Will McClay - blows

[XXLMike]

I had enough for this guy - Guyton looks a bust .

Zero playmakers drafted - ZERO - no gamebreakers - nobody’s whose jersey would sell after CD.

This guy is a fraud

 

[MysteryIceGuro]

Well when you’re surrounded by fraudulent ownership, fraudulent culture, fraudulent clowns masquerading as football players for years on end—that tends to have an effect on their psyche and how one acts.

McClay was great. Now he’s putrid like the rest of this abhorrent and aberrant team.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

Hey don’t make it about Will, today is Jerry’s birthday

 

[Risen Star]

If you're standing next to Jerry and Stephen anyone can look like Ron Wolf.

 

[big dog cowboy]

I had enough for this guy - Guyton looks a bust

Wow those 3 years went by in a hurry.

The draft was just 6 months ago in case you forgot.

 

[jaythecowboy]

Guyton was always a project. That isnt Mcclay’s fault. It isnt also Mcclay’s fault that the team does nothing in free agency which gives the team so many needs in the draft. He did mess up with the Mazi Smith pick though.

 

[Hoofbite]

Whatever he’s doing it damn sure isn’t finding depth.

 

[morat1959]

I’m in no way defending McClay but who cares how many jerseys sell? I hope Jerry never sells another one.

 

[CowboysDrew]

Guyton was thrown into one of the hardest positions to play in football as a rookie. Tyler Smith spoiled everyone on sliding into it and doing well.

I don't blame McClay for the pick, there's not enough time on his resume to know if he's going to be good or not. I blame the coaches on tossing him in day one without working him over from an easier position.

Even Tyron Smith played RT as a Rookie.

 

[Chasing6]

I had enough for this guy - Guyton looks a bust .

Zero playmakers drafted - ZERO - no gamebreakers - nobody’s whose jersey would sell after CD.

This guy is a fraud

He is a developmental project. Making the switch from LT to RT is not easy to do.

I would strongly consider making a change during the bye week.

LT - Smith
RT - Guyton
ST - Steele

Who becomes our LG???

 

[XXLMike]

You can defend him all you want you can tell me that Guyton was a project yada yada yada but the fact of the matter is teams in our division, especially the Giants and Washington club are adding players. They’re adding depth running back death wide receiver, depth, tight end, defensive line depth, big players quality players.
We’re still relying on DeMarcus, Lawrence and Ezekiel, Elliott and projects like Tolbert and a couple of wide receivers we got via UDFA.

I’m sick of that garbage get some friggin quality in here.

 

[J_Allen]

He has found us some gems but he is way overrated. There's just not much he can do with Jerry as the owner.

If there is Talent on someone's practice squad he can find it. And he's good at finding undrafted free agents. We've hit on several of those. The draft before this was not a good one and no team worth their salt is taking a backup tight end in the second round. That's the fourth time we've done that in the past 15 years. No team takes projects, head cases, and thugs in that round either year after year. You do that in the 6th and 7th.

I wouldn't take them, but Jerry would open up death row if he could. I was shocked he didn't sign Michael vick. Absolutely shocked.

 

[Chasing6]

You can defend him all you want you can tell me that Guyton was a project yada yada yada but the fact of the matter is teams in our division, especially the Giants and Washington club are adding players. They’re adding depth running back death wide receiver, depth, tight end, defensive line depth, big players quality players.
We’re still relying on DeMarcus, Lawrence and Ezekiel, Elliott and projects like Tolbert and a couple of wide receivers we got via UDFA.

I’m sick of that garbage get some friggin quality in here.

I agree that is 100% GM Jethro.

I am not sure how you can blame McClay, unless you can tell me we always 100% of the time pick best player available regardless of need or not and I know we don't do that.

 

[jokercard]

Everyone in this organization blows. Been that way for years.

 

[mattjames2010]

Wow those 3 years went by in a hurry.

The draft was just 6 months ago in case you forgot.

No, Guyton just looks all around bad. He's not going to live up to where he was drafted.

McClay's best days are behind him. Time to move on.

 

[Chasing6]

No, Guyton just looks all around bad. He's not going to live up to where he was drafted.

McClay's best days are behind him. Time to move on.

What LT drafted after him is playing better? Just curious.

When has the 8th tackle selected come out and played at a high level? Never mind switched from the right to the left. We drafted out of need. We did not draft best player available.

 

[thunderpimp91]

McClay really hasn’t done a bad job, the issue is Jerry being so dependent upon hitting in the draft. When you dive into draft success across the league you see that it’s just not realistic to hit on enough players to sit out free agency on a regular basis.

 

[BrAinPaiNt]

Will McClay is not the problem.
Thinking Will McClay is the problem...is a problem.

 

[SoBlue128]

Kind of hard to build a roster when all you’re afforded are funds for the clearance aisle at Walmart

 

[CowboysDrew]

You can defend him all you want you can tell me that Guyton was a project yada yada yada but the fact of the matter is teams in our division, especially the Giants and Washington club are adding players. They’re adding depth running back death wide receiver, depth, tight end, defensive line depth, big players quality players.

You overall aren't wrong. Cowboys have wasted 2nds and 3rds on picks that would better serve them.

However, there's a difference between Dallas and Washington the past three years and that's where they're picking. It matters. You can't compare it like apples to apples. Top 10 picks are not bottom 20. You add better players when you're picking at the top of the round like New York and Washington than the bottom.

When you're at the end of the 1st and the board is empty people like Mazi Smith and Guyton start to look more interesting. GM's take shots on those to see if they work. Many many of them bust. It's not an excuse but it is what the Cowboys scout team is working with and it's part of why the team has had problems.

The worst place to be is good enough to draft too high but bad enough you can't crack the playoffs. That's the land where you find Bobbie Carpenters and Taco Charltons.