Kiper mid season Rookie rating

[supercowboy8]

14. Frederick
16. Terrence Williams
30 JJ Wilcox

Look like that trade everyone bashed Jerry on has paid off this season thus far.
I remember all the slack Jerry took for not taking Floyd. Floyd isn't even on the list.

http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/9871367/nfl-afc-east-stars-top-mel-kiper-rookie-rankings

 

[CooterBrown]

Kiper is an idiot who has no more insight than any of us. Because I put no value on his draft evaluations, I put no value on his rookie evaluations.

 

[T-RO]

14. Frederick
16. Terrence Williams
30 JJ Wilcox

Look like that trade everyone bashed Jerry on has paid off this season thus far.
I remember all the slack Jerry took for not taking Floyd. Floyd isn't even on the list.

http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/9871367/nfl-afc-east-stars-top-mel-kiper-rookie-rankings

Yes Jerry got the best of his critics...this once.

 

[chagus]

Kiper is an idiot who has no more insight than any of us. Because I put no value on his draft evaluations, I put no value on his rookie evaluations.

So much fer this thread. haa!

 

[bark]

Three rooks already in the starting lineup and major contributors. A+ draft ( yes I know about out TE fetish)

 

[Titleist]

Surprising not to see the "can't miss" guard, Chance Warmack on the list. Add to that Jonathan Cooper suffering the same fate as DeCastro last year, and I'd say that we struck gold with Fred plus the extra pick.

Also, anybody find it ridiculous that Keenan Allen is #7 while TWill is #13 with nearly identical stats? What gives there? More anti-Cowboys bias?

 

[supercowboy8]

Three rooks already in the starting lineup and major contributors. A+ draft ( yes I know about out TE fetish)

The future can only tell the story on escobar but right now it would have been nice have gotten Warford but then I doubt we would have signed Waters

 

[TheCount]

Escobar is the only actual pick I questioned and still question, but it's still year 1.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Escobar is the only actual pick I questioned and still question, but it's still year 1.

Me too.

 

[Zordon]

TE jordan reed at #10. did the cowboys have any interest in him?

 

[Zordon]

Also, anybody find it ridiculous that Keenan Allen is #7 while TWill is #13 with nearly identical stats? What gives there? More anti-Cowboys bias?

allen is good and kiper said in his comments that t-will is headed for the top 10.

 

[Miller]

I see he has both safeties we looked at up high. I'd love to draft a safety for the long haul

 

[Zekeats]

TE jordan reed at #10. did the cowboys have any interest in him?

Probably had him rated as a second rounder as they usually do for TEs

 

[Zekeats]

I would love to see Kipers amazing predraft rankings for all of his midseason rankings. Gotta love how this guy even makes money off of any of the BS him and McShay put out there.

 

[jazzcat22]

Yes Jerry got the best of his critics...this once.

Yes but they won't focus on this time...they will still focus on the past....

 

[jazzcat22]

Escobar is the only actual pick I questioned and still question, but it's still year 1.

Last week, every draft pick played and contributed in some capacity [even if only on ST's] in the Eagles victory. Except Holloman who had an injury and was inactive. But we know he would have if was healthy.

 

[mldardy]

Escobar is the only actual pick I questioned and still question, but it's still year 1.

I don't question his talent because I think he has some like Bennett does but I question will we use him.

 

[reddyuta]

Escobar is the only actual pick I questioned and still question, but it's still year 1.

lets face it:Escobar will not do much as long as Witten is playing,its the definition of a wasted pick.

 

[ThreeandOut]

I don't question his talent because I think he has some like Bennett does but I question will we use him.

Williams success is partially to blame for them not using Escobar. The offense has done a lot better with 3 WRs than 2 TEs.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Kiper is an idiot who has no more insight than any of us. Because I put no value on his draft evaluations, I put no value on his rookie evaluations.

Jealous of the hair? J/K in all seriousness he is very knowledgable. That being said I don't think his judgement about players in the NFL and how they perform is at the same level as the college kids.