Top 10?

wesleyc288

Believer
Messages
730
Reaction score
7
My friend and I have a little wager.....the outcome will be determined by votes on this poll......Our question is this..

Is Bill Parcells in the top 10 greatest coaches in N.F.L. History?
 

stealth

Benched
Messages
4,882
Reaction score
0
how could he not be? top 10 is an easy choice there havent been hundreds of great coaches...
 

tomson75

Brain Dead Shill
Messages
16,720
Reaction score
1
without a doubt.

granted he might not be the best at coaching, he might be the most influential coach ever. HOF for sure.
 

AmishCowboy

if you ain't first, you're last
Messages
5,134
Reaction score
569
somewhere in the Bottom around 8,9 or 10 would be right for Bill.
 

baj1dallas

New Member
Messages
6,556
Reaction score
1
George Halas
Paul Brown
Vince Lombardi
Don Shula
Tom Landry
Chuck Knoll
Curly Lambeau
Joe Gibbs
Bill Parcells
John Madden
 

Cowboy4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,189
Reaction score
4,494
I think BP is a great coach, one of the best in the Game today,but not in the Top 10 of all time. There are 21 coaches in the HOF and Bill will be there one day for sure but I don't think he is one of the top 10 of all time. There are some legends that really built this game to where it is today.
 

EMMITTnROY

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,079
Reaction score
6,648
baj1dallas said:
George Halas
Paul Brown
Vince Lombardi
Don Shula
Tom Landry
Chuck Knoll
Curly Lambeau
Joe Gibbs
Bill Parcells
John Madden
these look great.. cant argue with them.. but Bill Walsh has to be in there somewhere..

as for the original question, yes, he is definitely Top 10 of all-time..
 

CooterBrown

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,159
Reaction score
1,262
baj1dallas said:
George Halas
Paul Brown
Vince Lombardi
Don Shula
Tom Landry
Chuck Knoll
Curly Lambeau
Joe Gibbs
Bill Parcells
John Madden

Before reading the responses, I made my own list, just to see where Parcells would be. Yours is close to mine. This is what I came up with, in order:

George Halas (Papa bear coached forever)
Paul Brown (his team was known as the Browns)
Vince Lombardi (Disciplinarian who influenced other coaches and the game.)
Tom Landry (great at making the players fit the scheme)
Don Shula (great at making the scheme fit the players)
Bill Walsh (you can't argue with success)
Joe Gibbs (the enemy, but a good one.)
Chuck Noll (see Walsh comment)
Bill Parcells (still could move up the list)
Dick Vermeil (took a long hiatus and only won one SB, but always builds winners.)
 

dal0789

New Member
Messages
592
Reaction score
0
Yes of course, but I would like all the ppl who voted no to post there opinion on why not. Which is probly never going to happen with an exception of a few.
 

baj1dallas

New Member
Messages
6,556
Reaction score
1
I don't know how I missed Walsh, I did intend to have him on there.

IMO Vermeil, Parcells, and Gibbs are the best coaches of my football lifetime. Vermeil is my favorite and imo underrated.
 

Juke99

...Abbey someone
Messages
22,279
Reaction score
126
I voted "NO" because I can't stand him.

:D

At least I am honest.
 

Juke99

...Abbey someone
Messages
22,279
Reaction score
126
Sarge said:
Good morning sir.

:)


:p:

You do realize this is the longest we've gone without making a snotty comment to eachother, right?

:)
 

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,515
Reaction score
12,529
He's a coach who made his bones in NY, and he deserves that, but he's had his fair share of losing, non-playoff seasons, and hasn't even won Super Bowls with teams from different decades, nor has he been an innovator in football, imo.

I'm not attacking him...though I've never liked him, I'll give him his props, but I say no way in Hell is he top 10.

Just off the top of my head, without even looking at a list to make sure I don't overlook anyone, I'd say George Halas, Paul Brown, Vince Lombardy, Tom Landry, Don Coryell, John Madden, Don Shula, Joe Gibbs, Bill Walsh, Chuck Knoll, Bill Cowher all rank ahead of Parcells in my opinion.

Jimmy Johnson, Bud Grant, Marv Levy get consideration.

But that's just me...there have been many many coaches in the NFL, so not putting Parcells in the freakin' top 10 all time is not a big deal. He won the SB with the same basic team, and has not won another one...being tough and helping teams become something better when they were mired in crap can be done by many good, solid coaches, but it doesn't make you top 10 all time, imo.
 

Concord

Mr. Buckeye
Messages
12,825
Reaction score
119
Juke99 said:
I voted "NO" because I can't stand him.

:D

At least I am honest.

Oh so we're telling the truth huh?

I can't stand him for the way he treats Henson!:D
 
Top