What would be your grade on our Rookies thus far?

[Coogiguy03]

Excellent Forrest Gump manglage

please don't ever reference my manglage again, this is a Cowboys site!! lol

 

[Typhus]

well he can only be great with time, everyone on here says he needs 3 years or more and that's when DT's can develop

Mazi is going to be just fine.

 

[Bobhaze]

On 2nd cup of coffee.
Had 4 beers between 7 and 11 last night though.

Living the dream.

 

[Mikexike]

Guyton-C+
Kneeland-B
Liaufau-C
Beebee-B
Carson-C
Flournoy-incomplete

 

[MapleLeaf]

Guyton: C
Kneeland: B-
Beebe: B
Liaufau: C
Carson: C-
Flournoy: INCOMPLETE

It‘s only been 4 games. I expect these grades to change quite a bit over the coming weeks. In fairness to all these rooks, they were thrown into the fire immediately and have done about as well as could be expected. Very, very few NFL rookies are just plug and play. All these rookies need developmental patience.

It's going to be a long year because many of our first and second year players are still learning the game of football at the NFL level.

My suggestion to Cowboys fans is to strap on your britches. It's gonna be a rough ride.

 

[charron]

Guyton-D
Beebee- B
Kneeland-C+ I think after today he will be a B to B+ I just need to see more reps.
Liaufu-C
Carson-C+ keep in mind this kid was never supposed to play this year. He has some issues as expected but has been a pleasant surprise.

 

[TequilaCowboy]

They all look like rookies and are playing like them. Beebe is the only one who may be exceeding expectations. I’d give him a solid B. Rest of them in the range of C- to D+.

 

[Mr_437]

Guyton - F
Kneeland - B
Liafau - C+
Beebe - B
Carson - D
Flournoy - N/A

 

[Chasing6]

This is probably the 1st season in a long time if ever, that we've had so many rookies play this early in the season. I know it's early (duh), but we've actually needed them to play because we were all-in, and didn't have the money to get veterans to help us. With that said, of the guys getting ample time in games, what would be your grade for them thus far.

Guyton
Kneeland
Liaufau
Beebee
Carson
Flournoy***
***We'll see what he has to offer this Sunday evening. Please give your grades on the players thus far, dang Coog it's only been 4 games!! Please give your thoughts...

4th year rookie Trance gets an F-.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

This is probably the 1st season in a long time if ever, that we've had so many rookies play this early in the season. I know it's early (duh), but we've actually needed them to play because we were all-in, and didn't have the money to get veterans to help us. With that said, of the guys getting ample time in games, what would be your grade for them thus far.

Guyton
Kneeland
Liaufau
Beebee
Carson
Flournoy***
***We'll see what he has to offer this Sunday evening. Please give your grades on the players thus far, dang Coog it's only been 4 games!! Please give your thoughts...

Guyton - D minus
Kneeland - C+
Liaufau = C
Beebee - B+
Carson - C-