Guys, lets not blow this thing completely out of proportion. Romo did bring alot fo good things to the offense, BUT he also was VERY careless with the football.
When Romo came in, we went from an offense that could not move the football at all to moving it down the field several times, even a few times when the game was still VERY much in doubt. It really did open up the playbook, all the recievers were involved in the game. Witten became a weapon in the offense again instead of being forced to be a blocker. Even Joe Thiesman had to point out that Romo definately opened up the offense.
However, Romo also had some very bad plays. The INT on the screen pass was beyond stupid, I have no idea what he was thinking. And anytime you throw 3 INT's in a half you definately have a VERY real problem. There is no way of glossing over the fact that he did throw 3 INT's.
That said, there are definately some positives to be taken from the game. Against a good D, when the game was definately still in contention (unlike Henson and the Ravens) Romo should he could move the team and did not appear intimidated by the situation or look lost against the Giants blitz's. A LOT of QB's getting there first playing time would NOT hold up well under those circumstances.
But there is also a HUGE Question Mark, THREE INT'S in a HALF is completely unacceptable.
What do we really have in Romo is still in question. Was this an issue of a young QB being excited and tring to make to much happen. Was it an issue of Romo like the rest of the team having a bad day. Was it Romo pulling a Brett Farve, without the unbelievable talent level that Farve possessed when he was younger? Or is he anouther QB that just can not make all of the reads that are required and will always endup staring down to many WR's and thus always make WAY to many INT's. Do we have anouther Jake Delhomme who will always be a bit of a gunslinger but will grow out of it a little as he gets a few years of experience. Honestly noone knows the real answer to that question. And the answer to that question will determine if we have our QB of the future or not.