I didn't ask you who you liked or didn't like or who did this or who did that. Initially you said.......
but there lies the difference, given elite options the other QBs win championships and put up 5000 yard season. dak becomes above average....its what you are able to accomplish if you have those type of options at your disposal.
So I listed other young quarterbacks who have elite options around them who don't have rings. So maybe I'm not understanding you so help me out. What QB's were you referring to that have elite options that win championships?
so as you said....
given elite options the other QBs win championships and put up 5000 yard season....
and then you listed a bunch of QBs....and as I mentioned I don't consider Cousin, Mariota or Winston above Dak.
Rogers, Brees, Brady, Roth, Wilson, foles, flacco, eli, some others that had weapons and made it to the superbowl, like Ryan, goff, newton.....
now, as I also mentioned, when Dak does that given the elite weapons he is given, then I will change my mind. when Dak becomes a top 10 passer in the league with the weapons he has, I will change my mind. until then, he has been an average passer, relying on the scheme and a bus driver. nothing wrong with that.
Its not about being naive its just about getting you to make sense of what you're saying. You are contradicting your own statements. All of the smakes no sense to me. So basically your point is that Dak should make Garrett into a great head coach?
See how silly that sounds?
and what I said, which you are twisting, that great coaches, good coaches, make good players into great, great players into elite and average players into good. they need to have the resources to accomplish their vision. Just like any other CEO of a company.....
without those resources, they can't waive a wand to create magic, but good coaches have the ability to take a group of good to great players and win championships or great coaches win multiple championships. the players have to be able to execute the vision. however, just throwing in a bunch of great/elite players together doesn't necessarily add up to championships, if the coach isn't any good or have the right vision. Dann Quinn had the right vision, had the players and took atlanta to the superbowl...his predecessor didn't. pretty much similar resources. parcells a great coach was able to take giants to the superbowl and the jets to AFCG...but in dallas he failed, given he had quincy carter, yet he took a crappy player and was able to get him to 10-6. no playoff wins. not championship.....
so the question is if Garrett is the right coach with the right vision and has the right players? is Dak the right player? or is Dak in the right system surrounded by elite players?
not sure why its hard to understand....you are seemingly twisting to defend Dak in one way or the other and that much is obvious, so no need to twist my words. just come out and say you like Dak, you think he is elite or great and just be done with it.