NFL: Gil Brandt's 25 greatest NFL running backs of all time (Emmitt 11th)

Hardline

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,847
Reaction score
36,405
Which makes his 5.0 ypc career average even more impressive. And you simply can’t compare the olines. Emmitt had a much better one....better than Walter’s too.

I understand that on a Cowboys forum, the majority will see things in Emmitt’s favor...and that’s fine. I’ll just say not everyone out there thinks he’s the best ever simply because of the yardage record.
No great running back achieved anything without a good to great offensive line. The offensive line excuse can be used for any great running back.

Barry had pro bowlers in front of him also.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
Here, let's put it another way:

Emmitt was a ferocious between the tackles runner. He attacked the A and B gap. Gogan, Tuinei, Newton, Step all led the way for him, sure, but after he got to the second level, back then, OL were usually left behind. Only recently have OL been taught to reach that second level. Still, those fellas mauled mofos.

Sanders was a sweep or C gap runner. He swept out and took off. That's why he met so many DL behind the LOS -- cuz he had no OL in front of him anymore, he pushed out too far to the left or right, so as to give his natural ability it's best way of being used.

In Dallas, while we did have some awesome tackles, our bread and butter was right up the middle baby. Right up that arse hole of the DTs position.

Sanders in Dallas would be a whole different deal. A whole different style. We cannot predict what he would have done here. Emmitt was the goat between the tackles runner of the 90s, Sanders outside the tackles.

Emmitt also blocked. Emmitt also could be relied on to catch out of the backfield in an era where RBs weren't asked to do it too often. It is much more employed in today's NFL.

Barry, higher peak. Emmitt, more sustained greatness. Emmitt GOAT. Guesses at what, who and who would do what here are purely subjective and an insult to our all-time great, imo -- in the same vein as those folks that use our OL against him.
 

Hardline

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,847
Reaction score
36,405
Sanders had better than average lines for a good part of his career, very good a couple seasons when the Lions twice had a top 5 ranked offense. Not only did he have the great Lomas Brown, but also he had Kevin Glover at center. That's two perennial Pro Bowl-caliber o-linemen. I'd also include solid guys like Fralic (also a Pro Bowler), Lutz, Tharpe and Eric Sanders. The big myth is that he always had 'atrocious', 'horrible' o-lines. It makes it easier to inflate Sanders as a rb; something he doesn't need. It's disrespectful to his linemen, two of which were among the best of their time, and to the game itself.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,448
Reaction score
36,613
While Emmit was the most accomplished RB in Cowboy history I don’t think he was the most gifted in talent .

Dorsett and Herschel both IMO had more raw ability . Emmit just made the most of his.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
You did watch Sanders play? Right??

You still thought Emmitt had more raw god given ability and talent?

Gil’s list isn’t about best careers.

Emmitt as one poster above said correctly was great for Dallas. Nothing else matters but that doesn’t mean he was the greatest back in NFL.
Yes I did. I loved him. What a freak of nature. His peak talent is greater than anything I've seen, maybe other than Deion or Larry Allen.

No, I don't, and I never said that.

Not concerned with Gil's list at this point, as much as I am posts in this thread.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,448
Reaction score
36,613
How many fans here watched OJ run for 2,000 yards in Buffalo on that awful field and snow games behind a non playoff team?

That was greatness!!! And in 14 games. Only a handful of players in NFL history I’d even place in comparison with those moves and ability.
Sayers, Dorsett and Sanders for starters.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
Emmitt was the perfect running back for that team and that's the only thing that matters.
This, thanks Avianno. I explained it a little more in-depth above.

Someone can probly do better, but I think I covered the essence of it pretty well.

Still, sometimes beauty is in it's simplicity, and this post of yours is banger-on, brudda
 

buybuydandavis

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,844
Reaction score
20,915
http://www.nfl.com/photoessays/0ap3...n=fb-nf-sf193174917-sf193174917&sf193174917=1
Come on now!? Must be click bait crap right ?!
Emmitt is at least top 3. I’ll give people Barry and Payton. I don’t really agree with them. But I see their point.

Jim Brown is #1.

I'd say it's arguable between Emmitt. Payton, Sanders.
Dickerson, OJ, Tomlinson, Faulk. Arguable.

Emmitt has a good claim based on how well rounded he was. He's leading the NFL in rushing and tds, and catching 50 balls. Leading in yards from scrimmage and touchers.

Brandt put Tony D over Emmitt. Any even older than me timers want to stick up for that one? I don't see it.

Weird list. He's got Bo Jackson 4th. Certainly a superfreak, but that seems like some big crazy talk to me. Career was too short and undistinguished.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,448
Reaction score
36,613
Rushing Leaders
RK
PLAYER YDS
1 Emmitt Smith 18,355
2 Walter Payton 16,726
3 Barry Sanders 15,269
Numbers dont lie
But they don’t describe “ best” . Just most accomplished.

I’m pretty sure Gil’s list of most accomplished would have been different than best.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,448
Reaction score
36,613
Well then that's productive in a message board thread lol

i wont repeat myself, if you care to know my stance, click on the first three pages of the thread. it's all there for ya.

if ya don't want to be bothered with it, then i you and posts like this.
I never read thru pages of post. Just pick up on last page.

I’m not picking sides . That Eagle fan I’m not interested in. I’ve tangled with him before . I just don’t know anyone but some overly homerish Cowboy fans that would say Emmitt was more talented or greater RB than Sanders. That doesn’t mean Emmitt didn’t have a greater career. Certainly more accomplished.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
I never read thru pages of post. Just pick up on last page.

I’m not picking sides . That Eagle fan I’m not interested in. I’ve tangled with him before . I just don’t know anyone but some overly homerish Cowboy fans that would say Emmitt was more talented or greater RB than Sanders. That doesn’t mean Emmitt didn’t have a greater career. Certainly more accomplished.
dude just read a few posts above. stop quarreling w me. it's post 143. i can shoot you a link?
 
Top