Why Josh McDaniels?

sportsman · Jan 10, 2009

ESPN is reporting that Josh McDaniels of New England is the leading candidate for the Broncos job. What has past coaches of the Bill Belichek staff done to warrant future staff interest. Coaches that have recently been fired from that tree Romeo Crennel, Eric Mangini(rehired) and the most popular Charlie Weis he's really done a bang up job at ND.

1fisher · Jan 10, 2009

I think McDaniels has done a fine job!

Alexander · Jan 10, 2009

1fisher;2566821 said:
I think McDaniels has done a fine job!

He did an outstanding job.

He took a player who had not started since high school and the Patriots were able to not only win eleven games with him after Brady went down but also have a dangerous passing game at times. That was remarkable.

NextGenBoys · Jan 10, 2009

Alexander;2566824 said:
He did an outstanding job.

He took a player who had not started since high school and the Patriots were able to not only win eleven games with him after Brady went down but also have a dangerous passing game at times. That was remarkable.

Exactly. Not to mention the Pats offense last year. Belichick has full control over his team, but everyone knows defense is his forte.

No coordinator from NE has ever had that type of success.

theogt · Jan 10, 2009

Alexander;2566824 said:
He did an outstanding job.

He took a player who had not started since high school and the Patriots were able to not only win eleven games with him after Brady went down but also have a dangerous passing game at times. That was remarkable.

Amazing how a decent coordinator can adjust an offense once the starting QB goes down.

DaBoys4Life · Jan 10, 2009

theogt;2566835 said:
Amazing how a decent coordinator can adjust an offense once the starting QB goes down.

Grrr....stop taking shots at Garrett that's my OC *sniffles* :laugh2:

NextGenBoys · Jan 10, 2009

theogt;2566835 said:
Amazing how a decent coordinator can adjust an offense once the starting QB goes down.

Seriously? Cant we drop that topic for just one thread?

theogt · Jan 10, 2009

NextGenBoys;2566841 said:
Seriously? Cant we drop that topic for just one thread?

No, not at all when it's a logical extension of the thread. It's a thread about a coordinator who's interviewing for a job one of our coordinators is. The question was why him, and the answer was his ability to adjust his offense and succeed, which has been a major criticism of our coordinator.

If they are able to choose between the two, I have no idea why they'd ever choose Garrett.

NextGenBoys · Jan 10, 2009

theogt;2566849 said:
No, not at all when it's a logical extension of the thread. It's a thread about a coordinator who's interviewing for a job one of our coordinators is. The question was why him, and the answer was his ability to adjust his offense and succeed, which has been a major criticism of our coordinator.

I think we can all admit McDaniels is a better coordinator than Garrett. Dont know anyone who would want to argue otherwise.

To me, it just seems like you're taking every opportunity to slam Garrett.

Could be wrong though.

Rampage · Jan 10, 2009

NextGenBoys;2566851 said:
I think we can all admit McDaniels is a better coordinator than Garrett. Dont know anyone who would want to argue otherwise.

To me, it just seems like you're taking every opportunity to slam Garrett.

Could be wrong though.

whether he is or not he should be slammed for failing this season with more offensive weapons than any other team.

Hostile · Jan 10, 2009

sportsman;2566800 said:
ESPN is reporting that Josh McDaniels of New England is the leading candidate for the Broncos job. What has past coaches of the Bill Belichek staff done to warrant future staff interest. Coaches that have recently been fired from that tree Romeo Crennel, Eric Mangini(rehired) and the most popular Charlie Weis he's really done a bang up job at ND.

I reported it two days ago.

ESPN gets all the credit.

Woods · Jan 10, 2009

Hostile;2566860 said:
I reported it two days ago.

ESPN gets all the credit.

Good, that means Garrett hopefully stays.

NextGenBoys · Jan 10, 2009

Rampage;2566857 said:
whether he is or not he should be slammed for failing this season with more offensive weapons than any other team.

Yeah but not at every opportunity available. We get it.

And IMO McDaniels has more to work with. Moss is the most gifted receiver in a game, and a QB can throw up a jump ball for him to go get. When you add to that the best underneath receiver in the game, you have two receivers that are better than what we have in Dallas.

That, and according to you and many, Garrett didnt run the ball, which McDaniels did.

I'm not giving Garrett a pass either, as he does have more than the majority of teams. I do not think the Pats are one of them however.

Alexander · Jan 10, 2009

theogt;2566849 said:
No, not at all when it's a logical extension of the thread. It's a thread about a coordinator who's interviewing for a job one of our coordinators is. The question was why him, and the answer was his ability to adjust his offense and succeed, which has been a major criticism of our coordinator.

If they are able to choose between the two, I have no idea why they'd ever choose Garrett.

McDaniels is a candidate because he has proven himself. He started doing nothing but piecing together video for Belichick. He's done what most of the Patriot assistants on offense have done. He's worked for it and earned it.

Garrett on the other hand has taken a much less different route and does not even have the track record.

1fisher · Jan 10, 2009

Woods;2566861 said:
Good, that means Garrett hopefully stays.

x 2

:wink:

Hostile · Jan 10, 2009

Alexander;2566865 said:
McDaniels is a candidate because he has proven himself. He started doing nothing but piecing together video for Belichick. He's done what most of the Patriot assistants on offense have done. He's worked for it and earned it.

Garrett on the other hand has taken a much less different route and does not even have the track record.

A pure football post. No drama, no emotional upheaval, just exact ways in which the game of football works at the coaching level with honesty.

These are rare. Cherish it all who read this.

Alexander · Jan 10, 2009

Hostile;2566860 said:
I reported it two days ago.

ESPN gets all the credit.

The Boston Herald also reported it two days ago.

http://www.bostonherald.com/sports/...w.bg?articleid=1144151&srvc=sports&position=2

Hostile · Jan 10, 2009

Alexander;2566873 said:
The Boston Herald also reported it two days ago.

http://www.bostonherald.com/sports/...w.bg?articleid=1144151&srvc=sports&position=2

You saying they trumped me after I just worshiped your post?

j/k

That's where I reported it from. Just saying ESPN is 2 days behind.

percyhoward · Jan 10, 2009

The Pats only had 57 penalties on offense, fewest in the league.

Dallas had 119, most in the league.

Hostile · Jan 10, 2009

percyhoward;2566883 said:
The Pats only had 57 penalties on offense, fewest in the league.

Dallas had 119, most in the league.

That just depresses me.

Why Josh McDaniels?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

What's it going to be then, eh?

Well-Known Member

Surrealist

Benched

Well-Known Member

Surrealist

Well-Known Member

Benched

The Duke

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

What's it going to be then, eh?

Well-Known Member

The Duke

What's it going to be then, eh?

The Duke

Research Tool

The Duke

Forum statistics