The_Jackal;1481373 said:
Embrace the hatred but resist the kool-aid.
I really like the priorities of this draft but remain cautiously optimistic about the individual prospects, most of whom, with the exception of Spencer, have legitimate question marks and who are in no way sure bets. Talk about which OL or WR is the odd man out on account of our new draftees, for instance, is a bit premature in my opinion.
B/B- for the time being.
Great post, though.
I'm not drinking the koolaid Jackal. I will be in 2008 if we have a legit shot at Darren McFadden though. I openly admit that now without any shame.
I already want to go to that draft (it's only 361 days from now) and be there for that pick. I asked AdButcher if he wants to go. I told him I might need him to bail me out of jail because my celebration is likely to be illegal in NYC. He said he's going to be in jail with me. Now that's friendship. Hopefully neither his wife nor mine are out shopping and can get to Western Union when we get our one phone calls.
My evaluation of the team was that we needed WR, CB, OL, and DT as well as backup QB. I will be honest, I think Jerry wanted Drew Stanton, QB, Michigan State with the 53 pick and would have settled for Steve Smith, WR, USC. I have my reasons for believing this that I prefer to keep to myself.
When both of those guys were gone he felt it would be better to move back and add some picks. Neither Stanton nor Smith would have been my choice, but I can't say they would be horrible either. The move to the top of the 3rd and the top of the 4th turned out to be James Marten and Isaiah Stanback. I won't blow smoke up anyone's skirt and say these are can't miss prospects. I do like the potential reward more than the potential risk.
As I look back at my Mocks, my evaluations of other people's Mocks, and the "experts" Mocks and see that the Cowboys did not follow those patterns it reminds me of something I've been saying since last year's draft. The Mocks do not EVER get it right. Not mine, not other fans, not the "experts." This is a striking thing to me.
Why don't they get them right? Why don't I get it right? Quite simply because I have no idea what the plans are for Flo, Fergy, TO, both Glenn's, Henry, et al. I think Flo won't be back in 2008. Is this what the team thinks? I have no clue.
I think people grade drafts too closely to what they expected to happen. This is a bad practice. If I were grading this based on what I thought the team should do, I assure you my grade would be lower than the B+ I gave it.
So does that mean I'm drinking the Koolaid? That the team not doing what I think has somehow reassured me that I have no clue what I'm doing and they are right? Oh goodness no. I'm too freaking arrogant to totally prostrate myself before the Cabal at Valley Ranch and genuflect.
It means that before I react, and potentially over-react (I'm damned good at that BTW) that it pays for me to step back away from my own opinions and look at what they tried to do here. In the case of this Draft I actually can see the gameplan. I don't by any wild stretch of the imagination agree with every pick. If I went strictly by my own opinions and emotions for everything, and was close minded to any other options I would grade this Draft a C.
However, I'm not close minded. Last night rather than jump the gun, put the cart in front of the horse, or whine about missing out on Brady Quinn and Robert Meachem (two players I have praised for months) I took the time to read up on the guys we did select. Anything I could find. Most of it was posted here. Some of it wasn't. Some I bookmarked and will post here if I feel the need. Here's what I found out.
Every guy we picked is praised by those around them for their character (very important to me personally), for their work ethic, and for their passion for the game. Each of them is considered a difference maker in some way.
I can process that information and come to a conclusion that is a bit uncomfortable to admit. I don't know everything. So I push my agendas aside and get excited.
That's all you see from me here. My excitement about what this could turn into. It could be better, I truly believe that. If I didn't my grade would be higher.