Doomsday101;2076651 said:
He has only coached 1 season in Dallas. 13-3 was a great season and falling short in the playoff hurt but this is not the 1st time this team even Cowboy teams who were favored at the start of the season failing to make it to the SB. No doubt the ultimate goal is to win SB but going out and winning and competing at a high level is what the job is about if not then more coaches are failure than successful.
That is why prempted my comment with "If Wade Phillips were to retire today".
The OP is really asking us to come to a conclusion based on events that have not happened. That of course being how Wade Phillips does in the future, which is impossible to know, so one is forced to evaluate his present body of work.
Wade Phillips can go 13-3 in the Regular Season each year of his tenure, but if he doesn't win a Playoff Game, he will not be remembered as a winner.
This point is especially evident given the abundance of talent Wade Phillips enjoys.