Don't know about extremely fair. They're offering him the same guaranteed amount as Goff on a 5-year offer as Goff got on a 4-year extension. Before folks try to jump in and say the extension is different because they were already under contract, they aren't. The extension really is a 4-year deal that they've spread out on top of money Goff and others were GOING TO MAKE already. Dak isn't under contract except the tag that goes away if he signs. There's nothing on top of anything. He just gets that deal. So if you want a 5th year, you have to up the guarantees, allow for a 5th year void, benchmark bonuses, etc.
I keep reposting the thread that had an article written by an agent that spoke about what Dak should look for if the Cowboys want to offer a 5-year deal. He took cash flows, the QB market, guaranteed at signing, etc. into consideration. He stated that a comparative deal for 5 years might come close to 5 years / $190M with close to $130M in guarantees. Don't think the $38M annual will happen but any fair-minded person would know that the same guarantee for Goff in 4 years is not equal on a 5-year deal, extension or not. This article even looked at those 3 deals I keep listing to show that Dak's offers aren't comparative.
https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/...yvT7iVqeIjgNSJ4QnRrSeBaK1JRFOaFUwWZvKNfdLZZEI
Wilson: 4 years, $140M ($107M guaranteed)
Goff: 4 years, $134M ($110M guaranteed)
Wentz: 4 years, $128M ($108M guaranteed)
No way Dak should sign anything rumored at this point.