How Stoked Would You Be If Jerry fires McCarthy after this season?

[Corso]

Fires McCarthy after this season,
Trades two 1st's for Payton, BUT:
He steps down and gives GM duties to his new Head Coach?

Not saying that is remotely going to happen and I know people are going to say "Not going to happen" all throughout this thread, but this is a what-if thing.

Anyone on board with this scenario?


And wow, I never start threads! Probably because I'm lame at it.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Jerry steps down?

I'm cool with it.

 

[Hagman]

1. Give two 1's for Payton? Or any other coach? No, we have a lot of holes to fill and can't afford to lose the capital.
2. Give up anything for Payton? Based on his record, he's McCarthy lite--and by about 80 pounds.
3. GM and head coach are full time jobs....need separate people to do them well.
4. Jerry steps down---heck to the yea.

 

[RodeoJake]

I'd not be stoked at all. Fine with firing McCarthy, but Payton ain't worth 2 1sts. I wouldn't give them one. I know many think he'd be Jimmy Johnson part 2, but I don't see it, even if Jerry and Stevie step aside.

 

[Corso]

1. Give two 1's for Payton? Or any other coach? No, we have a lot of holes to fill and can't afford to lose the capital.
2. Give up anything for Payton? Based on his record, he's McCarthy lite--and by about 80 pounds.
3. GM and head coach are full time jobs....need separate people to do them well.
4. Jerry steps down---heck to the yea.

On points 3 and 4: that's the crux of it and Payton has done it, like Belichick and YAY!!! Jerry steps down!

 

[Blast From The Past]

PIPE DREAM

 

[Corso]

I'd not be stoked at all. Fine with firing McCarthy, but Payton ain't worth 2 1sts. I wouldn't give them one. I know many think he'd be Jimmy Johnson part 2, but I don't see it, even if Jerry and Stevie step aside.

I'm surprised you'd rather keep Jerry as GM, but I get the loss of Draft capital.
It's not a perfect world I'm talking about.

 

[Hagman]

And wow, I never start threads! Probably because I'm lame at it.

And this is a dandy thread.........anything that envisions Jerry stepping down gets 5 stars in my book.

 

[Corso]

PIPE DREAM

And here's the first one. Called it.

 

[KJJ]

Fires McCarthy after this season,
Trades two 1st's for Payton, BUT:
He steps down and gives GM duties to his new Head Coach?

Not saying that is remotely going to happen and I know people are going to say "Not going to happen" all throughout this thread, but this is a what-if thing.

Anyone on board with this scenario?


And wow, I never start threads! Probably because I'm lame at it.

I would be absolutely beside myself if Jerry were to do that. That would indicate he’s gone completely bonkers! Lol Only an absolute fool would trade 2 number one picks for a burned out HC.

 

[Montanalo]

Fires McCarthy after this season,
Trades two 1st's for Payton, BUT:
He steps down and gives GM duties to his new Head Coach?

Not saying that is remotely going to happen and I know people are going to say "Not going to happen" all throughout this thread, but this is a what-if thing.

Anyone on board with this scenario?


And wow, I never start threads! Probably because I'm lame at it.

I would deal with the devil for Jerry to step down but not sure I would give up 2 first round choices.

 

[JBS]

Two firsts to get rid of Jerry is by far the best trade this franchise could make. H. Walker 2.0

 

[JBS]

I would deal with the devil for Jerry to step down but not sure I would give up 2 first round choices.

Dumb. Sorry but it’s a cheap price to pay.

 

[Corso]

I would be absolutely beside myself if Jerry were to do that. That would indicate he’s gone completely bonkers! Lol Only an absolute fool would trade 2 number one picks for a burned out HC.

Well yeah. What would you call Jerry at this point?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Fires McCarthy after this season,
Trades two 1st's for Payton, BUT:
He steps down and gives GM duties to his new Head Coach?

Not saying that is remotely going to happen and I know people are going to say "Not going to happen" all throughout this thread, but this is a what-if thing.

Anyone on board with this scenario?


And wow, I never start threads! Probably because I'm lame at it.

I thought you were going to say something else. And the answer would have been yes.

 

[Ekspozed]

If we are playing make believe, can I trade dak for Payton straight up, with Jerry and son still stepping aside?

 

[Corso]

I thought you were going to say something else. And the answer would have been yes.

But the current answer is no?

 

[JBS]

You guys are so dumb lolol

you’ve burned 30+ first round picks and you are willing to stick w the current regime and burn an unlimited amount of more first rounders just to save 2

You can’t be more stupid lolol

 

[KJJ]

Well yeah. What would you call Jerry at this point?

Well he’s certainly not a fool or he wouldn’t have the billions he has and have the richest franchise in the world. He has made some foolish moves before but I don’t see him make a foolish move like this. Jerry isn’t about to give up 2 number one picks for a burned out HC that he’s going to have to pay $10 million a year to stand around on the sidelines making facial expressions.

 

[Montanalo]

Dumb. Sorry but it’s a cheap price to pay.

"Dumb"? Did you miss my earlier post from the wine cellar?