Which movie is more believable, Independence Day or Battleship?

[Runwildboys]

I go with independence day out of personal preference . It's a silly popcorn movie but still one of my personal favorites.
I barely remember seeing battleship

Same here. I just remembered the premise being stupid, and that they had to force it to sorta fit with the game.

 

[visionary]

I have an argument going w/ my nephew.

All things considered, which movie is more believable:

Independence Day

Battleship


I know, I know, neither is believable. However, our argument is over which of these two is MORE believable.

I thought they were documentaries