That’s called a strawman argument.
I never said Dak was immune from criticism. In fact, I’ve said he HAS made bad throws.
Do you recall when Dak threw the incomplete pass in the end zone to CD, and CD looked at him and made a hand gesture? The announcer said that CD was saying “I know what you were thinking there”.
Both the WR and the QB are reading the defense and adjusting their decision based on what they’ve read. They ought to read the same thing. Sometimes they don’t, and it looks like a bad throws when, in fact, they just read it differently.
Dak can throw the ball, but someone has to catch the ball. When that doesn’t happen, it’s not automatically the fault of the QB (even when this forum desperately wants to blame Dak).
Sometimes it WAS a bad throw. The very best QB’s in history have bad throws and even lots of interceptions.
This forum has a lot of people who think in very binary terms. If Dallas wins, it was this or that or maybe lots of reasons.
If Dallas loses, it’s because Dak sucks.
Statistics and some knowledge of football proves that to be largely untrue.
I can name 25 QB’s I’d take Dak over every single game, and only a handful I’d perhaps want instead.
That’s me.
I can think of 25 defenses I’d rather have right now.
In my view, the conversation we will begin to read about is shortly to be “how long will Dallas continue with CP as defensive coordinator”. 3 games in is too early, but the early returns are pretty terrible.