Gallery is a huge bust. 2nd overall pick and he's easily been one of the 3 worst offensive tackles in the league since he's been in the league. Now the Raiders may move him to guard and his future there as a starter is uncertain.
Taylor has lead all safeties in TD's allowed in 2004 and 2006. He's only played 3 years. He looked good in 2005, but if it was just about any other safety in the league that didn't get the occasional highlight reels with his occasional big hits (Taylor also led the league in missed tackles last season with 19), he'd be considered a pretty bad safety.
Hell, Roy Williams' pass stat numbers over the past 4 years are far better than Taylor's have been in the past 3 seasons and he's usually considered as a terrible cover guy and horribly overrated (and Roy forces much more turnovers)
When a guy like Taylor is a former 6th overall pick and has pass defense numbers that are that bad (especially in an important stat like TD's allowed) and misses that many tackles, it's probably safe to start thinking he could be a bust if he doesn't get things turned around.
YAKUZA
remembers Art over on ES calling Newman a bust despite statistically being a top 10 corner in 2004, yet Taylor is some supposed superstar