Initial Thoughts on the Seahawks game

If we're going that conservative, we should have stuck with Weeden. No need to trade for this bum. He has a pop gun arm. Dumb as a box of rocks, too.

We gave up an asset for little in return. In retrospect, benching Weeden seems like a kneejerk reaction to public pressure that was not justified by Cassell's ability to play QB. This organization always seems so reactive without a prevailing philosophy or coherent plan going forward.

The various blame threads try to isolate one source for the team's failure, but at the end of the day it requires a strong organization to consistently field a competitive team year after year.
 
I agree with most of what you wrote, very good write up as usual by the way. That 4th down spot and the 12 men on the field were inexcusable. I still don't understand how that is not a first down.
 
I haven't read a single peep about the HP pass called the other day (could have missed one in all the complaint vomit on the board of course). With long standing complaints about vanilla playcalling, I would have thought it might get a mention. Or do none of the complainers actually watch the games? Or does it not count because it didn't work?
 
1. They really really don't trust C-Mike for some reason. Either they don't want him to pass block or he just does not know/understand the playbook.

I was careful to watch every play Michael was in and it's obvious he doesn't quite get the pass protection (again, it's not a playbook thing...it's a reading the defense and stoning the blitzer thing). Every play he was in he either got the ball on a rushing carry or went directly out for a pass. Michael is a bit on the short side and Rod Smith is about 6 inches taller than him. So I wonder if it is more of a size and technique issue than reading defenses. Of course, with smaller size means your technique has to be sharper.



3. Jeff Heath made some plays. He looked really good on pass coverage deep down the right sideline. He came up with a big stop and 3rd down. There was a question on the TD on who should have been in coverage, him or Church. Broaddus says he will get the answer but it looked like Church blew the coverage to me.

That looked all on Church to me. Just by body language alone. It looked like Church thought Willson was going outside and he got beat badly.


4. The issues with the Refs is getting old. The incompetence is tiring. I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but I do think some individual Refs have certain biases. Maybe a bias for or against a team. Maybe a bias for the home team. Maybe a bias to be overly critical of certain types of plays in an attempt to get noticed by their bosses. Whatever the issue, it is really getting old. I really wish there was some way to petition the NFL for drastic changes. Maybe full time refs would help or maybe better disciplinary actions for bad calls. It's not just against the Cowboys. I see it in other games where they at times appear biased and at other times just incompetent.

It's ridiculous to watch. It reminds me of 2005 all over again.

Either way, the NFL doesn't know how to address the problem. IMO, McFadden did by all intents and purposes...fumble the ball. They had a solid rule in place, but because Dean Blandino gave the incorrect ruling on the Dez catch...now blatantly obvious catches are no longer catches and blatantly obvious fumbles are no longer fumbles.

I do think that refs have biases, but I don't think it showed up here. I just think this is flat-out incompetence and it is set up by have a clown that has never refereed a game before on any level as the head of the refs.


5. The Cowboys defense was definitely good enough to win so I don't want to complain much about them; however, they still seem to have no consistent answer for the legal pick play. The Seahawks got at least 2 critical 3rd down conversions on legal pick plays. It is super easy for their QB to see pre-snap where the receiver will be open due to a pick play.

To me, it's poor play recognition from the corners and we don't have the MLB out there to stop it. I also think they ask a lot out of their corners because the safeties are limited in coverage. What I see out of Carr and Claiborne is that they cannot stop those long comeback routes with any consistency. It tells me that they are afraid of getting beat deep, likely because there is little safety help and the WR can get easy separation.


11. Doug Free had multiple bad plays again. The Cowboys had a great off-season except for retaining Free and Weed. It would be almost impossible for a rookie 3rd round pick that missed all of the off-season to come off of the PUP and do much, but if Green has anything he might be an upgrade at RT. It appears my dream of Leary getting healthy and Collins moving to RT is dead, at least for this year. Physically Collins compared to Free is like the Terminator compared to PeeWee Herman.

Collins probably isn't moving to RT and I really don't think he should. Hopefully, Garrett and company have read books on the science of movement pattern training, skill acquisition and motor skill learning. Switching Collins to RT would probably be a very bad idea because the movements are so different. He would also have to get time to alter his body to be better suited at RT. Combine that with the speed of the game and still refining his techniques...it would be a missed opportunity to at least develop a great left guard if we move him to RT.

Free had too many negative plays for sure, but he still has many good plays. I doubt Green would accumulate as many positive plays as Free and would probably have as many negative plays...if not more. The RT position has to be addressed next season because Romo's best years have come when the RT play has been good. If Collins continues to progress at this rate, I would then consider giving him a shot at RT in the offseason.





YR
 
Pay Hardy. Crawford is average at best. Pay Hardy. Lawrence is average at best. Pay Hardy. You can't afford to lose him.

The officiating on huge possession determining and scoring plays has killed us. I've never seen a player dive out of bounds and ruled inbounds in my 30+ years of watching football.

How Dallas has found themselves with 2, count them 2, backup QBs that can't operate a functional passing offense is the story of the season. Period. The team would be 4-3 easy with a QB worth a darn. And don't give me a bunch of empty stats racked up throwing 2 yd out paterns to TEs and RBs.

Props to David Irving for making a great individual play. But STs overall have been terrible.

Did you see how hard Hardy was driving on that field goal to? His hand was pretty close to Irving getting push. Hardy is raising havoc wherever he is...
 
If we're going that conservative, we should have stuck with Weeden. No need to trade for this bum. He has a pop gun arm. Dumb as a box of rocks, too.

I actually agree. Weeden stinks but Cassel has made a number of god awful throws that seem to slip out of his hand. The checkdown game plan w Weeden may have worked at least once in the last two weeks
 
I actually agree. Weeden stinks but Cassel has made a number of god awful throws that seem to slip out of his hand. The checkdown game plan w Weeden may have worked at least once in the last two weeks

At least Weedens passes have some velocity on them , Cassel looks like he is " punting the ball"
 
At least Weedens passes have some velocity on them , Cassel looks like he is " punting the ball"

He seemed to flat out choke at the end too. Looked nervous and indecisive and made horrific throws. We only needed 30 yards with a minute left and 2 or 3 checkdowns may have actually done it
 
He seemed to flat out choke at the end too. Looked nervous and indecisive and made horrific throws. We only needed 30 yards with a minute left and 2 or 3 checkdowns may have actually done it

Agree. We have Bailey who would give us a good chance from even 55-60 and we aren't playing like we want to use him. I for one kept thinking Tony would at least get us into range, Cassel looked like he was more concerned with no creating a game ending turnover.

This was do or die time. Better to go down trying to win, than looking totally incompetent.
 
I haven't read a single peep about the HB pass called the other day (could have missed one in all the complaint vomit on the board of course). With long standing complaints about vanilla playcalling, I would have thought it might get a mention. Or do none of the complainers actually watch the games? Or does it not count because it didn't work?

Complainers aside, since what they say isn't important anyway, that was a little bit of razzle-dazzle. Would have been more dazzling if it had actually worked, but it was fun to see. Good time and place to use it, too.
 
Complainers aside, since what they say isn't important anyway, that was a little bit of razzle-dazzle. Would have been more dazzling if it had actually worked, but it was fun to see. Good time and place to use it, too.

That's an interesting comment from a moderator on an internet message forum.
 
That's an interesting comment from a moderator on an internet message forum.

I don't care what complainers say when their complaints aren't grounded in what's actually happening on the field. Not a whit. Not a smidgeon. Not an iota. It doesn't matter to me. At all.

I also don't care how many people tell me McDonalds is 'ok food.' And I don't care what's going with the Kardashians, if that gives some perspective.

I will enforce the forum guidelines, though. I don't see where those things overlap all that much, I guess.
 
I don't care what complainers say when their complaints aren't grounded in what's actually happening on the field. Not a whit. Not a smidgeon. Not an iota. It doesn't matter to me. At all.

I also don't care how many people tell me McDonalds is 'ok food.' And I don't care what's going with the Kardashians, if that gives some perspective.

I will enforce the forum guidelines, though. I don't see where those things overlap all that much, I guess.

How can you lump everyone in and say complaints aren't grounded in what's on the field. Come on man you are better than that. What is on the field is 5 straight losses.
 
4. The issues with the Refs is getting old. The incompetence is tiring. I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but I do think some individual Refs have certain biases. Maybe a bias for or against a team. Maybe a bias for the home team. Maybe a bias to be overly critical of certain types of plays in an attempt to get noticed by their bosses. Whatever the issue, it is really getting old. I really wish there was some way to petition the NFL for drastic changes. Maybe full time refs would help or maybe better disciplinary actions for bad calls. It's not just against the Cowboys. I see it in other games where they at times appear biased and at other times just incompetent.

Sorry but it's more than just an incompetent ref or two. Many of these screwy calls are happening (or standing) even after dead time or commercial breaks.

It's quite obvious to objective observers that the game has been corrupted by the gambling influence. The opportunity for the league itself--or individual referees--to make extra money through engineered results is just too tempting when billions (!) of dollars are being gambled.

This type of systemic results-engineering has been documented, published and validated in pro sports by an FBI investigation and book from the inside by an NBA referee. It's the same thing now only with football.
 
LOL. Yea...Eli had twice the number of TD passes yesterday as our backups have had in total since Tony went down (Eli 6 yesterday, Cassell/Weeden 3 in 5+ games). If 6 TD's is "getting your teeth kicked in", I wish someone would start kicking Cassell in the mouth.
 
How can you lump everyone in and say complaints aren't grounded in what's on the field. Come on man you are better than that. What is on the field is 5 straight losses.

I didn't say all complaints aren't grounded in what's on the field. Some of them are, and some of them aren't.

But we both know there's a significant contingent of fans who will complain just to complain, regardless of the who-what-why of what's actually going on. With 5 straight losses, there is plenty of criticism to go around. But criticizing and complaining aren't the same thing.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
464,234
Messages
13,798,869
Members
23,775
Latest member
KingMe21457
Back
Top