LOL...based on that response you either don't watch film or you don't know what you're looking at when you do break down film. I would love....LOVE for you to give me even one game of film for me to go back and watch in Mingo's career where he looked like a #2WR. Campbell you could at least make a mild argument for based on a few of his 2022 games, but neither has been anywhere close to a consistent #2 guy. With the playing time they have been given neither has produced to a wr2 level. Mingo has a career 0.72 Yards per route run. Campbell a 1.01 y/rr. To compare Michael Gallup the year before he was forced into retirement was a 0.96. You're typical #2 types are going to be in the 1.4-1.8 range on average. The efficiency levels for both of these guys throughout their careers has been below average, and in Mingo's case is at a level where guys wont stick around to make a roster for very long.
But please if you have even one single game, especially on Mingo that shows him being a starting caliber WR I'm begging you to let me know which one it is. I'll absolutely go watch it and report back with what I find over the next day or two.
I've reviewed several of Mingo's NFL games.
- I find it really difficult to evalutate him.
- Obviously, if he was definitely going to be good in the future, then hewouldn't have been available.
Rookie Season:
- Rookie QB.
- The QB was often bad on his on and the OLine often struggled in Pass Protection.
Season 2:
- Most of his games in Carolina were with the 37 year old backup QB.
- His games in Dallas were with the backup QBs.
- An uncanny number of his targets with the Cowboys were what I consider uncatchable.
- Obviously, it's possible he was out of position relative to the QB's expectations on some of those.
- There were at least 2 plays where he was wide open but not targeted.
The only definitive thing I saw was that he is a very good blocker.
- That's become a more valueable skill with some of the modern era offenses.
- Rams and 49ers are the two the come to mind with regards to high expectations of their WRs to block.