Would you rather...

[TheSport78]

lets say the eagles don't trade up to grab Shawn Andrews in the 04' Draft. What do you do?

1) take andrews in the 1st and julius in the 2nd or
2) trade down like we did and grab julius + 1st rounder in 05' (spears)


Andrews and Julius or Julius and Spears

 

[kilz]

Andrews

 

[Tio]

both unproven. A DE is a cornerstone to a team unlike a RG would be.

 

[StonetheCrow77]

Andrews might not be a RG for the Cowboys... the Eagles just put him there... he could probably play RT...

But, I'd still rather have Spears...

 

[Roughneck]

Spears

Perfect fit for our rotation this season and for upcoming seasons.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Spears for me. He is going to be terrific for us.

 

[Echo9]

lets say the eagles don't trade up to grab Shawn Andrews in the 04' Draft. What do you do?

1) take andrews in the 1st and julius in the 2nd or
2) trade down like we did and grab julius + 1st rounder in 05' (spears)


Andrews and Julius or Julius and Spears

that scenario doesn't actually work out that way since we drafted Julius with the earlier of our two 2nd rounders. That was the one we got from Buffalo in the trade down.

It's a pretty big stretch to assume that Julius would have lasted until our next pick (the one we used on Jacobs)

With that in mind, I'd stick with what we did.