Top 15 Big Board Rankings

I like this opinion, and i'll say 1 more thing what about trading up? If we need to secure a player like Graham or Jeanty and we are wasting our later round picks on flyers...why not secure a dominant force in RD 1 with giving up little capital, possibly next years 3 or 4?
There is no way you'll be able to move up in round one and give up little capital. Let's say to move from 12 to 5 it would mean swapping 1st's plus giving up a second this year and a third next year. I don't think there's anyone in this year's draft worth that. Especially a RB.
 
I get that. But it's still over 3 months before the draft. And a lot can happen between now and then. Getting through the Scouting Combine will shake things up.
It’s reported that there are only 12-14 1st rd grades this draft. It may be a possibility where a luxury pick such as RB and FS are the only 2 left.
 
There is no way you'll be able to move up in round one and give up little capital. Let's say to move from 12 to 5 it would mean swapping 1st's plus giving up a second this year and a third next year. I don't think there's anyone in this year's draft worth that. Especially a RB.
The only way I‘m moving up that high is for QB. Don’t forget the trade down from 10-12 netted a 3rd and Micah.
 
The only way I‘m moving up that high is for QB. Don’t forget the trade down from 10-12 netted a 3rd and Micah.
You mentioned a dominant force and Mason Graham would be the closest description and possibly McMillan. There's no QB worth moving up for and it's pointless to even debate that. This year's draft is overall weak and I'm not sure a lot of teams are going to be willing to deal for the 12th pick. Most years there would be a Parsons or a Donald sitting at 12 or abouts that would draw attention for a deal. But you know it's hard to say what other teams will do and who they target/ fall in love with. Those of us who enjoy the draft process and evaluating players think we have a pretty good idea on who's what and who's not and every year there are surprises, especially with the Cowboys.
 
GgvluwAXsAALQRZ


Ranked my Top 15 prospects last night. I am all for taking prospect #2 Jeanty over Graham, but if MM comes back which he likely will, in what universe do you guys believe we will utilize him the way we need to?

If we are keeping MM as a HC it almost makes sense to trade back and collect extra picks with the needs and lack of depth at WR for his scheme, would love some thoughts on my rankings here.
Some will be mad when the Cowboys get the 2nd ranked player at 12.
 
The issue is we have spent at these positions except CB. DE was a 1st round pick defacto LBer but it has now turned into an EDGE. OT was a 1st round pick 2 years in a row. CB has been picked and paid quite high, although he might not be the same you can say we struck GOLD in cap value by hitting on Daron Bland.

So with a top tier CB, an up and coming CB, 2 1st round OT's and 1 HOF Edge who was drafted as a LBer we've hit on 2 of these players. I'm talking about Micah and Tyler Smith. We have hit on Corner outside of the 1st round as well as OL with Beebee. At some point we need to realize this FO is terrible at evaluating the QB, RB and LBer positions for this team.
. I just don't want a RB in round 1. It's a poor value. We found Pollard in round 4 and Dowdle on the scrap heap. We do fine at RB. It's the easiest position in the NFL to fill.

We have to replace Diggs. Just bc lightening struck once with Deron Bland doesn't mean it is likely to happen again. We need a LB or OT or DE. There is a big difference in picking mid 20's and #12. It's an easier projection and your not having to settle for the 8th OT off the board like we did with Guyton.
 
. I just don't want a RB in round 1. It's a poor value. We found Pollard in round 4 and Dowdle on the scrap heap. We do fine at RB. It's the easiest position in the NFL to fill.

We have to replace Diggs. Just bc lightening struck once with Deron Bland doesn't mean it is likely to happen again. We need a LB or OT or DE. There is a big difference in picking mid 20's and #12. It's an easier projection and your not having to settle for the 8th OT off the board like we did with Guyton.
Both of these OT's have questions. Banks is looking for as a guard instead of a tackle. Campbell is likely the best OT on the board but both of them are not sure things.

OT is a valuable position - I get it, but at some point you need to stop putting premium resources into one position group. DE is deep, but the fall off from Carter to the next DE is real...now let me ask you this. Is it better to take a CB because of position value or sign someone like Jaire Alexander in FA and try to fill this void some other way. I think this is our best option, because RB FA was something last year that won't happen again where the top 3 backs in the league are FA.

If Jeanty and Graham are not on the board, I am taking the next luxury pick as there are only 10 or so first round grades in this draft. Just because we don't value safety does not mean we should pass on Starks at 12 if he is prospected to be the next Troy P.
 
Both of these OT's have questions. Banks is looking for as a guard instead of a tackle. Campbell is likely the best OT on the board but both of them are not sure things.

OT is a valuable position - I get it, but at some point you need to stop putting premium resources into one position group. DE is deep, but the fall off from Carter to the next DE is real...now let me ask you this. Is it better to take a CB because of position value or sign someone like Jaire Alexander in FA and try to fill this void some other way. I think this is our best option, because RB FA was something last year that won't happen again where the top 3 backs in the league are FA.

If Jeanty and Graham are not on the board, I am taking the next luxury pick as there are only 10 or so first round grades in this draft. Just because we don't value safety does not mean we should pass on Starks at 12 if he is prospected to be the next Troy P.
we were spoiled as the first rd picks on OL have been incredible until Guyton. Tyron Smith first year starter will go into the HOF. Martin first year ALL PRO and will go to the HOF. Fredbeard first rd pick and I believe without the illness he would have been in the HOF. Tyler Smith if he stays at Guard has a real shot. And remember until Tyron Smith Jethro never used a first on a O lineman. Then comes Guyton. How that will effect Jethro is hard to tell.
 
Both of these OT's have questions. Banks is looking for as a guard instead of a tackle. Campbell is likely the best OT on the board but both of them are not sure things.

OT is a valuable position - I get it, but at some point you need to stop putting premium resources into one position group. DE is deep, but the fall off from Carter to the next DE is real...now let me ask you this. Is it better to take a CB because of position value or sign someone like Jaire Alexander in FA and try to fill this void some other way. I think this is our best option, because RB FA was something last year that won't happen again where the top 3 backs in the league are FA.

If Jeanty and Graham are not on the board, I am taking the next luxury pick as there are only 10 or so first round grades in this draft. Just because we don't value safety does not mean we should pass on Starks at 12 if he is prospected to be the next Troy P.
Every year , with the exception of Henry , the “best 3 backs in the league “ changes. I’ll take any position at 12 but rb. You talk about a deep DE class, have you seen the rb class? It’s 4 rounds deep.
 
Every year , with the exception of Henry , the “best 3 backs in the league “ changes. I’ll take any position at 12 but rb. You talk about a deep DE class, have you seen the rb class? It’s 4 rounds deep.
The drop off from Edge in round 1 to round 3 is significantly higher than RB. Although I don’t see all these rookies from 2023 massively contributing. It’s because they aren’t workhorse backs.

Would you rather have an edge who can impact the game with 1 sack per game potentially in year 1 or a back who can consistently grind out 20-25 carries for 100 yards with big play ability. Unless we get carter all of these OTs and DEs have massive question marks
 
The drop off from Edge in round 1 to round 3 is significantly higher than RB. Although I don’t see all these rookies from 2023 massively contributing. It’s because they aren’t workhorse backs.

Would you rather have an edge who can impact the game with 1 sack per game potentially in year 1 or a back who can consistently grind out 20-25 carries for 100 yards with big play ability. Unless we get carter all of these OTs and DEs have massive question marks
Bucky Irving was a 4th round rookie rb who had 1500 yards from scrimmage for Tampa. Huge impact player.

Every guy has a "massive question mark" until they get on the field and show what they can do against NFL competition. There are impact rookies every year. This year you had guys like Joe Alt, Brock Bowers, Cooper Dejean, Jared Verse, Bucky Irving, Edgerinn Cooper......... I have high hopes for the 12th pick. RB is just wasting it.
 
Bucky Irving was a 4th round rookie rb who had 1500 yards from scrimmage for Tampa. Huge impact player.

Every guy has a "massive question mark" until they get on the field and show what they can do against NFL competition. There are impact rookies every year. This year you had guys like Joe Alt, Brock Bowers, Cooper Dejean, Jared Verse, Bucky Irving, Edgerinn Cooper......... I have high hopes for the 12th pick. RB is just wasting it.
This is like saying drafting Zeke was a waste, he directly impacted the W column significantly and didn’t fall off until year 4.

Second contract sure, but Zeke his first 4 years was a beast.
 
I’m going to do my first video on Will Johnson - seems like people want to replace Diggs badly and CB may be available at 12. @atlantacowboy would CB fit your position priority and value?
 
I just don't want a RB in round 1. It's a poor value. We found Pollard in round 4 and Dowdle on the scrap heap. We do fine at RB. It's the easiest position in the NFL to fill.
100% on board with this.

There are plenty of good RB's on day 2 and this year, potentially early day 3.
 
This is like saying drafting Zeke was a waste, he directly impacted the W column significantly and didn’t fall off until year 4.

Second contract sure, but Zeke his first 4 years was a beast.
Oh, you want to play the hindsight game? ok. Drafting Zeke was a waste bc we could have filled that spot in round 2 with Derrick Henry.

We were bad the year before b/c Romo got injured in 2015 and we let Demarco Murray (reigning offensive MVP) walk. Sure Zeke gave us a boost but it amounted to nothing. Zeke lasted 4 seasons and was done. We would have been better off drafting Jalen Ramsey or Ronnie Stanley or Jack Conklin. Heck even Deforrest Buckner has had a better career than Zeke.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
464,267
Messages
13,801,757
Members
23,776
Latest member
saturdaysarebetter
Back
Top