gazmc_06;1555179 said:
I never even noticed this thread, a large part of my family are from the UK (not me obviously) so soccer is pretty big, we don't have the same amount of commitment to it over here which is the problem. people in other countries start playing at 2 and 3, we don't bother usually at all but if we do it's usually about 6 or 7 years old which is a pretty big gap.
anyway moving on.... Adu is not an elite player IMO, you look at the young talent being produced in other places, Ronaldo, Messi, Robinho, Quaresma...there is a huge gap between their ability and Adu's.
Soccer is getting bigger in the US. It just grows at such a slow pace. Nothing is going to speed that up, but I do see it growing. It is bigger now than when I was a kid.
I don't think the US is close to competing on the international level. Even though it is growing it is just so far behind.
Good points about the age at which kids start playing soccer. It does not stop there. Once kids start getting older they often have less options until they get to high school. They have to play club soccer that costs some money. Not every kid as the chance to play because of money.
I know in Texas when I was growing up there weren't a large number of high school teams. It has grown since then and some schools and areas also have junior high teams as well. Still not near the same number of junior highs that have football and basketball.
Then there is college. There are only two colleges in Texas that have a men's soccer team. That isn't representative of college soccer in other states, but with the population of Texas you would expect more than two options. So if a kid grows up in Texas and wants to stay close to home and play soccer he doesn't have many options. If you love the game you will just play, but some kids like to do both live in state and play soccer. It happens in college football all the time. Kids choose a college because it is close to home.
The percentage of kids that love soccer is way less than those that love football, basketball or baseball. That will always be the case in the U.S. The percentage is going up, but it will lag the other sports.
Now if you just take the kids that love soccer and give them less options growing up to play the game you then end up with fewer elite players. In football, they have so many options that a larger percentage are retained as they grow up.