Dak Just Got Dissed big Time On NFL Live!

Carson

Well-Known Member
Messages
37,072
Reaction score
65,193
If it wasn’t for his 8-0 start Jimmy G wouldn’t be on their. Also. Anybody notice a pattern with the list?

Exactly

QB # A - 184-272, 67.6% Completion, 14 TD's, 8 Picks, 2054 Yards passing, QBR 60.3, 15 drops, 39 bad throws
QB # B - 230-360, 63.9% Completion, 12 TD's, 5 Picks, 2553 Yards passing, QBR 60.9, 15 drops, 63 bad throws
QB # C - 218-319, 68.3% Completion, 18 TD's, 9 Picks, 2,777 Yards passing, QBR 82.1, 20 Drops, 38 bad throws

So QB C, had the best completion %, most touchdowns more picks but throwing 47 more passes than QB A, most yards passing, highest QBR, most dropped passes BUT least amount of bad throws
 

Maverick84

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,248
Reaction score
9,175
Today I learned that Rob Ninkovich's opinion controls real life, and that I should care about it....
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
53,670
Reaction score
32,044
Jackson and Watson is a fad that will end soon, see RG3,. If they don’t become better passers they won’t last long. Murray is a bit different because in that system he gets rid of the ball super fast. Jimmy G is horrible, after Monday night most of the football world who doesn’t think he is bad is on drugs. Mahomes is great but his body will most likely fail him. None of these guys have the frame of Dak. I’d take Mahomes over him and that’s it but I’d know it was a 2-3 year investment and no more!!!
Watson is not a fad. He runs because he has a poor offensive line. Give that kid protection, and he'll kill you in the passing game. I thought Dabo was blowing smoke when he compared Watson to Michael Jordan. But seeing Watson play, he is more talented and more gifted than I gave him credit for.
Jackson is likely to have a short career, ala, Slash/Kordell Stewart. He won't be able to run like that for many more years. Either he's going to have to develop throwing from the pocket, or I'm giving him 3 more years of running as a quarterback - MAX! But maybe the Ravens think they'll get a Super Bowl out of him, which may be worth it.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,940
Reaction score
27,124
Soooo,

NFL Live just did a segment where co-host and former DL Rob Ninkovich from the Hatriots gave his "TOP 5 QBS Under Age 30". Here they are, in order of Ninkovich's preference, with #1 being his top QB:

1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Deshaun Watson
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Kyler Murray
5. Jimmy Garoppolo

Is there anyone who would seriously take Kyler Murray or Jimmy Garoppolo over Dak? Heck, I wouldn't even take Deshaun Watson over Dak, and I would have to think very hard about taking Lamar Jackson over him.
he should be 4 or 5 for sure..but Watson is better QB, and Jackson is a true front runner for MVP this year. he or Wilson are getting it..

so I agree 1-3 but Dak most likely should be 4..
 

aikemirv

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,224
Reaction score
9,723
I wouldn't trust the opinion of someone that puts Jimmy G in the Top 5 of anything, so I'd disregard that. Kyler is actually pretty good given his circumstances, but we should all know by now that judging a rookie is ridiculous. Dak knows and we know what his worth is, and that's all that matters. He's great QB. End discussion.
Yeah, Garrapolo is trash.
 

MysteryIceGuro

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,736
Reaction score
15,698
Exactly

QB # A - 184-272, 67.6% Completion, 14 TD's, 8 Picks, 2054 Yards passing, QBR 60.3, 15 drops, 39 bad throws
QB # B - 230-360, 63.9% Completion, 12 TD's, 5 Picks, 2553 Yards passing, QBR 60.9, 15 drops, 63 bad throws
QB # C - 218-319, 68.3% Completion, 18 TD's, 9 Picks, 2,777 Yards passing, QBR 82.1, 20 Drops, 38 bad throws

So QB C, had the best completion %, most touchdowns more picks but throwing 47 more passes than QB A, most yards passing, highest QBR, most dropped passes BUT least amount of bad throws

If you don't mind me asking, who is QB A & B? I know Dak is C, but it would be nice to know who he's being compared to.
B has A LOT of bad throws...
 

Bigdog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,764
Reaction score
11,407
I will be the first one to admit that I really liked Jimmy G and liked the trade that San Fran made to get him but Dak has really grown on me. I think I would take him over anybody on that list except for Mahommes.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,940
Reaction score
27,124
Watson is not a fad. He runs because he has a poor offensive line. Give that kid protection, and he'll kill you in the passing game. I thought Dabo was blowing smoke when he compared Watson to Michael Jordan. But seeing Watson play, he is more talented and more gifted than I gave him credit for.
Jackson is likely to have a short career, ala, Slash/Kordell Stewart. He won't be able to run like that for many more years. Either he's going to have to develop throwing from the pocket, or I'm giving him 3 more years of running as a quarterback - MAX! But maybe the Ravens think they'll get a Super Bowl out of him, which may be worth it.
agree with Watson, hes does more with less , always seems to make a play when needed under duress..Jackson can throw as well but the fact hes more like Mike Vick then Kordell.. dont underestimate that part of his game..hes not slash he is known for running but also moving and throwing on the run.. he may fade a bit but he has that IT factor that drives him to be great, not just his legs..you cant leave the 2019 MVP or runner up MVP off the list..

But dak belongs on the list at 4 IMO
 

CalPolyTechnique

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,383
Reaction score
44,174
Yeah, I don’t know if Dak belongs in the Top 5, but he’s certainly above guys like Kyler Murray, Jackson, and Garrapollo in my eyes.
 

visionary

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,719
Reaction score
32,209
Watson is not a fad. He runs because he has a poor offensive line. Give that kid protection, and he'll kill you in the passing game. I thought Dabo was blowing smoke when he compared Watson to Michael Jordan. But seeing Watson play, he is more talented and more gifted than I gave him credit for.
Jackson is likely to have a short career, ala, Slash/Kordell Stewart. He won't be able to run like that for many more years. Either he's going to have to develop throwing from the pocket, or I'm giving him 3 more years of running as a quarterback - MAX! But maybe the Ravens think they'll get a Super Bowl out of him, which may be worth it.

Yep
I’m taking Mahomes and Watson in a heartbeat

jimmy G still early in his starting career

the rest, no so much
 

IceStar-D7

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,179
Reaction score
7,451
Soooo,

NFL Live just did a segment where co-host and former DL Rob Ninkovich from the Hatriots gave his "TOP 5 QBS Under Age 30". Here they are, in order of Ninkovich's preference, with #1 being his top QB:

1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Deshaun Watson
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Kyler Murray
5. Jimmy Garoppolo

Is there anyone who would seriously take Kyler Murray or Jimmy Garoppolo over Dak? Heck, I wouldn't even take Deshaun Watson over Dak, and I would have to think very hard about taking Lamar Jackson over him.

LMAO...they were hitting 1000 until they got to Jimmy G.. It's not a dig against Dak. Being a top 5 quarterback isn't bad. Better then being a top 10 or top 20. Even Romo wouldn't be above any of these guys not named Jimmy G. So how is this bad for Dak? And then you add on top of it!!! These guys ALL have better coaches and coaching then Dak does. Put these guys in Dallas under this staff and see how they are ranked then,
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
53,670
Reaction score
32,044
On that list, Das should at least be 3 maybe 4. I say that because Dak has reached the playoffs twice, Jackson once, and didn't really do that much. Kyler Murray shouldn't have even sniffed that list yet.
I think the slight was intentional. Even Rob Rob knew snubbing Dak would outrage Cowboys fans. Dak has some ways to go but so do Lamar, Kyler and Jimmy. That's how you know the list was slanted to get a rise out of the billions of Cowboys fans out there. I can understand if Rob is not convinced by Dak. But what convincing have Kyler Murray, Jimmy Garoppolo and Lamar Jackson done that Dak hasn't?
 

ryanbabs

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,496
Reaction score
5,312
Soooo,

NFL Live just did a segment where co-host and former DL Rob Ninkovich from the Hatriots gave his "TOP 5 QBS Under Age 30". Here they are, in order of Ninkovich's preference, with #1 being his top QB:

1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Deshaun Watson
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Kyler Murray
5. Jimmy Garoppolo

Is there anyone who would seriously take Kyler Murray or Jimmy Garoppolo over Dak? Heck, I wouldn't even take Deshaun Watson over Dak, and I would have to think very hard about taking Lamar Jackson over him.
No way would I put Garropalo in the top 5. Maybe they were buds since he is an ex-Patriot.
 

RustyBourneHorse

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,758
Reaction score
42,597
Soooo,

NFL Live just did a segment where co-host and former DL Rob Ninkovich from the Hatriots gave his "TOP 5 QBS Under Age 30". Here they are, in order of Ninkovich's preference, with #1 being his top QB:

1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Deshaun Watson
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Kyler Murray
5. Jimmy Garoppolo

Is there anyone who would seriously take Kyler Murray or Jimmy Garoppolo over Dak? Heck, I wouldn't even take Deshaun Watson over Dak, and I would have to think very hard about taking Lamar Jackson over him.

Dak is easily better than Murray.
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,857
Reaction score
60,972
Yeah, I don’t know if Dak belongs in the Top 5, but he’s certainly above guys like Kyler Murray, Jackson, and Garrapollo in my eyes.

yeah it’s the qualifier of “under 30” that complicates some things too. There’s a handful of QB’s who can be placed in the discussion that just miss out on being under 30. Namely, Russell Wilson, stafford, cousins
 
Top