rwalters31
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,443
- Reaction score
- 643
CBS has the following QB ratings from first to 8th with comparisons. After the first two the rest will only be average at best and only backups in the NFL. In other words after the Cowboys pass on the first two at number 4 pick the future of Dallas is written on the wall. There will not be a future for Dallas winning SBs for a long time. Does not matter who we pick after that in the draft
Read and enjoy:
5
*Jared Goff
QB
1
California
Jr
6-4
215
1
7
Carson Wentz
QB
2
North Dakota State
Sr
6-5
237
1
33
*Paxton Lynch
QB
3
Memphis
rJr
6-7
244
1-2
39
Connor Cook
QB
4
Michigan State
rSr
6-4
217
1-2
71
*Christian Hackenberg
QB
5
Penn State
Jr
6-4
223
2-3
106
*Cardale Jones
QB
6
Ohio State
rJr
6-5
253
3-4
140
Dak Prescott
QB
7
Mississippi State
rSr
6-2
226
4-5
165
Jacoby Brissett
QB
8
NC State
rSr
6-4
231
5
Warts
Goff - Goff is a good athlete for the position but isn't a true scrambling threat and his accuracy drops when attempting to throw on the run. Dykes' offense rarely calls for traditional deep balls down the sideline, although Gray has shown improvement in his downfield touch throughout the 2015 season.
COMPARES TO: Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons -- Tall, smart passers without an elite arm, both have the mental processor and pocket mechanics to be consistently deliver downfield.
Wentz - Although his internal clock needs maturing, Wentz performs well within structure, but can also improvise when the play breaks down, stretching out his legs to pick up chunk yardage if it's there (949 career rushing yards). He possesses a NFL-style skill-set with his size, athleticism and arm talent, including the field vision to work through reads and make sound decisions.
NFL Comparison: Alex Smith, Kansas City Chiefs -- Wentz is a physically enhanced version of Smith with his taller stature and stronger arm, but both have similar athleticism to move the pocket and the intelligence on and off the field desired for the position.
Lynch - Inconsistent base, doesn't always throw with a balanced foundation, which affects his downfield accuracy. Must sharpen footwork. Relies on arm talent over fundamentals. Requires maintenance with his throwing technique, which was not emphasized by his coaches.
NFL Comparison: None
My Take: His foot work is terrible and looks like injuries to knees will be a problem in NFL. Dallas should NOT pick him.
Cook - Once moved from his original spot, he attempts to "arm" everything and abandon his base footwork, often content making throws with his weight falling away from his target. Cook isn't fully comfortable with a muddy pocket, which forces his eye level to wander and confuses his internal clock. Some thinking it might be tough for him to acclimate himself in a NFL locker room. NFL teams will be doing a lot of background work on Cook to answer the questions they have, including why he wasn't voted a team captain.
NFL Comparison: None
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, does not do well in a Romo type offense.
Hackenberg - Nonexistent feel or awareness in the pocket, struggling to navigate himself around the noise. Slow to process and late reading coverages due to questionable vision. Immature eye use, staring down targets and predetermining throws, which leads to inexplicable decisions.
COMPARES TO: Jay Cutler, Chicago Bears -- Players with power arms and well-built frames, Hackenberg and Cutler have similar strengths, but also similar question marks as inconsistent ball placement and pocket awareness can limit their pro ceilings.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, does not do well in a Romo type offense. He can openly be a backup and NO SB with him.
Jones - He needs refinement with his footwork, internal clock and overall accuracy to all levels of the field. Maturity has been another trouble issue with Jones and his class clown routine won't be tolerated by many NFL head coaches.
COMPARES TO: JaMarcus Russell, ex-Raiders -- Jones is physically impressive with the size, build and arm strength that instantly draws comparisons to Russell, including the mobility to pick up yards with his legs when needed. He can make every throw and showcases precision when he squares his shoulders and follows through with his delivery, but his game lacks sophistication and he's simply extremely raw.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, another JaMarcus Russell
Prescott - Tends to predetermine some throws and relies on a lot of back shoulder patterns, something that got him in trouble against Auburn and Alabama. Has not shown the consistency to lead his team through the air in tough road environments when the ground game is shut down
COMPARES TO: Tim Tebow, ex-Broncos, Jets, Patriots - It is the natural comparison, beyond just the connection to Mississippi State head coach Dan Mullen, who was Florida's offensive coordinator when Tebow was in Gainesville. Although Prescott has a slightly better arm and more consistent mechanics, he and Tebow grade similar in several categories, including composure, mobility, power and leadership.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, another Tim Tebow
My Analysis – After the first two QBs the rest are BURST. If we cannot get the first two top QBs, we are screwed at QB until maybe next year or never!!
Read and enjoy:
5
*Jared Goff
QB
1
California
Jr
6-4
215
1
7
Carson Wentz
QB
2
North Dakota State
Sr
6-5
237
1
33
*Paxton Lynch
QB
3
Memphis
rJr
6-7
244
1-2
39
Connor Cook
QB
4
Michigan State
rSr
6-4
217
1-2
71
*Christian Hackenberg
QB
5
Penn State
Jr
6-4
223
2-3
106
*Cardale Jones
QB
6
Ohio State
rJr
6-5
253
3-4
140
Dak Prescott
QB
7
Mississippi State
rSr
6-2
226
4-5
165
Jacoby Brissett
QB
8
NC State
rSr
6-4
231
5
Warts
Goff - Goff is a good athlete for the position but isn't a true scrambling threat and his accuracy drops when attempting to throw on the run. Dykes' offense rarely calls for traditional deep balls down the sideline, although Gray has shown improvement in his downfield touch throughout the 2015 season.
COMPARES TO: Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons -- Tall, smart passers without an elite arm, both have the mental processor and pocket mechanics to be consistently deliver downfield.
Wentz - Although his internal clock needs maturing, Wentz performs well within structure, but can also improvise when the play breaks down, stretching out his legs to pick up chunk yardage if it's there (949 career rushing yards). He possesses a NFL-style skill-set with his size, athleticism and arm talent, including the field vision to work through reads and make sound decisions.
NFL Comparison: Alex Smith, Kansas City Chiefs -- Wentz is a physically enhanced version of Smith with his taller stature and stronger arm, but both have similar athleticism to move the pocket and the intelligence on and off the field desired for the position.
Lynch - Inconsistent base, doesn't always throw with a balanced foundation, which affects his downfield accuracy. Must sharpen footwork. Relies on arm talent over fundamentals. Requires maintenance with his throwing technique, which was not emphasized by his coaches.
NFL Comparison: None
My Take: His foot work is terrible and looks like injuries to knees will be a problem in NFL. Dallas should NOT pick him.
Cook - Once moved from his original spot, he attempts to "arm" everything and abandon his base footwork, often content making throws with his weight falling away from his target. Cook isn't fully comfortable with a muddy pocket, which forces his eye level to wander and confuses his internal clock. Some thinking it might be tough for him to acclimate himself in a NFL locker room. NFL teams will be doing a lot of background work on Cook to answer the questions they have, including why he wasn't voted a team captain.
NFL Comparison: None
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, does not do well in a Romo type offense.
Hackenberg - Nonexistent feel or awareness in the pocket, struggling to navigate himself around the noise. Slow to process and late reading coverages due to questionable vision. Immature eye use, staring down targets and predetermining throws, which leads to inexplicable decisions.
COMPARES TO: Jay Cutler, Chicago Bears -- Players with power arms and well-built frames, Hackenberg and Cutler have similar strengths, but also similar question marks as inconsistent ball placement and pocket awareness can limit their pro ceilings.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, does not do well in a Romo type offense. He can openly be a backup and NO SB with him.
Jones - He needs refinement with his footwork, internal clock and overall accuracy to all levels of the field. Maturity has been another trouble issue with Jones and his class clown routine won't be tolerated by many NFL head coaches.
COMPARES TO: JaMarcus Russell, ex-Raiders -- Jones is physically impressive with the size, build and arm strength that instantly draws comparisons to Russell, including the mobility to pick up yards with his legs when needed. He can make every throw and showcases precision when he squares his shoulders and follows through with his delivery, but his game lacks sophistication and he's simply extremely raw.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, another JaMarcus Russell
Prescott - Tends to predetermine some throws and relies on a lot of back shoulder patterns, something that got him in trouble against Auburn and Alabama. Has not shown the consistency to lead his team through the air in tough road environments when the ground game is shut down
COMPARES TO: Tim Tebow, ex-Broncos, Jets, Patriots - It is the natural comparison, beyond just the connection to Mississippi State head coach Dan Mullen, who was Florida's offensive coordinator when Tebow was in Gainesville. Although Prescott has a slightly better arm and more consistent mechanics, he and Tebow grade similar in several categories, including composure, mobility, power and leadership.
My Take: Not a leader - Dallas should pass on him, another Tim Tebow
My Analysis – After the first two QBs the rest are BURST. If we cannot get the first two top QBs, we are screwed at QB until maybe next year or never!!
