Vander Esch

Irvin88_4life

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,492
Reaction score
26,367
To me they aren’t even on the same page as prospects...

Landry and Ridley were the BPAs available by a good sized margin.
Landry didn't even get drafted in the first round so that means 12 picks made after ours didn't feel Landry was best player available either
 

DcFootball4

Active Member
Messages
253
Reaction score
169
I disagree. Dak is going to have no where to go with the ball at this rate. Look for teams to load the box , stuff the short throws, and give Zeke fits again b/c we have nobody on the outside they need to worry about.

I liked the pick just because I like the focus on defense. But, IMO, Dak will do just fine as-long as we can establish the run. He has enough ammunition to produce with the current talent, not to mention what will come in the later rounds.
 

csirl

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,732
Reaction score
4,035
I have a question - how are we going to use the player.

I'll openly admit that I have not seen any footage of him other than the various highlights films of draft prospects.

It's correct to say he was drafted for his athletic traits rather than to play a specific role?

He's a 6-4 256lb linebacker. Likely will end up c.270lbs in the pros - bigger than some DL players. I can see potential as a run stopper and a great foil for Barkley of the Giants.

However, the trend in the NFL is towards LBs with hybrid LB/SS skills - Jaylon is one. Smaller more mobile players who can cover slot receivers and pass catching speedy running backs.

I just dont see any 270lb player - no matter how great an athlete - being able to cover small speedy turn on a dime slots such as Edelman or RBs such as Kamara.

Can this guy play in the increasing number of situations where 2 x quick mobile LBs are needed? If so, he must be the greatest athlete of all time!
 

Melonfeud

I Copy!,,, er,,,I guess,,,ah,,,maybe.
Messages
21,976
Reaction score
33,152
This has to be considered a commentary on what the team thinks about Jaylon Smith’s progress.
Or Not!,,, NOW! were a Q.B. scooped up in the first round?,,,well then BULLEIT BOB,,,:huh:
that would sing volumes,,,o_O





:starspin::star::starspin:
 

dallas72

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,369
Reaction score
835
I have a question - how are we going to use the player.

I'll openly admit that I have not seen any footage of him other than the various highlights films of draft prospects.

It's correct to say he was drafted for his athletic traits rather than to play a specific role?

He's a 6-4 256lb linebacker. Likely will end up c.270lbs in the pros - bigger than some DL players. I can see potential as a run stopper and a great foil for Barkley of the Giants.

However, the trend in the NFL is towards LBs with hybrid LB/SS skills - Jaylon is one. Smaller more mobile players who can cover slot receivers and pass catching speedy running backs.

I just dont see any 270lb player - no matter how great an athlete - being able to cover small speedy turn on a dime slots such as Edelman or RBs such as Kamara.

Can this guy play in the increasing number of situations where 2 x quick mobile LBs are needed? If so, he must be the greatest athlete of all time!
Well hes 247. Not 270...and last i looked Rolondo McClain was 6 4 255....Ray Lewis was 245, clay mathews 6 3 255, Jaylon is 6 3 245, just to name a few
 

csirl

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,732
Reaction score
4,035
Well hes 247. Not 270...and last i looked Rolondo McClain was 6 4 255....Ray Lewis was 245, clay mathews 6 3 255, Jaylon is 6 3 245, just to name a few

He weighed 256 at both combine and pro day. A lot of reports say he is still filling out his large frame - likely 270 after time in NFL S&C program.
 

CalPolyTechnique

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,369
Reaction score
44,161
I have a question - how are we going to use the player.

I'll openly admit that I have not seen any footage of him other than the various highlights films of draft prospects.

It's correct to say he was drafted for his athletic traits rather than to play a specific role?

He's a 6-4 256lb linebacker. Likely will end up c.270lbs in the pros - bigger than some DL players. I can see potential as a run stopper and a great foil for Barkley of the Giants.

However, the trend in the NFL is towards LBs with hybrid LB/SS skills - Jaylon is one. Smaller more mobile players who can cover slot receivers and pass catching speedy running backs.

I just dont see any 270lb player - no matter how great an athlete - being able to cover small speedy turn on a dime slots such as Edelman or RBs such as Kamara.

Can this guy play in the increasing number of situations where 2 x quick mobile LBs are needed? If so, he must be the greatest athlete of all time!

This post is hilarious, smh.
 

Rayman70

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,686
Reaction score
32,243
He weighed 256 at both combine and pro day. A lot of reports say he is still filling out his large frame - likely 270 after time in NFL S&C program.
he can come off the edge time and again...
 

dallas72

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,369
Reaction score
835
He weighed 256 at both combine and pro day. A lot of reports say he is still filling out his large frame - likely 270 after time in NFL S&C program.
Dont see 270 though...255 probably his weight ..needs to maintain his speed
 

Rayman70

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,686
Reaction score
32,243
Vander Reach scares me from a football schematic POV. Not sure he is a fit.
 

buybuydandavis

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,913
Reaction score
20,989
But honestly, if the coaches would quit forcing him to be a pocket passer he would be better off. The kid needs to move out of the pocket. He is best when he is not forcing himself to stay in the pocket.

I remember when Garrett similarly forced Romo to stay in the pocket, while teams had been spending a lot of energy trying to keep him in the pocket because of how effective he was on rollouts. Funny, I remember Romo getting injured in the pocket, not on rollouts.

Garrett's gonna Garrett

Of course Dak should be rolling out. One thing we saw in 2016 was how he was more accurate rolling out than in the pocket. He's really good at it.

It's mentally much simpler to be chased from one direction than to be surrounded by tacklers you're trying to avoid. Pocket presence is not Dak's strong suit. They should let him roll.
 

Rogerthat12

DWAREZ
Messages
14,453
Reaction score
9,867
I have a question - how are we going to use the player.

I'll openly admit that I have not seen any footage of him other than the various highlights films of draft prospects.

It's correct to say he was drafted for his athletic traits rather than to play a specific role?

He's a 6-4 256lb linebacker. Likely will end up c.270lbs in the pros - bigger than some DL players. I can see potential as a run stopper and a great foil for Barkley of the Giants.

However, the trend in the NFL is towards LBs with hybrid LB/SS skills - Jaylon is one. Smaller more mobile players who can cover slot receivers and pass catching speedy running backs.

I just dont see any 270lb player - no matter how great an athlete - being able to cover small speedy turn on a dime slots such as Edelman or RBs such as Kamara.

Can this guy play in the increasing number of situations where 2 x quick mobile LBs are needed? If so, he must be the greatest athlete of all time!

Doubt he plays at 270 regardless and he is a lean 256lbs primarily due to his height and structure.

His coverage skills, height, length and closing speed are the primary reasons they like the player along with his athleticism with instincts.

He will play the Mike most likely can handle the run but is excellent in coverage.
 

visionary

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,701
Reaction score
32,175
Hes replacing Hitch....has nothing to do with Smith

You guys keep parroting this but Hitch is nit a great long term starter at MLB. Letting him go is one of the smart things we did so we're not "trying to replace him"

We have a huge need at MLB because this FO did what it usually does, make a decision with its heart rather than its brain in taking a player who we had no business drafting at the top of rd 2

We just need to hope LVE turns out to be a great great MLB
 

visionary

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,701
Reaction score
32,175
Doubt he plays at 270 regardless and he is a lean 256lbs primarily due to his height and structure.

His coverage skills, height, length and closing speed are the primary reasons they like the player along with his athleticism with instincts.

He will play the Mike most likely can handle the run but is excellent in coverage.

Agree

He better be able to handle the run otherwise we're in trouble esp with the smaller DTs we stupidly like to trot out there
 

cnuball21

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,320
Reaction score
9,397
one reason LB made sense....its not as deep as the WR class.
You could stretch it to the 4th or 5th if you wanted.
They wont....but you couldnt do that at LB.
I mocked Ridley to us at 19...and the LB options start to run thin.
This was a good pick.
Give it a chance.

I do with this 100%...I made a post about it too saying I’d be cool with us going LB to take advantage of thebWar and OG depth later, I just didn’t see Landry falling.

If there are injury concerns I’m on board with the pick.
 

cnuball21

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,320
Reaction score
9,397
I have a question - how are we going to use the player.

I'll openly admit that I have not seen any footage of him other than the various highlights films of draft prospects.

It's correct to say he was drafted for his athletic traits rather than to play a specific role?

He's a 6-4 256lb linebacker. Likely will end up c.270lbs in the pros - bigger than some DL players. I can see potential as a run stopper and a great foil for Barkley of the Giants.

However, the trend in the NFL is towards LBs with hybrid LB/SS skills - Jaylon is one. Smaller more mobile players who can cover slot receivers and pass catching speedy running backs.

I just dont see any 270lb player - no matter how great an athlete - being able to cover small speedy turn on a dime slots such as Edelman or RBs such as Kamara.

Can this guy play in the increasing number of situations where 2 x quick mobile LBs are needed? If so, he must be the greatest athlete of all time!

He'll be our starting MIKE at some point. In the post draft presser, the Boys were comparing him to him to RoMac and love his size/length and ability to fill gaps in run lanes and cover in zone as well.

He's not going to play at 270 lol
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
He'll be our starting MIKE at some point. In the post draft presser, the Boys were comparing him to him to RoMac and love his size/length and ability to fill gaps in run lanes and cover in zone as well.

He's not going to play at 270 lol

He may be MLB this year. Stephen Jones was saying Lee at WLB, Smith SLB and Vander Esch is MLB. Guess we will see how this plays out. Great thing is all 3 guys are willing to do whatever is asked of them by the coaching staff.
 

Cap12

Well-Known Member
Messages
785
Reaction score
572
Evans is supremely more talented.
"physically more talented perhaps, but he doesn't have the size to be an every down LB in our system. You don't want to spend a 1st round draft pick on a part time player.
 
Top