Maybe I'm missing the obvious, but wouldn't any team that plays on a Thursday night have 3 games in 11 days? I guess the exception would be a bye week on either side of that game.
I mean we have this early in the year too with three games from the 15th - 26th of September because of TNF.
- Week 2: New Orleans Saints (Sun. 9/15, 12:00 p.m. on FOX)
- Week 3: Baltimore Ravens (Sun. 9/22, 3:25 p.m. on FOX)
- Week 4: at New York Giants (Thurs. 9/26, 7:15 p.m. on Prime Video)
Is there just some specific issue around Thanksgiving that I'm missing?
You're not wrong. But two words come to mind about Thanksgiving, rest and recovery. Look at the Raven/Giants two step here. Let's say the Ravens game ends at 7pm central time. A full 4 days will have passed before they kick off on Thursday night against the Giants. Since the Ravens game is at home most of the players will be in their own beds by 10 pm and will not have to sit their battered bodies on a bus to the airport and then on a plane for several hours and MAYBE get into their own beds by 3 am? Anyone who has ever had to take a late flight that lands in the wee hours can attest to what that does to your body. Fast forward to the Thanksgiving pivot. They play a noon game at the Commodores. If that game ends by 4 pm Central, by the time they shower, dress, bus to the airport, fly back lets say that whole process takes 7 hours. They're in their own beds by 11 pm but they're stiffer for having dealt with the whole bus and flight thing after the game. Then they play the 3:00 game on Turkey day. On the surface it would seem like the 4 hours lost rest would be no big deal but you add in the extra 7 hours getting home from the previous game they've really lost 10 or 11 hours. Now I expect them to still spank the Giants on Thanksgiving, but I think playing an actual good team on that schedule is a huge disadvantage. Oh and thanks to the Monday night game this year the Cowboys will play 3 games in TEN days around Thanksgiving. Thanks a lot Goodell.
But all of that only addresses the "rest" part of the equation. The second half is recovery. We know these players come out of games feeling like they've been in several car wrecks. It can take days and sometimes weeks for the body to get right after a game. And then 7 days later to do it again is insane but that's what they get paid for. The Thursday night game compresses one of those recovery weeks which in turn elongates the recovery. Having that happen in September allows 12-15 weeks to get the players' bodies right after going through it. Doing it in early December? Not so much. You get 3-4 weeks to get your body right before the playoffs. For some guys that's more than enough time. For others, not even close. When the Cowboys have drawn that Thursday night game the week AFTER Thanksgiving I just don't think they've been able to get enough guys back right before the playoffs. I think this has had a large part to play in why the teams have looked mostly lethargic in January for the last 20 years.
The bottom line is that the talent level between NFL teams is frightfully even. So everything that impacts player performance must be considered. Anything that gives one team and advantage over the other should be avoided if possible. After watching the Cowboys stumble through that Thanksgiving horror in 2014 after playing the SUNDAY NIGHT GAME at the Giants even Goodell recognized how unfair that was and we've not seen a repeat. That game ended after midnight and the Cowboys did not get back to DFW until 6 am. What showed up at the stadium on Thursday was nothing like the team they truly were. My guess is Jerry had a talk with Goodell about that one..
Obviously all of this is speculation on my part and I am truly relating how my own body would have reacted in those situations to professional athletes which is almost never a true comparison!