I think for a bunch of our fans, including myself-we look at the trends and trajectory of the squad. The mind can see and predict the future without permission, and without guarantee. My mind does an absurd number of computations, and comes up with how probable something might be with what I am seeing happen on game day. You combine that with historical trends and performance of not just your favored club, but many others and give yourself a probability of something happening. If it does not yield an answer you like, you do not have to ignore it because it does not make you unhappy to think that your favored club has very little chance of success compared to other clubs. It makes you believe that the team could stand to make moves that improve your perceived set of odds.
Other fans deal in faith and belief structure like their fandom is their religion. They feel like their faith is healthy, and puts them in a good mood because it costs nothing to put faith into something that they use as entertainment. There is a small or large letdown depending on how much emotion they invest into their faith (if the season ends as a disappointment to them). Then they start again after the season as a complete separate entity.
For me, it’s a continuous experience. My experience is a totality of experience, not a season to season thing. I don’t toss good or bad experiences out of my mind-like tossing out negative experiences as a way to cope and not confront a thought. I spent less time actually watching the games than ever before this season because the team did not show me much difference to the previous 2 seasons. I of course would tune into the game(s) in the postseason, to enjoy game day with friends and family and hopefully see the team move forward. My doubts about the team’s performance capabilities do not matter much to me-they are just there in the background.
After the season, the computations are still ongoing and I think rationally and logically about the team’s chances moving forward. If I do not see a trend that I want to see, it does not mean I dump the thought. I might turn more attention to something else based on my interest level though which has happened more and more over the past 3 decades.