- Messages
- 61,982
- Reaction score
- 63,112
Bold> Plaxico Burress was arguably a great receiver. I would not dismiss him as a good example of Eli Manning's 'great receivers'.Thats exactly how eli succeeded. Well along with a good team too.
Eli heaved it up in a way that allowed his great receivers to go get it. I sont remember a lot of tight windows...just opportunities.
On the other hand, David Tyree was simply a good receiver. Tyree made one of the best catches any receiver has ever made at the professional, college or even high school level--and in the Super Bowl.
Tyree is one reason why I will always say luck can play a part in achieving success, even if it is a tiny part. That guy trapped the ball, on top of his helmet, primarily with ONE hand, while jumping and during a fairly tough tackle. The greatest wide receivers may not have made that catch. Tyree himself may have not made that same catch if he had attempted it multiple times.
"Big time players make big time plays." In that moment, Tyree was a big time player but greatest? I would disagree. However, I think my little rant is being motivated somewhat by pointing out it takes two to complete any catchable pass.
It is why I believe most quarterbacks are often OVERLY criticized (not saying you though) for incomplete catchable passes. Manning received more glory in that moment, after escaping a sack and heaving the ball, than Tyree. It is still true to this day. What would have been the reaction to Manning if Tyree had dropped that heave--despite the difficulty in hauling it in?
Click here for Tyree's catch.
lol. We will never know.