What would our record be with Bledsoe or Carter?

sacowboysfan513

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,998
Reaction score
44
dbair1967;1826043 said:
please dont start with this non sense again

1) Carter sux as a QB...we didnt win because of him, we won in spite of him

2) that team in general was a fluke

if he played here now, Garrett would have to really reign in the offense because Q-Bong was so dumb and so inaccurate...we'd get killed throwing as much as we do now with somebody like him trying to throw...we're 12-1 because we have a great QB that runs a great passing game...Carter is not 1/3 the player Romo is, and never would have been

David

Truth be told, I don't think Carter was 1/8 the player that Romo is. But thats not the discussion. And besides, with players like Owens/Witten/Crayton/and Barber, they can make a lot of QB's look good. Yes, even Crayton.

I never said Carter was great, or even good. But I could see this team win about 11 games "in spite" of Carter.

This is not a bad team with a good qb. This is a good team with a great QB.
 

sago1

Active Member
Messages
7,791
Reaction score
0
I don't see QB as an option in this discussion. Isn't he in rehab again for the 4th or 5th time? There's no way we win anything with either Bledsoe or QB. Bledsoe was benched because he no longer the accurate QB he had been in 05 & QB wasn't stable enough to be the poster boy of the Cowboys. Move on.
 

Mavs Man

All outta bubble gum
Messages
4,672
Reaction score
0
All that matters is that we never have to worry about answering that question.
 

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,846
Reaction score
16,869
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
It's time to break out the old Carter poem...:cool:




(To the tune of "Casey at the Bat")

The outlook wasn't brilliant for the Dallas offense that day,
The score stood seventeen to fourteen with two minutes left to play,
And when Johnson dropped an errant pass, and Glenn dropped one, too,
Quincy's fans cried "Conspiracy!", while his critics could do naught but boo,

The crowd steadily dwindled, but those who remained,
Prayed for a miracle, a freak thunderstorm with rain,
They thought, "If only Troy or Roger were here to take control,"
They had no faith in the offense with Quincy running the show,

But Troy was in Foxboro, watching the Pats play in the snow,
Roger was running his business and watching his money grow,
So upon the remaining crowd, the pall of despair descended,
For there seemed little chance of scoring so long as the other team defended,

But Jones broke a long run, and the crowd gave a sigh,
Then Keyshawn snagged an out, though it was thrown a little high,
And when the offense huddled, and the refs had spotted the ball,
The Cowboys were past the fifty, to the amazement of all,

Then from the remaining partisans, there rose tumultous cheers,
It rumbled through Texas Stadium, and roared in Quincy's ears,
It made his spirit soar, and it made his heart pound,
He took his place among the other greats that had also heard this sound,

Now his faced looked calm, and as he bent to take the snap,
He saw the cornerbacks playing tight, and tackles playing the gap,
He saw the linebackers playing man under, and the safeties in cover two,
He saw Glenn in the slot, and he knew what he had to do,

Quincy gave a hard count, and the center snapped on three,
A quick playaction to Jones, and Glenn was running free,
Quincy wound his mighty arm and let the football fly,
It sailed over Glenn's head, about five feet too high,

"Kill him! Kill Terry Glenn," cried Quincy's loyal fan base,
And they likely would have killed him but for the look on Quincy's face,
With a quick pat to his own chest and a friendly slap to Glenn's head,
Quincy took the blame even though his critics were seeing red,

With a deprecating smile of humility, Quincy's visage beamed,
And his fans knew he was not at fault, but had taken one for the team,
And as he stepped back under center, with Keyshawn to his right,
His fans remained certain that there would be a victory party that night,

The center hiked the ball, and Quincy dropped back,
Keyshawn split the seam, and exploded through the crack,
He was streaking down the field, the corner was far behind,
But Quincy dumped it in the flat to Anderson, the only receiver he could find,

"Coslet!" screeched Quincy's loyal fans, too angered to clearly see,
That Mo was in the booth because Coslet was fired in Oh-Three,
But Quincy raised his hands for quiet, and his fans applauded his aplomb,
They knew that on third and nine, Quincy would finally launch a bomb,

Quincy lined up in the shotgun, with Glenn and Johnson split wide,
Witten was lined up on Quincy's left, and Jones was at his side,
The ball was snapped on a silent count as soon as the ref blew his whistle,
Glenn and Johnson streaked downfield, and Quincy launched a missile,

Oh, somewhere in the state of Texas, there must be a happy crowd,
Somewhere fans are cheering, somewhere they are proud,
Somewhere a team has a victory, and well-earned accolades are accepted,
But that somewhere isn't Dallas, because Quincy's pass was intercepted.

 

silverbear

Semi-Official Loose Cannon
Messages
24,195
Reaction score
25
We'd undoubtedly be 0-13 with Bledsoe at the helm...

But we'd be 13-0 with the legend that is Quincy Carter at the helm... unless he got his hands on some killer bud the night before one of those games... you know, like the "Reindeer" or the "Frankenstein" that Dante was selling in Grandma's Boy...
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
5Stars;1826157 said:
It's time to break out the old Carter poem...:cool:




(To the tune of "Casey at the Bat")

The outlook wasn't brilliant for the Dallas offense that day,
The score stood seventeen to fourteen with two minutes left to play,
And when Johnson dropped an errant pass, and Glenn dropped one, too,
Quincy's fans cried "Conspiracy!", while his critics could do naught but boo,

The crowd steadily dwindled, but those who remained,
Prayed for a miracle, a freak thunderstorm with rain,
They thought, "If only Troy or Roger were here to take control,"
They had no faith in the offense with Quincy running the show,

But Troy was in Foxboro, watching the Pats play in the snow,
Roger was running his business and watching his money grow,
So upon the remaining crowd, the pall of despair descended,
For there seemed little chance of scoring so long as the other team defended,

But Jones broke a long run, and the crowd gave a sigh,
Then Keyshawn snagged an out, though it was thrown a little high,
And when the offense huddled, and the refs had spotted the ball,
The Cowboys were past the fifty, to the amazement of all,

Then from the remaining partisans, there rose tumultous cheers,
It rumbled through Texas Stadium, and roared in Quincy's ears,
It made his spirit soar, and it made his heart pound,
He took his place among the other greats that had also heard this sound,

Now his faced looked calm, and as he bent to take the snap,
He saw the cornerbacks playing tight, and tackles playing the gap,
He saw the linebackers playing man under, and the safeties in cover two,
He saw Glenn in the slot, and he knew what he had to do,

Quincy gave a hard count, and the center snapped on three,
A quick playaction to Jones, and Glenn was running free,
Quincy wound his mighty arm and let the football fly,
It sailed over Glenn's head, about five feet too high,

"Kill him! Kill Terry Glenn," cried Quincy's loyal fan base,
And they likely would have killed him but for the look on Quincy's face,
With a quick pat to his own chest and a friendly slap to Glenn's head,
Quincy took the blame even though his critics were seeing red,

With a deprecating smile of humility, Quincy's visage beamed,
And his fans knew he was not at fault, but had taken one for the team,
And as he stepped back under center, with Keyshawn to his right,
His fans remained certain that there would be a victory party that night,

The center hiked the ball, and Quincy dropped back,
Keyshawn split the seam, and exploded through the crack,
He was streaking down the field, the corner was far behind,
But Quincy dumped it in the flat to Anderson, the only receiver he could find,

"Coslet!" screeched Quincy's loyal fans, too angered to clearly see,
That Mo was in the booth because Coslet was fired in Oh-Three,
But Quincy raised his hands for quiet, and his fans applauded his aplomb,
They knew that on third and nine, Quincy would finally launch a bomb,

Quincy lined up in the shotgun, with Glenn and Johnson split wide,
Witten was lined up on Quincy's left, and Jones was at his side,
The ball was snapped on a silent count as soon as the ref blew his whistle,
Glenn and Johnson streaked downfield, and Quincy launched a missile,

Oh, somewhere in the state of Texas, there must be a happy crowd,
Somewhere fans are cheering, somewhere they are proud,
Somewhere a team has a victory, and well-earned accolades are accepted,
But that somewhere isn't Dallas, because Quincy's pass was intercepted.


:lmao: :lmao: :lmao2: :lmao2:

David
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
I woke up from that nightmare and do not want to relive it again thank you very much
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
how lucky we are that Q-Bong was such a royal screw up on and OFF the field, because Romo wouldnt be here today if not for the Q-Bongers grass habit

Romo was the odd man out that yr...he's probably be in Denver or some other place today if not for that glorious day when Bill & Jerruh kicked Q to the curb

David
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
dbair1967;1826401 said:
how lucky we are that Q-Bong was such a royal screw up on and OFF the field, because Romo wouldnt be here today if not for the Q-Bongers grass habit

Romo was the odd man out that yr...he's probably be in Denver or some other place today if not for that glorious day when Bill & Jerruh kicked Q to the curb

David

I think Romo would still be our QB even if Carter didn't fork up. At least we would have been saved from a year of Vinny Green-testicles. I'm pretty sure BP would have brought in Bledsoe the year after anyway.
 

Frozen700

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,511
Reaction score
6,475
silverbear;1826212 said:
We'd undoubtedly be 0-13 with Bledsoe at the helm...

But we'd be 13-0 with the legend that is Quincy Carter at the helm... unless he got his hands on some killer bud the night before one of those games... you know, like the "Reindeer" or the "Frankenstein" that Dante was selling in Grandma's Boy...


:lmao2::lmao2::lmao2::lmao2::lmao::lmao::lmao: omg!
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
Eddie;1826425 said:
I think Romo would still be our QB even if Carter didn't fork up. At least we would have been saved from a year of Vinny Green-testicles. I'm pretty sure BP would have brought in Bledsoe the year after anyway.

no he wouldnt, unless we had been able to stash him on the PS...Parcells and Jones both said Romo would have been released...we would have had Q-Bong, Vinny and Henson

David
 

Frozen700

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,511
Reaction score
6,475
dbair1967;1826434 said:
no he wouldnt, unless we had been able to stash him on the PS...Parcells and Jones both said Romo would have been released...we would have had Q-Bong, Vinny and Henson

David


:banghead::banghead: damn what a disaster that would have been
 

Mr Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,612
Reaction score
32,654
If either one of them were our QB, it would mean that we still had Parcells in charge, running his conservative, not to lose offense, and his vanilla defense. No Garrett or Stewart, and Haley would still be around antagonizing TO.

We would be no better than 9-7, but probably about 6-10, looking forward to drafting another OLB in the first round and a TE in the second.
 

Frozen700

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,511
Reaction score
6,475
Mr Cowboy;1826445 said:
If either one of them were our QB, it would mean that we still had Parcells in charge, running his conservative, not to lose offense, and his vanilla defense. No Garrett or Stewart, and Haley would still be around antagonizing TO.

We would be no better than 9-7, but probably about 6-10, looking forward to drafting another OLB in the first round and a TE in the second.

lol, a olb is the first...i hated that ****
 
Top