Way 'nuff said:
I'll believe you if you can show me where the 49ers violated the cap.
NFL Fines Former 49ers Executive $400,00 for Salary Cap Violations
Lenient penalty results in criticism by owners
New York, December 7, 2000 - Giants co-owner, Wellington Mara, spoke out in anger over the settlement that the NFL reached with former 49ers executives Carmen Policy and Dwight Clark over their alleged violation of the salary cap in 1997. Under the terms of the deal, Policy was fined $400,000 and Clark was fined $200,000. The 49ers will also have to pay a $300,000 fine and give up a 5th round draft choice in 2001 and a 3rd round choice in 2002.
Mara apparently became upset after Policy refused to admit any wrongdoing in the matter. Mara has since accused Policy of lying to the NFL Management Council Executive Committee about the allegations. Mara issued a statement in which he said, "of all those present, not one believed what [Policy] said." Mara added that the group then agreed that Policy "should give a deposition under oath as soon as possible," but Policy "declined to be sworn in and instead began negotiating the settlement,." according to Long Island Newsday.
Others weighed in on the situation in varying degrees of agreement with Mara and also thought the settlement let the 49ers off too easy. New Orleans Saints' Owner Tom Benson, on the settlement: "It's good that we're going to get a lot stricter on this stuff, but I wish we'd had a policy in place that would have made this ruling stiffer ... But the new agreement [giving the commissioner broad powers] should be a deterrent. At least I hope it is." Another NFL team owner was quoted as saying, "I think they (Policy and Clark) got away with murder."
National Football League Players' Association Executive Director Gene Upshaw said, "I don't think (the 49ers) got off light . . . The other owners around the league will make a lot of noise, but they've got to look at what was there. They might have wanted more authority from the commissioner, but it wasn't there,"
In comparison with the NBA's recent actions against the Minnesota Timberwolves, the NFL action is quite light and, in a typical settlement-type agreement, stipulated that neither Policy or Clark admit to any wrongdoing.
In addition to the penalties levied against the 49ers and their former executives, agents Leigh Steinberg, Jeff Moorad and Gary Wichard, who represented quarterback Jim Druckenmiller, linebacker Woodall, quarterback Steve Young and tight end Brent Jones, received "substantial" fines. It was reported that Steinberg, who represented Young and Jones, will pay a fine of $250,000, while Wichard, who represented Druckenmiller, will pay $100,000. The money is "going to league and union designated charities."
Nate Allen