YR's My Meaningless Thoughts On The Game...

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
- Before the 2009 season, I think it was a writer over at the BleacherReport.com wrote something about Tony Romo that drew the ire of fans on this message board. Generally, I think the Bleacher Report is a joke. This comment was very harsh and I think in the end a bit too harsh for Romo, but I don’t think it was too far off and it was one of those ‘when you think about, it’s pretty true and the truth hurts’ type of comments.

Anyway, the comment was that Romo was more or less the Paris Hilton of football in that he’s more or less ‘famous for being famous.’ Meaning that in the NFL he’s an ‘A List Celebrity’, but what exactly had he accomplished? And there was certainly some truth to that at that point because he had yet to win a playoff game. And truth be told, it still applies as I don’t think winning 1 playoff game should let somebody off the hook.

But even worse, this really applies to the entire team.

I don’t think we are overrating the actual talent and skill level of the team. But more or less they’ve become ‘famous for being famous’ instead of being famous based on the merits of their accomplishments. And there’s only a handful of guys that play with a sense of urgency (Miles, Dez, Free, Ratliff, Ware and Brooking).

To me, THAT is the entire problem with this team. We as fans are too eager to bath them with anointing oil because they ‘look great on paper’, but have not really done much outside of individual goals in their career.

You would think that a team with Ware, supposedly the greatest defensive player in the league, Romo…supposedly an elite QB, Miles an elite WR, Witten…supposedly the best TE in the game, Ratliff supposedly the best NT in the game, etc…that this team could be coached by Lou Holtz and win 13 games. Instead we look like a 6-10 team…and that might be generous.

It’s like Irvin said about Roy not too long ago, not having any rings on your fingers should serve as motivation. Yet the team in general just seems to want to get the rock star treatment without the actual team accomplishment.


- As bad as Wade’s lack of fire is, at least I can say he’s gotten mad at players before. Can’t say that for Garrett. I still feel that Campo has done a worse job than Houck so far. To Houck’s credit, they’ve yet to really draft a player in the first 2 rounds that he wanted. He’s developed Free into a very good left tackle. But I wouldn’t say he’s done a great job by any means…although I’ll say the jury is still out for me. Campo OTOH got Jenkins and Scandrick and inherited Newman and Scandrick hasn’t progressed like we thought and Jenkins has regressed this year and we still can’t get anything from our safeties.

- Don’t blame Buehler, his kickoffs were excellent yesterday. Even the one after the Witten/Colombo penalty. He angled it well, hit it deep and got plenty of hangtime. But we couldn’t stop the returner.

- Here’s something I don’t understand about this coaching staff. They seem to want to tell the entire world the gameplan. Like how heavily they are going to focus on Chris Johnson. That’s why I said that my pre-game thoughts was I was worried about Vince Young. I thought that the Cowboys would overly focus on Johnson and make things easy for VY. And that’s what we did and we made VY look like Joe Montana. But somebody explain to me the advantage of telling the Titans that we are coming at Johnson at all costs?

- Gotta say, I’m down on Romo as well. I just don’t see a true leader in him. I think somebody like Aikman or Peyton or Brees or Brady or Rivers would let these guys know that this nonsense will not be tolerated. I put a lot of the blame on Wade, but the QB can still let the players know that regardless of what the coach thinks…he’s still the franchise and that their level of play is not acceptable. But, we will never get that from Romo.

And Romo seems to be good for one comeback/game winning drive at the most in a game, but not two. There’s going to be times when you think they’ve made a comeback or a game winning drive and the other team surprises you a bit and comes right back and now you have to make a game winning drive again. Romo doesn’t have that extra game winning drive in him. I suspect the big issue is that teams know that eventually he’ll key on Witten…which is what happened against the Titans on the final offensive play of the game.

- We all saw what Felix can do when he gets the touches. So why does it take a coaching staff and executive meeting for this to be pointed out to Garrett?

- Helluva game, Roy Williams. But with a team filled with C- guys, I just can’t help but be skeptical that you too will ‘do enough to get the critics off your back and then revert to your old ways.’

- I think we need fresh blood on our coaching staff. I think Gruden would probably be more into coaching again right now than Cowher, although I prefer Cowher the coach over Gruden the coach (Gruden’s overly complex offensive scheme drives me nuts and we can’t execute simple stuff with our current roster). People make the mistake of believing that Cowher had complete control over personnel when it was pretty similar to what we have here. He just knows how to motivate and not put up with slackers and their slacking ways. Still though, we need a younger HC with fire and the stamina to ‘keep on these guys’ in order to get the best of them. I vote for Ron Rivera, the San Diego D-Coordinator and make the SD Tight Ends coach Rob Chudzinski the O-Coordinator.

Rivera is a tough guy who gets his defenses to play disciplined football and create turnovers (he learned from the best in creating turnovers in Lovie Smith). Chudzinski grew up in football laden Ohio and was a very good, tough tight end at the U. of Miami and is learning from one of the best offensive minds in the game in Norv Turner. I don’t think you’ll have to tell him that Felix needs more touches.

I see Garrett politicking his way into the HC job and they’ll probably make Pasqualoni the D-Coordinator. If that happens, I ain’t watching much Cowboys football anymore. Sorry, I put up with Pasqualoni’s nonsense for 13 straight years, I ain’t putting up with it again.


- And that’s kind of the point of this team. They are horribly UN-FUN to watch. It’s funny that back in ’08 they remarked about not liking Martellus Bennett’s ‘body language’, but the entire team outside of a handful of players has an unlikeable body language. And instead of wanting to watch football it’s become more or less a chore to watch these guys and their sloppy, uninspired play. If I had season tickets, I’d probably look to sell them on eBay right now




YR
 
Gotta say, I’m down on Romo as well. I just don’t see a true leader in him. I think somebody like Aikman or Peyton or Brees or Brady or Rivers would let these guys know that this nonsense will not be tolerated.

I guess this magical power of Aikman's evaporated during the Switzer and Gailey years, when the team was plagued by penalties and mental mistakes?

If we depended on Aikman to put up 400 yards and 3 TDs with zero mistakes every week for us to have a chance to win the game, like we depend on Romo to do, we're an 8-8 football team under Aikman as well. Thanks to the most dominant OL in NFL history, a hall of Fame RB, and a defense that annually finished among the Top 3 in the NFL, Aikman never had to carry his team on his back week in and week out like Romo currently has to. When the defense eroded, the OL got old and Emmitt lost a step, we saw that Aikman's "mojo" wasn't enough.
 
- Gotta say, I’m down on Romo as well. I just don’t see a true leader in him. I think somebody like Aikman or Peyton or Brees or Brady or Rivers would let these guys know that this nonsense will not be tolerated. I put a lot of the blame on Wade, but the QB can still let the players know that regardless of what the coach thinks…he’s still the franchise and that their level of play is not acceptable. But, we will never get that from Romo.

I had to go to a sports bar to watch the game yesterday but it allowed me to watch ALL the games that were being played. I got to see first hand how Brees and Rivers played in their losses and neither of them was better than Tony Romo in the area of letting "these guys know that this nonsense will not be tolerated".

The Chargers lost pretty much the same way we did only to a lousy team. Rivers put up HUGE numbers but had some turnovers and his team made a bunch of dumb mistakes as well.

Not sure how you can put the onus on Romo to fire up the defense or STs either. He moved the offense down the field several times and kept us in the game. Bennett has a ball go through his hands in the endzone and it winds up in the DBs arms for an INT. How is that on Romo?

Tony's last INT was all on him but every QB makes bad throws in those situations at times. I saw Manning do it week-1 only the DB dropped it.

Drew Brees threw 3 INTs last night too in a loss to the Cards. His team made a bunch of mistakes just like the Boys did and they lost because of them. And they are the defending SB Champs!

The point is this is a problem across the board on this team. The defense isn't taking advantage of opportunities and is making way too many stupid mistakes. We dropped 2 easy INTs and had 3 blatant PI calls on the FIRST FRIGGIN DRIVE! Essentially GIVING the Titans a TD right off the bat.

This isn't a well coached or well run team and hasn't been for over 15 years now. Parcells couldn't make these players play any smarter, we led the league in penalties when he was here too, so it isn't just the style of HC that is the issue, it is the style of ownership and GM that is the problem and has been all along.

See my sig...
 
Right on YR.... It's amazing that some people think that Romo had a good game yesterday... 3 picks is not good especially 1 that basically ends the game . I think it's time for some criticism to be directed to the "untouchables" of the team - Romo (very careless throwing the ball) Witten (recent history of penalties, tipped passes - great warrior but becoming very undisciplined) Bradie James (not aggressive enough or physical for IB - that play with Chris Johnson blocking him was just pathetic - he should have blown up all 190 ibs of that kid)
 
San Diego lost that game on 2 blocked punts. He's far more fiery than Romo has ever been and while I can't stand the guy, I'd rather have a fiery guy who will light into a team (which I've seen Rivers do on countless occasions) than somebody who just accepts it. If you're going to stink and make dumb mistakes, at least show that you care.

Aikman won a Super Bowl with Barry Switzer which is a helluva lot more than what Romo has ever done, period. He still lit into the team when they performed poorly and by the time of the Gailey years the level of talent was far less than it is now. And we went to the playoffs under Gailey with less talent, I don't see that happening this year.




YR
 
Arik2;3610652 said:
Right on YR.... It's amazing that some people think that Romo had a good game yesterday... 3 picks is not good especially 1 that basically ends the game . I think it's time for some criticism to be directed to the "untouchables" of the team - Romo (very careless throwing the ball) Witten (recent history of penalties, tipped passes - great warrior but becoming very undisciplined) Bradie James (not aggressive enough or physical for IB - that play with Chris Johnson blocking him was just pathetic - he should have blown up all 190 ibs of that kid)

:laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: Romo doesn't get criticism :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2:


Romo is the most criticized career 90+ QB passer in NFL history, and it's not even close. Choice fumbles a ball? It's Romo's fault. Bennett can't catch a pass that hits him in both hands? Romo's fault. Romo merely throws for 400 yards, 3 TDs ... he should have thrown for 500 yards and 5 TDs. Romo should have designed a defensive scheme for Wade that didn't make Vince Young look like the second coming of Dan Fouts. Romo should have taught the special teams units how to tackle.
 
Arik2;3610652 said:
Right on YR.... It's amazing that some people think that Romo had a good game yesterday... 3 picks is not good especially 1 that basically ends the game . I think it's time for some criticism to be directed to the "untouchables" of the team - Romo (very careless throwing the ball) Witten (recent history of penalties, tipped passes - great warrior but becoming very undisciplined) Bradie James (not aggressive enough or physical for IB - that play with Chris Johnson blocking him was just pathetic - he should have blown up all 190 ibs of that kid)

That would probably be a good start. Facts are facts...these guys, as good as they may look and as many Pro Bowls they have gone to, really haven't done jack squat in their careers. 1 playoff win doesn't cut it.





YR
 
Yakuza Rich;3610674 said:
San Diego lost that game on 2 blocked punts. He's far more fiery than Romo has ever been and while I can't stand the guy, I'd rather have a fiery guy who will light into a team (which I've seen Rivers do on countless occasions) than somebody who just accepts it. If you're going to stink and make dumb mistakes, at least show that you care.

Aikman won a Super Bowl with Barry Switzer which is a helluva lot more than what Romo has ever done, period. He still lit into the team when they performed poorly and by the time of the Gailey years the level of talent was far less than it is now. And we went to the playoffs under Gailey with less talent, I don't see that happening this year.
YR

Funny how you conveniently left 1997 off. The 1997 team finished 6-10 with a team that was talented enough to go to the NFC Championship the year before ... why didn't Aikman let his teammates know how really, really mad he was that year? I mean, according to you, all a QB has to do is let his teammates know that he's really really really mad and they'll play up to their talent level. Did Aikman take the year off?
 
InmanRoshi;3610676 said:
:laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: Romo doesn't get criticism :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2:


Romo is the most criticized career 90+ QB rating in NFL history. Choice fumbles a ball? It's Romo's fault. Bennett can't catch a pass that hits him in both hands? Romo's fault. Romo merely throws for 400 yards, 3 TDs ... he should have thrown for 500 yards and 5 TDs. Romo should have designed a defensive scheme for Wade that didn't make Vince Young look like the second coming of Dan Fouts. Romo should have taught the special teams units how to tackle.
Sad but it's so true.
 
To the point about broadcasting the game plan...it's a very valid point.

Now, I temper this with the awareness that I can't stand Jerry Jones...

But with regard to your comment, most of the comments come from Jerry. It's as if he wants the world to know how involved he is.

I found his public pushing for Felix to carry the ball more beyond foolish. Jones is a VERY different RB than Barber. Let the Titans prepare for Barber and then run more heavily with Felix.
 
I have no idea why in a game where the defense got lit up for 34 points to Vince friggin Young the onus is suddenly on Romo.

Guy got sacked 5 times in the first quarter. You do that to anyone - Manning, Brees, Rivers, anyone - and you are going to get a game like yesterday. The fact that he got it turned around enough to tie the game is amazing.

2 of his picks went off other people's hands. The other 1 - well when you throw the ball 46 times in a game that's what happens.

The bar set up for this guy is incredible.
 
Yakuza Rich;3610550 said:
- - And that’s kind of the point of this team. They are horribly UN-FUN to watch. It’s funny that back in ’08 they remarked about not liking Martellus Bennett’s ‘body language’, but the entire team outside of a handful of players has an unlikeable body language. And instead of wanting to watch football it’s become more or less a chore to watch these guys and their sloppy, uninspired play. If I had season tickets, I’d probably look to sell them on eBay right now

YR

I have tickets to both the Minnesota and Green Bay game.

They're both going up on StubHub/Ebay.
 
What exactly has Aaron Rodgers accomplished? Yet he's treated like he's a top 5 QB in this league.

What has Phillip Rivers done? No super bowls there, on an incredibly talented team with a very QB friendly coach.

What has Matt Shaub done? Nothing.

What has Jay Cutler, Carson Palmer, Vince Young? Former first round picks.

Tony Romo has played great considering the circumstances in Dallas. He plays behind a terribly inefficient offensive line, without a balanced attack and a competant coordinator. Put Romo on a team like the Chargers, Packers, Patriots, Saints, Colts, etc - and he'd be constantly putting his team in a position to win. But on this team, that constantly makes stupid penalties - and NEVER forces any turnovers to give the offense a short field. He makes the best of a bad situation. Factor in special teams, constantly making us lose the field position battle. Romo has done exceptionally well considering the circumstances.

Romo definitely isn't the problem, he's helped mask the line's problems for years with his mobility.

Romo is a top 5 QB in this league, even after yesterday's performance I can comfortably sit back and say that.
 
Romo isn't quite the leader you'd want for America's team... He does'nt have the Aikman or Staubach presence.
 
I just don't know what to make of this team. There are so many average teams right now that are freakin' 3-2, 3-1 that I think we are better than, and here we are 1-3. Good grief. The most frustrating part for me is the NFC is there for the taking this year.
 
I’m not blaming Romo for the loss. But I think his laid back attitude with the team doesn’t prevent the team from making dumb mistakes over the long haul. It’s like watching a parent let their kids do whatever they want and assume that they’ll eventually mature and stop acting like brats.

I thought the last INT was more of a bad playcall than anything. The INT to Bennett in the end zone should’ve been caught.

He’s hardly the main problem, but I think his lackadaisical attitude doesn’t prevent these vast amount of errors on offense being from made in the long run and I think the book is out on Romo when it comes to crucial plays and where he’s going. Why he cannot see that is beyond me.





YR
 
Yakuza Rich;3610770 said:
I’m not blaming Romo for the loss. But I think his laid back attitude with the team doesn’t prevent the team from making dumb mistakes over the long haul.

Can someone tell me what the physical signs are that shows that Romo has a "laid back" attitude? Is it the 3TD and 400 yards that he throws on the field part of it?
 
Great post YR....the only thing I disagree with is Romo. The laziness and ineptitude are bigger than him. He can rant, rave, "lead" and it won't be any different.
 
1997 - Cowboys 5th most penalized team in the NFL.
1998 - Cowboys 4th most penalized teams in the NFL.
1999 - Cowboys the most penalized team in the NFL.

Why didn't Aikman use his fiery personality and leadership abilities to get his teammates to knock it off?
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,696
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top