I certainly can be wrong about a prospect not being good, but the truth is, I’m simply not a big fan of Rice. He is supposed to be a contested catch, strength, high-point type of receiver, with concerns about his athleticism.
SMU listed him at 6-2, 205 pounds but when he got to the Senior Bowl, he measured at 6-0, 200 pounds. A couple inches is not that big of a deal, some might say… but when your only real attribute is being a big, strong guy who is going to take away the ball from the defender… that two inches is very important to that type of player.
But that isn’t my only issues with him. Probably the best defense that he faced all season was Cinncinati - a game that he was terrible in. He had drops (plural) in that game, he had problems getting off of the line of scrimmage in that game. He looked terrible. Against Tulane and UCF he looked good… but he was going against guys that won’t be sniffing the NFL in those contests.
Finally, some of the people that I trust in their evaluations see him similarly to what I do, and don’t have him listed in their top 10 WR’s. He just really hasn’t impressed me at all.
Now, maybe he goes to Indy and completely changes my view of his athleticism - which is one of my bigger problems with him - but it would surprise me because he just doesn’t appear to have it when I watch him play. If he proves that he is more athletic than I’m thinking, then maybe my view will change, but for now, he’s a big, strong 50/50 possession receiver who really isn’t big, and lacks athleticism. I just don’t think he will be that good, which is ultimately why I mentioned that I didn’t like the pick in your mock. There are just a lot of other WR’s that I’d rather have on the Cowboys.
So, right or wrong, that’s my take on him. I’m sure I’ll watch some more of his tape, so nothing is written in stone this far out from the draft. I’m not one of those guys that will defend his take to the death… I have no problem saying that I was wrong if he changes my mind.