Well, granted I don't follow the Titans that closely. However, before the season started he came out and said he didn't want to be known as a tandem with Lendale White. No more Bash and Slash. He wanted to be the feature back and gave himself his own nickname. Granted White isn't necessarily the best back out there, but they made a really good one two punch in 2008. Right there that told me he wasn't the best team player.
So, they switch to Chris Johnson as the main back, and he almost breaks the record in yards. Cool, but White's carries fall and the Titan's offense sputters at the beginning of the season until Vince Young takes over.
In both Titans games I watched this season, I studied him. They were both after Young had taken over and it was still possible for them to make the playoffs, so they were playing for something. The dude does not pass block. He doesn't even try. I know he's small, but I'd like to see some effort at least. He just stands in front of the guy and then let's him go. There was one instance where the Titans had 4th and 1, he took a swing around the right corner, had two guys on him head to head. If he had dove and bulled through it, it was almost certainly a first down. He duck out of bounds.
Yeah, he had great numbers this year. But I think the team suffered for it.