talk about pot meet kettle. :)
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
Roy got got burned last year in coverage,
TNew is good but he is no D. Sanders or TLaw (in his prime)
I like Julius Jones, when healthy and but does he scare anyone, Not me

the closest game changer I can think of is T Glenn, he could beat you deep and put 6 on the board quickly when healthy
and Yes we have young potential game changers but who are teams scared of???
 

juice28

Member
Messages
321
Reaction score
0
Bigdog24 said:
Roy got got burned last year in coverage,
TNew is good but he is no D. Sanders or TLaw (in his prime)
I like Julius Jones, when healthy and but does he scare anyone, Not me

the closest game changer I can think of is T Glenn, he could beat you deep and put 6 on the board quickly when healthy
and Yes we have young potential game changers but who are teams scared of???

who on the stealers scare you?
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
TruBlueCowboy said:
Ben Roethlisberger, Hines Ward, Alan Faneca, Joey Porter, Troy Polamalu... just to name a few

The Steelers did that through good drafting but we haven't had the luxury of a Parcells controlled draft for that long, and he screwed up his second one.

Sometimes, if a freak free agent like LeCharles Bentley pops out of nowhere, you've gotta go full steam and sign him. Cowboys did that with Henry last year and it was a terrific signing.

Hines Ward is a very good player, but a game changing player? Roesthlisberger is a very good QB, but he isnt John Elway or Troy Aikman right now...Alan Faneca is a guard, he isnt a "game changing player"

the guy I was responding to said we needed big names like Vick, Moss and Owens, I said teams winning the super bowls dont have those kinds of players (and the issues that come with them)...the Steelers and Pats won because they play as a team with alot of above average to good players

David
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
clayman said:
Sam Madison is a huge upgrade for the Giants.....I don't think you could call him aging and washed up yet people here are fine with signing McGinest....talk about pot meet kettle. :)

he isnt washed up, but he isnt anywhere near as good as he was 3-4 yrs ago either...clearly on the downside

and I dont want McGinest either

after signing the likes of Ryan Young, Eddie George, Ferguson and Rivera, I'd think Jones should wise up on these aged "Parcells" player types...go get some young guys with a career ahead of them, not behind them
David
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
Agreed but Peyton always choked when looking at T LAw and Willie McGinst
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
clayman said:
Sam Madison is a huge upgrade for the Giants.....I don't think you could call him aging and washed up yet people here are fine with signing McGinest....talk about pot meet kettle. :)

Nice to meet you, kettle. At the cost of Will Allen, Sam Madison's not an upgrade. He's on the downside of a great career.
 

clayman

New Member
Messages
272
Reaction score
0
The two Wills weren't performing or the Giants would keep them being so thin....Madison is nearing his end but is still better than them for 2 years....Idgit. :)
 

TruBlueCowboy

New Member
Messages
7,301
Reaction score
0
dbair1967 said:
he isnt washed up, but he isnt anywhere near as good as he was 3-4 yrs ago either...clearly on the downside

and I dont want McGinest either

after signing the likes of Ryan Young, Eddie George, Ferguson and Rivera, I'd think Jones should wise up on these aged "Parcells" player types...go get some young guys with a career ahead of them, not behind them
David

so then I can safely assume you're behind a LeCharles Bentley movement ;)

That's really all we're saying. No more 35ish offensive linemen. Just say no to Mawae and the rest.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
clayman said:
The two Wills weren't performing or the Giants would keep them being so thin.... :)

Apply the same reasoning to Miami's situation with Madison. Tell me what you come up with. I'll wait, while you puzzle it out.

Here's a hint, though: Madison offered to take a pay cut to stay with the Dolphins. They declined.
 

DawnOfANewD

New Member
Messages
674
Reaction score
0
dbair1967 said:
he isnt washed up, but he isnt anywhere near as good as he was 3-4 yrs ago either...clearly on the downside

and I dont want McGinest either

after signing the likes of Ryan Young, Eddie George, Ferguson and Rivera, I'd think Jones should wise up on these aged "Parcells" player types...go get some young guys with a career ahead of them, not behind them
David

Don't forget the M. Wiley fiasco.
 
Top