Why old stadiums should be demolished

rynochop

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,763
Reaction score
4,657
I've been to Reliant once in '05 or so and I forgot somehow until the Sunday night game how physically close the astrodome is to it. Reliant is a great facility and the dome looks like a giant pimple on it. I'm as sentimental as they get about some stuff, but tear that thing down. It was a dump the last time I was in it pre-Katrina.
I was more upset about Astroworld being leveled.
 

BoysFan4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
3,510
Yeah part of me feels the same way, It was the frist of it's kind and has meant a lot over the years to the people of Houston. I have gone to all kinds of events including some great concerts. The other part of me sees it as a money pit that is just sitting there and costing the people of Harris County money

Truly an issue where you can see both sides of the coin. If I lived there I think I would hate to see it go. Just from a female's sentimental mindset. I'll be interested to see the final outcome either way.
 

BoysFan4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
3,510
I've been to Reliant once in '05 or so and I forgot somehow until the Sunday night game how physically close the astrodome is to it. Reliant is a great facility and the dome looks like a giant pimple on it. I'm as sentimental as they get about some stuff, but tear that thing down. It was a dump the last time I was in it pre-Katrina.
I was more upset about Astroworld being leveled.

What is Astroworld?
 

BoysFan4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
3,510
A bigger symbol of Houston is NASA in which one of the real Space Shuttles should have went to :eek:
I drive by there everyday only to see a replica and it angers me :(

I missed this shuttle stuff but presume the government was involved in some way?
 

rynochop

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,763
Reaction score
4,657
Was Houston's only amusement park, like Six Flags. Home of the Texas Cyclone, was the biggest wooden roller-coaster at the time, or was it the fastest? I forgot.

I think it was the bumpiest, lol. I had the worse headache after every time I rode that thing as a kid. Thunder River, Greased Lightning...good times.
 

Nova

Ntegrase96
Messages
10,701
Reaction score
12,660
Um, no offense, but haven't you said you're mid-20s or so? I think you just don't appreciate how special it was for its time. I'm not even old enough to remember that and I'm a lot older than you. But in its day it was a true architectural and engineering marvel. It wasn't just the place where the Oilers and Astros played.

Yup mid 20s. I'm 27. Or I will be in a month.

So I guess you could say it's unfair for me to criticize since I was never able to truly appreciate it. I don't disagree with that.

But you could say the same for many of the things I referenced in the first post. I didn't see Yankee stadium spring up in the 20s, and I didn't see it reopen in '78, but that doesn't mean I can't comprehend the history that took place there and understand that it was on a different level than the Astrodome and was still demolished.

The problem with architectural and engineering marvels is that architecture and engineering are always improving-- AT&T stadium will be outdated in 10 years, maybe less. And while I assumed the Astrodome may have been some awesome feat in the 50s and 60s, it pales in comparison to what we can build and achieve now.

Now obviously I'm not a guy saying we should get rid of all modern marvels, or landmarks because "new is always better", I just don't think that the Astrodome is worthy of preservation if it serves no purpose.

Yes, it may have been the first of its kind, but usually when things are considered landmarks or considered to be of importance, it's because they are the last of their kind. But obviously, there are hundreds of these cathedrals to sports around the world now, so what real value does the Astrodome have?

It's not the Pyramids. It's not the Colossus of Rhodes. It's not the Taj Mahal or even the Empire State Building.

Its importance now is just sentimental.
 

Tabascocat

Dexternjack
Messages
27,802
Reaction score
38,862
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
I think it was the bumpiest, lol. I had the worse headache after every time I rode that thing as a kid. Thunder River, Greased Lightning...good times.

When I was 16, went there with a few buddies. We rode it 36 times that day, mostly in the back. The night rides were the best. Not one ache the next day.

Fast forward to 2010. At the age of 40, the wife and I went to Magic Mountain in LA. We started the day on one of the medium sized coasters to warm-up. We felt like we were in a car crash, almost passed out due to the loops and lost my lucky Mets cap. That was the last coaster I have rode to this day. We finished up on the water rides :(
 

rynochop

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,763
Reaction score
4,657
When I was 16, went there with a few buddies. We rode it 36 times that day, mostly in the back. The night rides were the best. Not one ache the next day.

Fast forward to 2010. At the age of 40, the wife and I went to Magic Mountain in LA. We started the day on one of the medium sized coasters to warm-up. We felt like we were in a car crash, almost passed out due to the loops and lost my lucky Mets cap. That was the last coaster I have rode to this day. We finished up on the water rides :(

We're the same age, probably the last time I went was around 16. I wouldn't get on a coaster now, rode a ferris wheel with my kids a couple years ago and thought was going to have a panic attack.ha Water rides i'm fine with though, weird.
 

Tabascocat

Dexternjack
Messages
27,802
Reaction score
38,862
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
We're the same age, probably the last time I went was around 16. I wouldn't get on a coaster now, rode a ferris wheel with my kids a couple years ago and thought was going to have a panic attack.ha Water rides i'm fine with though, weird.

Age, it sucks getting older :(

We stick to water rides as well. It is weird that I developed some fear of heights too. I was never phased in the past, now I get anxious on ferris wheels and the like. Heck, even going over the Golden Gate brought minor panic at times, heh. That was mostly due to the fog and the chance of an earthquake at an inopportune time.
 

Doomsay

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,542
Reaction score
6,160
I used to live in Wrigleyville, I don't think that you could ever replace the atmosphere there. Also, best venue for a Pearl Jam Concert.

Similarly, the old places like Comisky Tiger and Fenway gave you a connection to the root of the sport, kind of hard to replace. The only "Classic" feeling pro football stadium that I've been to was Soldier Field and I think that they did a really good job maintaining the traditional look when they re-built it recently. The newest versions of the Meadowlands, Gillette and the Vet are all improvements over nondescript structures to begin with IMO.
 
Top