for what price? if the contract is decent, yes....everyone wants improvements everywhere and you can't have all pros at every position. he is decent. he does some good things. some areas he needs to improve. but yeah, if price is right I would resign.
Realistically - you're right in you won't have All pros and Pro Bowlers at every position,
Theoretically you'd want to try- attempt to have and develop pro bowlers at every position ... as well as quality depth.
The aim is to have as talent laden roster as possible. And never become complacent.
Even if it's very solid guys such as Darrin Smith, Dixon Edwards.
The 90's team had All pro's and Pro Bowlers all across the OL.
The DL has pro bowlers: Haley, Tolbert, Lett, even Maryland.
When we even had guys that were eventually Pro Bowlers elsewhere on other NFL teams (ala Brock Marion, Ron Stone)
Besides eventual big injuries and age to our big stars, horrible drafting,, trade and FA signings became because we became content and complacent with that Jimmie roster.
i don't think Brown will be an All Pro, .. but yet i was wrong in thinking he could Not be a solid starter as a No.2 CB. on the outside,
i thought he was more of a slot guy than an outside guy.
Even teams like Joe Burrow and Matthew Stafford haven't been able to take advantage of him .
And obviously the Cowboys were initially skeptical with Brown as a No.2 to be drafting Kelvin Joseph as a 2nd rd.
My questions would be: .
1) .What is considered the "right' price for re-signing Brown ?
2) Who would we have as a replacement should A Brown depart as a UFA. ?