NFL Total Access Ranks the NFC East QBs

[gimmesix]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

I think Dak and Wentz can be debated for the No. 1 spot, but anyone who ranks Eli above either is living in the past ... when he wasn't great, but at least had moments of brilliance.

 

[DandyDon52]

I have no beef with that ranking order. Flying under the radar can be used to our advantage. They'll be forced to reevaluate their list and put Dak at the top eventually. Eli is washed up and Wentz just doesn't win enough.

I agree Joe, who cares about these rankings anyway? They are just someones opinion, that is all.
All that matters is how they all do this season, and 2 of those could be replaced before the season is over.
I think wash may start their Rookie depending on how he looks in TC and PS, and Eli if things dont go well could get replaced.
So you have to include those guys that may step in early or late too.
And if Wentz goes down again, they aint got nobody to step in. Phil was I think hasty to sign him, I would want to see him
finish a season before that contract.

 

[Whyjerry]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

Here is what I find interesting...

Eli Manning hasn’t won a playoff game since 2011. He hasn’t been a good QB since 2015. Pretty sure every GM in the league would rather have Dak today. As I have gotten older and wiser I have learned that these media experts have no expertise at all. Just opinions. Opinions are formed by bias most times. What is said in the media today is typically meant to incite a reaction. I guess that is what this moron is doing.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

eli!! WTH.....I can see the argument between wentz and Dak...but Eli!

 

[Qbert]

Who said this crap , was it Shaun O’Hara?

Who said this crap , was it Shaun O’Hara?

Yep


And he also said this

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Eli is the worst in the division.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Yep


And he also said this

He’s a true moron.

 

[Daillest88]

Yep


And he also said this

Yup saw this. He’s getting flamed hard.

 

[Crazed Liotta Eyes]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

Well, at least Dak was rated above Keenum. LOL. Eli is done. Been canceled like Spinal Tap at the hotel. **'er is still going to throw for 300 yards against us next year though.

 

[Sydla]

Yep


And he also said this

O’Hara is just one of those former NFL players with a huge blind spot for his former team.

He sounds like a loon in these clips.

 

[buybuydandavis]

Wentz isn't clutch in 4th quarters, Dak is.

I think that's fair. But there are 3 other quarters.

 

[GMO415]

Ranking what they've done, what they'll likely do this year, or what they'll do for the rest of their career?

If you factor in running and durability, there's a case for Dak at the top for this year. Assuming everyone is healthy, I'd give it to Wentz.

Eli's resume is being the QB on SB teams with great defenses. Every so often he'd make a run of great games, but he'd have runs of stinkers too. His highest season QB rating was 93.6. Not impressive.

The one thing that has always impressed me about Eli is his ability to stick in the pocket and get rid of the ball before taking a hit. He's a tough QB who can execute under threat of a hit.

I damn near threw up when they said Dak second from the last.... citing "I saw him miss wide open guys!" We'll, I've seen all those QBs do the same!

 

[armadillooutlaw]

Wentz (if healthy)
Dak
My dog
My other dog
My other dog
My OTHER dog
Eli
Kellen Moore
Case Keenum.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

I think that's fair. But there are 3 other quarters.

My point is when pressure is highest, 4th quarter & overtime, Dak excells.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

Dak
My dog
My other dog
My other dog
My OTHER dog
Wentz (if healthy)
Eli
Kellen Moore
Case Keenum.

Dak
My dog
My other dog
My other dog
My OTHER dog
Wentz (if healthy)
Eli
Kellen Moore
Case Keenum

 

[supermanonsteroids]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

i bet he doesn't even follow football.

 

[armadillooutlaw]

Dak
My dog
My other dog
My other dog
My OTHER dog
Wentz (if healthy)
Eli
Kellen Moore
Case Keenum

I gotta admit, I considered putting Jameill Showers ahead of Keenum, too.

 

[ghst187]

1. Wentz
2. Eli
3. Dak
4. Keenum

* Host stated... "Given Eli's resume, he should be #1"

WTH?

So we are ranking them based on lifetime achievements on one hand but on media love and potential in the other hand? You can’t have it both ways.
Right now, Eli is hands down the worst QB in the east and it isn’t close. Not sure how that’s even debatable.
We can argue over Wentz v Dak potential but we can’t argue the fact that Dak is 3-1 against Wentz with better stats across the board. So you can have an opinion that Wentz is better than Dak, there’s just nothing to support it from what we can see and measure.
If one was a QB coach in the film room and practices with both and he said Wentz was better I would give that some credence but these clowns have no more insight than us.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

keep talkin' chumps...keep talkin'.
all I know is he has led his team to a division title 2 outta his 3yrs.....and beats those other chumps when we play'm.
'MERICA'S TEAM

Imagine how farther we would have gone if we had a qualified QB under center!
See bud there's always another side of the coin......

 

[supermanonsteroids]

nt