RaZon
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 4,443
- Reaction score
- 3,188
Dan Marino is probably the 4/5 best QB of all time, as we know 0-1 in SB. While Brad Johnson and Trent Dilfer and Jim McMahan are SB champs. So just how important is winning the biggie to a QB's legacy?
Philip Rivers
Warren Moon
Fran Tarkenton
Dan Fouts
Jim Kelly
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
are on a par with
Eli Manning
Phil Simms
Joe Namath
Terry Bradshaw
Len Dawson
Doug Williams
Bart Starr
All SB champs.
Nobody thinks Jim McMahan was a great QB, he was no Dan Fouts. Fouts had one of the greatest offenses we have seen, three 1000 yard receivers and a stud RB, but a defense Alabama would have put 30 on. McMahan had the great Walter Payton and a D that had five future HOFers and a Mad Dog on it.
So just how much credit do we give a QB for SB success or failure?
The game Doug Williams had was incredible so, hmmmm?
Philip Rivers
Warren Moon
Fran Tarkenton
Dan Fouts
Jim Kelly
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
are on a par with
Eli Manning
Phil Simms
Joe Namath
Terry Bradshaw
Len Dawson
Doug Williams
Bart Starr
All SB champs.
Nobody thinks Jim McMahan was a great QB, he was no Dan Fouts. Fouts had one of the greatest offenses we have seen, three 1000 yard receivers and a stud RB, but a defense Alabama would have put 30 on. McMahan had the great Walter Payton and a D that had five future HOFers and a Mad Dog on it.
So just how much credit do we give a QB for SB success or failure?
The game Doug Williams had was incredible so, hmmmm?
Last edited: