Who retires first - Brady, Brees, Manning, Roethlisberger, Rivers?

Who retires first?

  • Tom Brady

    Votes: 2 4.3%
  • Drew Brees

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Eli Manning

    Votes: 28 59.6%
  • Ben Roethlisberger

    Votes: 14 29.8%
  • Philip Rivers

    Votes: 3 6.4%

  • Total voters
    47

Cowboy Brian

@BrianLINY
Messages
15,864
Reaction score
5,053
As the first generation of NFL superstars of this century is now on its last leg of remaining active NFL players, who among them will be the first to retire?

Brady?
Brees?
Eli Manning?
Roethlisberger?
Philip Rivers?

This is an interesting question in many ways. By the end of this season, if each walked away from the game, they're all bona-fide HOFers, each with a unique story and records to their own.

By the end of 2018, Drew Brees will arguably become the NFL's greatest QB in history statistically, with Tom Brady currently ~4,000 yards behind him (essentially one season). In all liklihood, the next time he suits up he wall pass both Brett Favre and Peyton Manning to become the all-time leading passer. (http://www.espn.com/nfl/history/leaders/_/stat/passyards)

Eli Manning may never get out of the shadow of his older brother, but he currently sits as the #6 all-time NFL passer by yards, followed by Roethlisbeger at #7 and Rivers at #8. All of them are within 1,500 yards of each other.

Rivers easily can go down as this generation of stars Dan Marino, walking away without a ring.

The NFL has a true lack of megastars that have emerged in to replace these 5 men, and time will tell if in the era of "full-disclosure" due to social media, if there will ever be a star at the level of Tom Brady again.
 
Last edited:

Bigdog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,763
Reaction score
11,407
Big Ben
Manning
Rivers
Brees
Brady
I believe in this order. Big Ben and Eli might switch.
 

C42

Well-Known Member
Messages
859
Reaction score
454
If Eli wasn't so durable I’d put him before Ben, but the guy has never been hurt. The past two offseasons I have been expecting Ben to retire, so I’ll go with him.
 

Melonfeud

I Copy!,,, er,,,I guess,,,ah,,,maybe.
Messages
21,976
Reaction score
33,152
If Eli wasn't so durable I’d put him before Ben, but the guy has never been hurt. The past two offseasons I have been expecting Ben to retire, so I’ll go with him.
Right-on! ,,,ya,I picked the Pittsburgler to hang it up first also.
 

Ranched

"We Are Penn State"
Messages
34,885
Reaction score
84,323
As the first generation of NFL superstars of this century is now on its last leg of remaining active NFL players, who
Eli Manning may never get out of the shadow of his older brother, but he currently sits as the #6 all-time NFL passer by yards, followed by Roethlisbeger at #7 and Rivers at #8. All of them are within 1,500 yards of each other.

Rivers easily can go down as this generation of stars Dan Marino, walking away without a ring.

The NFL has a true lack of megastars that have emerged in to replace these 5 men, and time will tell if in the era of "full-disclosure" due to social media, if there will ever be a star at the level of Tom Brady again.
He doesn't have to, he had two rings first.:muttley:
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,921
Reaction score
11,907
I went Rivers. He seems the most carefree of all the qbs, he could just say he wants to do something else at any point.
 

ksadler1

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,927
Reaction score
5,277
I picked Manning but l'd flip a coin between him and Roth...
 

Cowboy Brian

@BrianLINY
Messages
15,864
Reaction score
5,053
Surprising that the two oldest Brees and Brady are viewed as the least likely to retire.
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,779
Reaction score
47,599
Brady.

At some point, he's simply going to have a sharp decline.
 

Cowboy Brian

@BrianLINY
Messages
15,864
Reaction score
5,053
Brady.

At some point, he's simply going to have a sharp decline.
I wonder if it comes down to him wanting to break the records Brees is shattering. He's lagging about a season behind, but Brees is 2 years younger.
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,779
Reaction score
47,599
I wonder if it comes down to him wanting to break the records Brees is shattering. He's lagging about a season behind, but Brees is 2 years younger.
Brady is extremely lucky to be playing in this time, and to have a top 10 all time HC. He's been kept protected by both his OL and by the rules. If Brady had played in the 70's/80's, he'd have been done by age 33.

Can you imagine how long Aikman would play in today's league?
 

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,390
They should all conspire to go out at once, then host a retirement party at Chucky Cheese . Now, that would be novel.
 

funkytown

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,550
Reaction score
559
Hopefully the Giants let Eli play forever.

He should to be the 1st one to go from this group. But put me down for the surprise. Brees.
 
Top