There is only 2 great QBs in the NFL now

[juck]

Peyton Manning and Brady

then you have good with a chance to be great

3.Brees
4.Rottenburger
5.Mcflabb
6.Romo
7.Eli
8.Ryan
9.cutler

Who would u take over Romo besides the obvious top 2?

 

[stilltheguru]

Ben is easily on par with Brady and Peyton.


Romo and Mcnabb?ehhh thats a toss up. Other than that, noone.

 

[Doomsday101]

All of those are very good QB as is the one we have, I'm perfectly happy having Tony Romo as my QB

 

[Idgit]

Ben is easily on par with Brady and Peyton.


Romo and Mcnabb?ehhh thats a toss up. Other than that, noone.

Dude. You're completely nuts.

I'd consider Brees over Romo. On that list, I think only Brees, Rothlisberger, and probably Brady are more likely to win a title sooner, or more of them, than Romo from here on out. But Brady's got to jump the shark at some point, and Rothlisberger is a good QB in a great situation. I think Ben in Dallas would be a mistake for both parties.

 

[cwbyfan72]

There "is" only one English language ......you butchered it.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

All of those are very good QB as is the one we have, I'm perfectly happy having Tony Romo as my QB

very well said.

 

[Doomsday101]

very well said.

What can I say I don't spend much time looking to see how green the grass is on the other side. We have damn fine QB who I support 110% and like any of those QB on this list it will take an entire team to win it all even the Great Peyton Manning is not doing it alone

 

[Rampage]

Peyton Manning and Brady

then you have good with a chance to be great

3.Brees
4.Rottenburger
5.Mcflabb
6.Romo
7.Eli
8.Ryan
9.cutler

Who would u take over Romo besides the obvious top 2?

where's Philip Rivers?

 

[Doomsday101]

where's Philip Rivers?

In San Diego. :laugh2:

 

[Faerluna]

In San Diego. :laugh2:

Thankfully!

 

[dadymat]

Ben is easily on par with Brady and Peyton.


Romo and Mcnabb?ehhh thats a toss up. Other than that, noone.

only in the ring category.....talent wise he couldnt carry their jock

 

[superpunk]

Trent Edwards.

 

[stilltheguru]

Trent Edwards.

 

[DFWJC]

Ben is easily on par with Brady and Peyton.


Romo and Mcnabb?ehhh thats a toss up. Other than that, noone.

No offense...and i like Ben...but he is closer to Garrard than Brady or Manning....he's just played on a team with a lights-out defense, a decnet running game when healthy, and has had three very good WRs to throw two for the past few years.

Trade places w/ Garrard and he has no rings for sure and DG may have one or two.

This man-love for Big Ben has gotten pretty old

 

[DFWJC]

where's Philip Rivers?

The list is a joke without him on it....espcially with some of those other guys that are on there (Eli for example)

Long term outlook...I like Ryan's potential to be very Manning-like.

 

[FLCowboyFan]

I think you could say that any year. There are rarely more than a couple of guys who are as good as Brady and Peyton. Remember Peyton had almost the same things said about him as Romo is having now. Looks like Peyton proved them wrong and I believe Romo will as well.

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

I'd still take Jay Cutler over any of them. I agree that Brady and Payton are the best right now but if I would take Cutler over the rest if it were me.

 

[casmith07]

Peyton Manning and Brady

then you have good with a chance to be great

3.Brees
4.Rottenburger
5.Mcflabb
6.Romo
7.Eli
8.Ryan
9.cutler

Who would u take over Romo besides the obvious top 2?

I'd take Dirk Nowitzki over Romo any day. ANY DAY.

In all seriousness, the fact that you have Drew Brees, Roethlisberger, and McNabb over Romo is laughable. Also, the fact that you have E. Manning and Cutler over Kurt Warner is also laughable.

 

[triplets92]

Peyton Manning and Brady

then you have good with a chance to be great

3.Brees
4.Rottenburger
5.Mcflabb
6.Romo
7.Eli
8.Ryan
9.cutler

Who would u take over Romo besides the obvious top 2?

Why is Matt Ryan on that list? he had a great year yes but it was only one year. I can't consider him a great player until 3 years in the nfl.

 

[DFWJC]

Why is Matt Ryan on that list? he had a great year yes but it was only one year. I can't consider him a great player until 3 years in the nfl.

read the post again

He said "have a chance to be great"

I's say Ryan absolutely has that, but right now is not as good as the others.