And let's not forget that, in the season (2010-11) he won the championship, Rodgers struggled with accuracy pretty bad the first half of that season even with that great receiving corps. They were in danger of missing the playoffs and barely made it in and finished 10-6 and got a wild card only because the Bears had a bigger choker in Jay Cutler.
Even since his MVP season in 2014, he's had several stretches where he's really struggled with accuracy inexplicably. After a blazing 6-0 start in 2015, his accuracy was mediocre middling-NFL tier the rest of that season, and they finished the year 4-6 even including the one miracle win in Detroit with the Rodgers-to-Rodgers hail mary. Even though Rodgers wasn't injured at all that season.
His accuracy issues got even worse in the 2016 season. Green Bay started off that season 3-6 before Rodgers finally woke up and they ran the table, mostly against an easy schedule and a weak division, and they rode that momentum all the way to the NFC Championship game where Atlanta blew them off the field badly.
Rodgers is a great QB and instoppable when he's on one of his hot streaks, but the fact that he's had so many cold streaks throughout his career, to me makes him a Tier 2 all time QB, not a Tier 1. He'll make the HOF, but he'll be shades below the Brady's and Montana's of the league. Even below Staubach and possibly a shade below Aikman and Favre, especially if he doesn't win another title.
It also remains to be seen if his mobility outside of the pocket will be affected by last year's brutal injury. He might be a little run-shy after taking that hit on one of his signature roll-out plays. He's never been the best pocket passer, though he might be the best out-of-pocket passer I've ever seen. But if his escapability is affected by the past setback, Green Bay's offense will struggle quite a bit at times going forward.
