News: Vela: The Cowboys Camp Orlando Scandrick Conundrum

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,017
Reaction score
22,609
The Cowboys Camp Orlando Scandrick Conundrum
Rafael Vela
http://cowboyszone.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/25/2014/07/176.jpg
http://cowboyszone.com/2014/07/the-cowboys-camp-orlando-scandrick-conundrum.html

Let”s file this issue under the heading “good problems.” To the casual observer, any 2014 improvement by the maligned Cowboys defense would have to come from the back. The team’s biggest investments are in the secondary, where high 1st rounder Morris Claiborne and high-ticket free agent Brandon Carr play.

Between them should be nickel corner Orlando Scandrick. These three provide the best potential to lead by example.

Scandrick has upset this plan a bit, but in a good way. He has outplayed his bigger name counterparts in the last year and has continued his strong play into this year’s camp. With Carr absent, due to family matter, Scandrick has established himself at left corner. This a year after locking down the right corner spot while Claiborne battled a chronic shoulder injury.

Scandrick has created the kind of problem coaching staffs love. When Carr returns, where will Scandrick play? It’s clear he needs to be somewhere, but if the team leaves him at left corner, it’s parking one of its biggest contracts on the bench when the Cowboys are in their base defense. That’s a poor return on the Carr investment.

They would not want to shoe-horn Scandrick back into the right corner slot when Carr returns, not when Claiborne appears to be making a push in this critical third year...
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Not much of a conundrum. Scandrick is probably the best player on our defense right now. Play the best two guys and bring the next-best guy off the bench when you need him.

I have to say, I am intrigued with the idea of letting Scandrick play deep-middle in a few packages, though. I bet he could do it, and do it well.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,017
Reaction score
22,609
And a center field is the biggest need of the current 4-3. Sounds interesting to this fan, for sure.
 

The Natural

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,205
Reaction score
18,969
Was never a fan of his size (please save me the player comparisons) or ball skills as a #1 CB. However he was a pleasant surprise last year, I agree throw the two best out there
 

silver

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,874
Reaction score
1,698
We play nickle most of the time so all three corners see about the same playing time. Hopefully Claiborne can sustain a 16 game schedule without getting hurt or torched and this would not be an issue and we wont have to see Webb or Mitchell out there. History says otherwise though.
 

BigStar

Stop chasing
Messages
11,528
Reaction score
17,081
It seems the only thing holding this up is Carr's contract, which the team can cut bait on next off season. Stick with Carr, or pay Claiborne, or neither (not likely). Scandrick should start and not "nickle" start. The battle should be between those two.
 

noshame

I'm not dead yet......
Messages
14,944
Reaction score
13,432
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Good Lord, it's not like we haven't had injury issues, lets get past the first week of camp before we worry about overcrowding:confused:
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
34,316
Reaction score
19,714
The Cowboys Camp Orlando Scandrick Conundrum
Rafael Vela
http://cowboyszone.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/25/2014/07/176.jpg
http://cowboyszone.com/2014/07/the-cowboys-camp-orlando-scandrick-conundrum.html

Let”s file this issue under the heading “good problems.” To the casual observer, any 2014 improvement by the maligned Cowboys defense would have to come from the back. The team’s biggest investments are in the secondary, where high 1st rounder Morris Claiborne and high-ticket free agent Brandon Carr play.

Between them should be nickel corner Orlando Scandrick. These three provide the best potential to lead by example.

Scandrick has upset this plan a bit, but in a good way. He has outplayed his bigger name counterparts in the last year and has continued his strong play into this year’s camp. With Carr absent, due to family matter, Scandrick has established himself at left corner. This a year after locking down the right corner spot while Claiborne battled a chronic shoulder injury.

Scandrick has created the kind of problem coaching staffs love. When Carr returns, where will Scandrick play? It’s clear he needs to be somewhere, but if the team leaves him at left corner, it’s parking one of its biggest contracts on the bench when the Cowboys are in their base defense. That’s a poor return on the Carr investment.

They would not want to shoe-horn Scandrick back into the right corner slot when Carr returns, not when Claiborne appears to be making a push in this critical third year...

its not about investment. parcells use to say, play the best guy regardless of draft status, contract, etc. so that's what you do. swallow your pride, put his arse on the bench, make him into a slot corner and cut his arse next year and move on.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,017
Reaction score
22,609
its not about investment. parcells use to say, play the best guy regardless of draft status, contract, etc. so that's what you do. swallow your pride, put his arse on the bench, make him into a slot corner and cut his arse next year and move on.

I doubt that anyone who invests regularly in describing accomplishment and successes is too invested in a single item carrying that battle field of opinion. Investment price lost often tells a tale as well...and taking notes along a journey's path, often proves beneficial.
 

JonJon

Injured Reserve
Messages
11,262
Reaction score
733
If Scandrick is the best out there then play him. I don't care how much Carr is making; if he can't prove to be better than Scandrick or Claiborne, then put him on the bench. We are trying to win games, not save face with past investments.
 

SilverStarCowboy

The Actualist
Messages
10,337
Reaction score
1,998
If Scandrick is the best out there then play him. I don't care how much Carr is making; if he can't prove to be better than Scandrick or Claiborne, then put him on the bench. We are trying to win games, not save face with past investments.

This we thing excludes Jerruh.
 

daveferr33

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,192
Reaction score
2,257
Vela is correct. Its a good problem to have and he is not suggesting otherwise. Just play the best player.

On a different note, this is perfect example of why regularly restructuring contracts forecloses options in the future. We saw this with Romo and this team's inability (despite Jerry's professed love affair with a certain qb) to draft a qb high. Likewise, We've restructured the Carr contract multiple times and that leaves the team with little flexibility. Wouldn't it be nice, if the team were to find him expendable, to be able to flip him from some D-Line or linebacker help at this point? But that option is effectively off the table because of the multiple restructures.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
34,316
Reaction score
19,714
I doubt that anyone who invests regularly in describing accomplishment and successes is too invested in a single item carrying that battle field of opinion. Investment price lost often tells a tale as well...and taking notes along a journey's path, often proves beneficial.

yes, the note (lesson learned) is truly evaluate where the team is. truly evaluate what a player is. and make the right investment. smart money say move on and don't get emotionally involved.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,017
Reaction score
22,609
yes, the note (lesson learned) is truly evaluate where the team is. truly evaluate what a player is. and make the right investment. smart money say move on and don't get emotionally involved.

I'm not diverting here, as progression achieved from realistic after action evaluations has helped Jerry, Jason, and the team as a whole.

It is part of a process that gives the best chances for success.

Eventual records don't tell the whole story, but success is tied directly to the process.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Not much of a conundrum. Scandrick is probably the best player on our defense right now. Play the best two guys and bring the next-best guy off the bench when you need him.

I have to say, I am intrigued with the idea of letting Scandrick play deep-middle in a few packages, though. I bet he could do it, and do it well.

It's not a conundrum at all. Scandrick took significantly less money than he could've gotten to stay in Dallas (where he wants to stay his entire career) and enjoys his role on the team and enjoys living in Dallas with his family.

This is a non-story and an attempt to make a story. He did acknowledge that it's a "good problem to have" but it's not even really a problem.
 

Frozen700

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,512
Reaction score
6,475
It's not a conundrum at all. Scandrick took significantly less money than he could've gotten to stay in Dallas (where he wants to stay his entire career) and enjoys his role on the team and enjoys living in Dallas with his family.

This is a non-story and an attempt to make a story. He did acknowledge that it's a "good problem to have" but it's not even really a problem.

Lover your Sig. Some one should bring that up to him.

Anyways, Carr always balls out in camp, and has done good for us. He is dealing with family issues, so I don't think this should be held against him.

With that being said, if anybody should be coming off the bench it's MO. This is the problem with people getting to hyped, just like Madden giving Wilson the same rating as Tom Brady, just because he won the SB.

MO has been our weak link in the secondary for some time, what, he comes back starts camp out doing good, now he should just have his starting role back and all should be forgotten?

Camp just started, and we haven't even seen him in pre season action, the first time he gets dusted people will jump off the hype machine and start calling him a bust. Even though i don't think he is, but that's how it usually goes around here.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Lover your Sig. Some one should bring that up to him.

Anyways, Carr always balls out in camp, and has done good for us. He is dealing with family issues, so I don't think this should be held against him.

With that being said, if anybody should be coming off the bench it's MO. This is the problem with people getting to hyped, just like Madden giving Wilson the same rating as Tom Brady, just because he won the SB.

MO has been our weak link in the secondary for some time, what, he comes back starts camp out doing good, now he should just have his starting role back and all should be forgotten?

Camp just started, and we haven't even seen him in pre season action, the first time he gets dusted people will jump off the hype machine and start calling him a bust. Even though i don't think he is, but that's how it usually goes around here.

lol I just changed my sig...whoops.
 
Top