Maxx Crosby or George Pickens?

[TasteMyScythe]

He may want it. He won’t get it. His injury history works against him. My guess is he signs a modest contract with Jacksonville depending on what they manage to draft.

He will sign before the draft. Players of his caliber don't last long.

He’d want to. I think teams would rather assess where they are post-draft before committing the money it will take to sign him.

Usually, teams sign FA before the draft so as not to have to force their picks, this letting them take the best player on their board. The only teams that sit on their hands and waits until after the draft is Dallas...picking scraps off the dump heap.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Did anybody pay attention to what happened when Cee Dee Lamb was hurt for several games. Without GP, Dallas had no offense.

So the answer is bring back GP in the event Ceedee may get hurt again….


LOL

 

[Q_the_man]

Easy.

We had Pickens. We were eliminated from the playoffs with 3 games left.

Let's try Crosby.

Amd the Raiders were eliminated week 5. Lol

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Amd the Raiders were eliminated week 5. Lol

Maybe Jerry will run it back like you want, bro.

 

[diamonddelts]

Maybe Jerry will run it back like you want, bro.

Sorry but he got you with your own logic on that one.

 

[diamonddelts]

Amd the Raiders were eliminated week 5. Lol

Well done.

 

[Bigrandrn]

Crosby is the biggest uneducated cry baby in the entire NFL. There’s never been an easier choice. Hell, he just left the team because he was told he wasn’t playing. Just listen to him talk for 5 minutes.

Pickens ain’t winning no intellectual debates either…..

 

[diamonddelts]

I will choose George Pickens all day and twice on Sunday. Pickens is younger with no major injuries. Crosby is four years older and may not be the same player after the knee surgery.

 

[Bigrandrn]

Remember guys, we had the top scoring and passing O in the league 2 years ago without Pickens and a lesser running game and similar oline. We need D help more than we need a number 2 like Pickens. Flournoy might be better than who we had as our #2 2 years ago too (old cooks and Gallup).

 

[diamonddelts]

But only in Dallas Has GM Leatherface fooled his low brow fans into thinking that you can never have a quality offense and defense with any semblance of roster depth at the same time.

 

[CATCH17]

Pickens.

He’s younger.

We just need a decent defense.

It’s not a defensive league. The chances of you building a legit defense are slim.

 

[CATCH17]

Easy.

We had Pickens. We were eliminated from the playoffs with 3 games left.

Let's try Crosby.

We can have Pickens and Add 2 first round defenders.

You’re right. It is easy.

Let’s stick with Pickens.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Hendrickson is also older and would eat up a much bigger chunk of cap. Crosby is under contract for 4 more seasons at an AAV under 30.

Only TWO seasons of guaranteed money .........C'mon D. You know that's what matters.
How are you thinking Hendrickson would eat up more of the cap with a new deal?


This is his market value according to Spotrac
https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/player/market-value/_/id/21845/trey-hendrickson

$25.5MAvg. Annual Salary

Market Value​

• 2 years, $51,089,038
• Avg. Salary: $25,544,519
• NFL Rank: 52

Current Contract​

• Free Agent: -
• Avg. Salary: -

Comparable Players​

 

[CATCH17]

It was very logical at the time. At least we use logic and not pick 4 wins every year because we hate Dak.
Also, I am not a big fan, but do not hate him.

Things happen during seasons that derail teams.
Educate us on hating a player so much it consumes you.

I’ve been a down on Dak for most of his career.

He was phenomenal this year.

He’s never been close to this good.

Maybe he statistically has been the same but the actual on field play by him has never been this good.

 

[CATCH17]

Remember guys, we had the top scoring and passing O in the league 2 years ago without Pickens and a lesser running game and similar oline. We need D help more than we need a number 2 like Pickens. Flournoy might be better than who we had as our #2 2 years ago too (old cooks and Gallup).

We have 2 first round picks and I’m sure we’ll have cap space to play around with to fix the defense.

Pickens is a game changer.

If you want Crosby then we better trade Pickens to a team like New England for a 1st & more.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Trey Hendrickson is also three years older and is going to want a long term deal worth 40m+

Hendrickson signed a $30M one year this season.....BEFORE his injury. How is he going to command $10M more following a season where he missed most of his games due to injury.

Trey Hendrickson is just as good, if not better than Crosby.........

$25.5MAvg. Annual Salary

Market Value​

• 2 years, $51,089,038
• Avg. Salary: $25,544,519
• NFL Rank: 52

Current Contract​

• Free Agent: -
• Avg. Salary: -

Comparable Players​

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Pickens ain’t winning no intellectual debates either…..

How do you know this????????

 

[Walker]

One is already on the team and the other one will require draft picks. Easy decision.

 

[Chasing6]

Damn......that's a tough one. I can't decide......

Crosby wants to play and Raiders want to lose. So they put him on IR. Even Raiders GM is smarter than GM Jethro.

 

[CowboyoWales]

He will sign before the draft. Players of his caliber don't last long.

Usually, teams sign FA before the draft so as not to have to force their picks, this letting them take the best player on their board. The only teams that sit on their hands and waits until after the draft is Dallas...picking scraps off the dump heap.

Yep, he's the best available and IT ONLY TAKES ONE TEAM TO BE DESPERATE ENOUGH TO PAY early and OVER THE ODDS (Caps for effect)......and that's not Jerry who's looking for a deal (that showcases his footballing/business genius).