For fun who was the biggest FA bust for the Cowboys

75boyz

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,060
Reaction score
9,724
Roy Williams WR

Yeah, based on draft capital given up to acquire him I'll go with Galloway but with RW right behind him.

Based on contract alone, probably Brandon Carr. Although the bust term could be somewhat subjective to some in Carr's case as he never missed a game and he was overall solid.
It's just, in my eyes, 50 million at the time required more than just solid.
 

cern

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,900
Reaction score
21,050
I consider that two wrongs not making a right, avoiding something that you're not good at rather than working to get better at it.

But yeah, let's play another game, guess the last name of the guy that's been in charge of pro scouting for the last few years?
The apple fell far from the tree. Stephen is his own man. Thank god.
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,045
Reaction score
10,810
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
The list is long and undistinguished.

I'm going with Eddie George. They signed him in 2004. Apparently, he retired in 2003..

When he was with the Oilers/Titans, seven out of his eight seasons he rushed for well over a thousand yards. The other season he rushed for 939. He was a four time Pro Bowler, he was a thousand yard rusher the previous season.He had never nissed a start in his first eight seasons.

In Dallas he carried as many as 31 times and never got a 100 yards in a game.....not one.He looked old, tired and completely uninspired.
That Eddie George signing drove me nuts. He was obviously finished long before he ever put on a Cowboys' uniform. His yards per carry was 3.4 or lower in each of the three previous seasons, and he was never a receiving threat. He had only reached 1000 yards because they kept feeding him the ball. Running backs who get 310+ carries should never be barely clearing 1000 yards. Or more precisely, RBs who need 310 carries to get to 1000 yards shouldn't be getting anywhere near that many carries.
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,620
Reaction score
47,488
He wasn’t a trade, he was out of contract with Seattle who franchised him... and we were dumb enough to give up two firsts.
And for giving up two firsts and his subsequent production, I’d say he was our biggest free agency bust.
I've never heard that. You sure?
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,620
Reaction score
47,488
Yeah 100%... Not sure if the term was franchised back then, might have been slightly different... But he was definitely out of contract, Seattle franchised or whatever the term back then was, and it cost us two first rounders.
Just read up on it. It's sorta both. Galloway was franchised, which gave his rights to SEA. They then traded those rights to Dall for the two 1sts.
 

Cattle_Rancher

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,486
Reaction score
1,623
Sometimes I wonder if some smarter dudes like Bellychickens pass around the info about players like Carr. It was blatantly obvious he was a #2 type corner. And yes, I said it at the time. How did he gain the status of top player in FA? Way I see it, either someone lied or someone is stupid.

Yeah i viewed him as a top level number 2 and if I recall KC had a heck of a pass rush he benefited from. I would say cowboys front office does a poor job evaluating CB. Traded up for Mo, the kid they drafted in the first in 08, passed on Joseph to pursue the guy from Oakland who signed with Philly, then over paid Carr. Not a good record on choosing guys.
 

ottawacowpoke

Well-Known Member
Messages
451
Reaction score
468
What really compounds the Galloway signing was the report that came out a couple years afterwards that the pro personnel department recommended signing an unheralded free agent WR from Kansas City, but the Cowboys brain trust felt they needed more of a proven commodity to replace the star power Michael Irvin provided. The proven commodity was obviously Joey Galloway. The relatively unknown FA WR was Joe Horn, who went on have 4 Pro Bowl seasons over the next 5 years in New Orleans.

It makes you wonder what could have been if we had made just a few different decisions. The year before we let an ascending Patrick Jeffers get away in favor of signing Rocket Ismail. Carolina was all too happy to sign Jeffers to replace the departed Ismail, which should have been the first warning sign that were were miscalculating their value relative to one another.

Our salary cap situation was already in a precarious position in those days, and signing Raghib Ismail to a big money deal in 1999, followed by an even bigger money deal to Galloway in 2000 didn't make it any better.

It's hard not to wonder what difference a starting line up featuring less expensive / more productive players like Joe Horn and Patrick Jeffers in place of Joey Galloway and Rocket Ismail would have made. The cap difference between the two could have been used to shore up a roster that had talented but aging starters and little to no depth.

Those were some rough years.


Not to mention letting go of WR Jimmy Smith
 

Rayman70

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,470
Reaction score
31,984
Brandon Carr. He never could cover anyone. Paid a ton of money for him too.
 

Cowboysheelsreds053

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,810
Reaction score
11,072
Yeah, based on draft capital given up to acquire him I'll go with Galloway but with RW right behind him.

Based on contract alone, probably Brandon Carr. Although the bust term could be somewhat subjective to some in Carr's case as he never missed a game and he was overall solid.
It's just, in my eyes, 50 million at the time required more than just solid.

Both of those trade old Jerrah lost his pants.
 
Top