This one feels worse than ‘just a loss’. This team had no answers for what they were getting out there yesterday.
They couldn’t even slow the Saints down.
They look fundamentally flawed out there on defense. Nothing was working.
And our offense clearly couldn’t match their pace. Our offensive tackles struggled repeatedly to pass protect when they had to have it.
It might just be one ‘L’, but it feels bigger than that to me. It feels like this team has some serious issues.
It was an eye opener for sure. And I think you are right. This teams has some serious flaws. The rookie LT is not ready for prime time. It happens. The Giants drafted Evan Neal, 7th overall in the 2022 draft and he is still a mediocre player for them. They drafted Andrew Thomas 4th overall in the 2020 draft. He is better than Neal but not great considering his draft position.
Just because Dallas took Guyton in the 1st round does not mean he is great or he will be great. The kid needs to get stronger and work on his technique. Maybe he will be great some day, but he is not right now. It would have been better to sign Tyron for a 1 year deal and let Guyton back him up.
Terence Steele was never a great pass blocker. But he isn't as good as he was before his injury. Zack Martin is definitely sliding on the downside of his career. Beebe seems to be holding his own and Tyler Smith is still good, but the offensive line is a definite weakness right now. One guy makes a good block and the other four are shoved into the backfield. There is really little forward movement from this group.
I don't have to discuss the RBs. We all see the problem there. At WR we put too much faith in Cooks, who is getting older, guys like Tolbert and Brooks who are unreliable, and the TEs not named Ferguson. Dak is a good, not great QB. He cannot makes the scrap heap we have on offense better, or good enough to beat solid defenses.
On defense, our safeties are mediocre, especially in coverage. Diggs is hit or miss. Lewis is solid, Bland is solid, but Caelen Carson is a rookie getting picked on. He looked good in pre-season but this is the big leagues now. Our secondary is awful in run defense, btw.
The LBs are good enough, not great, but good. The problem is the DL. Phillips is a waste of space which is why the Giants let him go. He can't play. Joseph is old. Mazi is maybe a hair better than Phillips but a huge disappointment. Tyrus Wheat should be on the practice squad. Kneeland is a rookie. Golston is a JAG. The DL is actually a joke.
Put is all together and this team maybe wins 6 games this year.