What if Eric berry was in this class...?

[CanuckCowboysFan]

Dez Bryant scouting report, I think your looking at his prospects a lil too happy eyed. He was a great prospect, but he had some big flaws.

and at this point, Mike Williams would be going #3 over Dez to the team that has him if the draft was re-done if they went WR. Would be foolish for TB to take Dez over Mike Williams in a redraft

No, he wouldn't. If you think Williams is better then Dez, I'm sorry but you have some issues.

And please, don't tell me his stats. I know them.

In almost all 2010 re-do drafts, Dez is going top 10, some even top 5.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

You got yourself a horrible scouting report. Which has already been proven wrong.

Dez wasn't quite the superman prospect everyone here loves to make him out to be.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

No, he wouldn't. If you think Williams is better then Dez, I'm sorry but you have some issues.

And please, don't tell me his stats. I know them.

In almost all 2010 re-do drafts, Dez is going top 10, some even top 10.

I didn't say that, I said TAMPA would take Mike Williams over Dez. The team with Mike Williams now? Tampa.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Source?

Off the top of my head Scott Wright, Bill Simmons, Mike Francesa. Kind of an obscure point for 3 totally separate people make. Thats how scary Dez is

And looking at the list of 2010 draftees #3 sounds about right. 1.Bradford 2.Suh 3.Dez

http://www.draftcountdown.com/archive/2010/2010-Top-Overall.php

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Off the top of my head Scott Wright, Bill Simmons, Mike Francesa. Kind of an obscure point for 3 totally separate people make. Thats how scary Dez is

And looking at the list of 2010 draftees #3 sounds about right. 1.Bradford 2.Suh 3.Dez

http://www.draftcountdown.com/archive/2010/2010-Top-Overall.php

Never seen Scott Wright do a re-draft 2010 with Dez at #3.

 

[CanuckCowboysFan]

I didn't say that, I said TAMPA would take Mike Williams over Dez. The team with Mike Williams now? Tampa.

No, they would not. If they saw what Dez did this year, they'd take him 3rd.

if Dez was on Tampa, and got as many snaps as Mile Williams did, and be the only legitimate target, he'd have 1300+ yards.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

No, they would not. If they saw what Dez did this year, they'd take him 3rd.

if Dez was on Tampa, and got as many snaps as Mile Williams did, and be the only legitimate target, he'd have 1300+ yards.

 

[CanuckCowboysFan]

Coming from the laughing stock of the site... yeah. Truth hurts.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Coming from the laughing stock of the site... yeah. Truth hurts.

Wouldn't be close to 1,300 yards but alrite bro. I can be the laughing stock, atleast im not making ridiculous claims, just unpopular ones.

 

[texbumthelife]

If he had been healthy, Dez would have been near 1300 yards here so I don't think it's that big of a stretch.

 

[dbair1967]

Any draftnik/scout would agree with Green>Jones>Bryant. Not like im making some outrageous statement.

It isnt outrageous, its just damn stupid.

Not sure why your such a ****** when it comes to Dez Bryant.

 

[DFWJC]

Charles Rogers, Andre Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald, and Calvin Johnson were all better prospects than AJ Green.

The fact that Charles Rodgers is on that list tells us how flawed "great prospect" prognostication can be.

Maybe the better way to to put it was to say that he was "falsely a better prospect"...or maybe a "supposedly great prospect". Because in the end, he was in fact not a great prospect.

They just miss badly sometimes. Gholsten is another recent example. It's yet another great reason to always remember not to fall completely in love with a prospect and give up the farm for him.

Then again, maybe Green turns out to be one of those too. I seriously doubt it, but it happens every year.

 

[jwitten82]

Any draftnik/scout would agree with Green>Jones>Bryant. Not like im making some outrageous statement.

Jones is not better than Bryant

 

[Cover 2]

The fact that Charles Rodgers is on that list tells us how flawed "great prospect" prognostication can be.

Maybe the better way to to put it was to say that he was "falsely a better prospect"...or maybe a "supposedly great prospect". Because in the end, he was in fact not a great prospect.

They just miss badly sometimes. Gholsten is another recent example. It's yet another great reason to always remember not to fall completely in love with a prospect and give up the farm for him.

Then again, maybe Green turns out to be one of those too. I seriously doubt it, but it happens every year.

That's why interviews and looking into their background are important. I believe Charles Rogers was the most physically gifted of all those players besides maybe Calvin Johnson, but he was lazy and injury prone. He had two TD's his very first game. He also lacked discipline by ballooning up, and placing pot above becoming great.

I was never sold on Gholston tbh.

And you're right. No matter how great a prospect looks, it's no guarantee of success.

 

[Dmoore Esq]

That's why interviews and looking into their background are important. I believe Charles Rogers was the most physically gifted of all those players besides maybe Calvin Johnson, but he was lazy and injury prone. He had two TD's his very first game. He also lacked discipline by ballooning up, and placing pot above becoming great.

I was never sold on Gholston tbh.

And you're right. No matter how great a prospect looks, it's no guarantee of success.

He also had some tough luck injuries that really hurt him. I'm a MSU fan, and he was so dominate. Those were good years, going from Plaxico to Rogers. Exciting football.

I like Dez and I think both Green and Jones have tremendous potential. I haven't seen anything from either of them to say they're better than Dez. Can't use where they are on draft lists to compare them. Last year was a much better draft class.

 

[locked&loaded]

Yea, can someone make R2A's argument for him?

..lol

 

[locked&loaded]

Source?

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/548771-lets-try-that-again-a-2010-nfl-re-draft#page/6

5th overall

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2010/writers/don_banks/12/16/2010-nfl-draft-redux/index.html

8th

http://www.***BANNED-URL***/incomin...nfl-draft-cowboys_dez-bryant-a-top-5-pick.ece

top 5

But really this is getting ridiculous. Are people really arguing that Green is 10x the prospect Dez was? Clearly people don't watch the whole game; but instead just have an angle concentrated on Miles Austins *** the whole game.

 

[JPM]

It isnt outrageous, its just damn stupid.

Not sure why your such a ****** when it comes to Dez Bryant.

When you have an agenda you stick to it no matter what. It's Nors-like with him.

 

[casmith07]

No, not close.

This is why you get ganged up on in threads. Moronic opinion, at best.

 

[Dough Boy]

AJ Green >>>> Miles Autsin