I thought at the time it stank of Garrett, but then why didn't Moore bring play action back when Garrett was gone?
I guess if we're going to believe McCarthy, he was putting pressure on Moore to run and run and run again. I like running too, but the play action was just working. And I think it made the run game work better too. You gotta stay on the field to grind down the opposing defense.
I remember just some awful games that season where they just kept running and running and running on 1st down despite getting no production out of it.
All in all, the McCarthy + Moore team up ended up a big disappointment for me. Each brought so much, and I thought it would be great to combine the two. Instead, Moore morphed into Garrett, while McCarthy seemed to pull a "don't blame me, not my offense", like he's just biding his time until Moore fails.
The real worry is that the 4 Stick Routes staple of Garrett and Moore may have been dictated by their lack of confidence that Dak could handle more, or at least could do so reliably.
The other problem with Dak is that now that he's cut way down on running, a big part of his game is gone. He's not Dan Fouts or Dan Marino. Dak has always been up and down, but he's mainly been down since the ankle injury. Not the same QB.