The argument to keep Jason Garrett for 2020

nobody

nobody

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,429
Reaction score
18,547
CowboysFever1973 said:
What if keeping Jason Garrett is a better idea?

Truth is.. life with Garrett hasnt been too bad. We have had many 8-8+ seasons, have won division numerous times and Garrett is the mastermind behind our current playoff push. A new coach brings so many unknowns.

My opinion is, resign Garrett for 2020 and give Garrett an ultimatum: Win SB or go home..
Click to expand...

e8a.gif
 

SmarterThanEinstein

Member
Messages
70
Reaction score
67
acr731 said:
Here's your big time couch...

a98800_couch_1-stuffed-cat.jpg





Smarter than Einstein, but doesn't know the difference between 'couch' and 'coach'.
Click to expand...
good one, i like funny. You funny... And probably was a supporter of hiring Garrett. I knew he was a looser. When did you see it? Did i spell everything correctly?
 
Aerolithe_Lion

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,911
Reaction score
11,883
I'll be in the huge minority here, but I do believe Garrett will leave a special legacy behind after he's gone; a very positive one at that. He built 2 of the 5 greatest QBs in Cowboys history with his bare hands. I have a feeling Dak won't quite be what you have come to expect once Garrett leaves. He doesn't know winning playoff games, he doesn't seem to have that Parcells/Belichick nasty side where players become too afraid to lose. But what he does have is a special connection to the quarterback position. Andy Reid has it, Frank Reich has it, Doug has it when his confidence is up, Walsh had it.

Not saying Garrett is anywhere as good as those coaches. But he didn't 'accidentally' fall into 2 of the biggest QB steals of the last 20 years. Romo was already good when Garret came in. He was great when he left. Dak has been better than any 4th round pick I can remember since Jared Allen. That doesn't happen in New York, in Arizona, in Denver, in Jacksonville. It happens with Jason Garrett.

Not saying don't fire him. He's earned whatever's coming. But it may irrevocably affect Dak, especially if the next guy is not QB-centric.
 

CowboysFever1973

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
2,105
Aerolithe_Lion said:
I'll be in the huge minority here, but I do believe Garrett will leave a special legacy behind after he's gone; a very positive one at that. He built 2 of the 5 greatest QBs in Cowboys history with his bare hands. I have a feeling Dak won't quite be what you have come to expect once Garrett leaves. He doesn't know winning playoff games, he doesn't seem to have that Parcells/Belichick nasty side where players become too afraid to lose. But what he does have is a special connection to the quarterback position. Andy Reid has it, Frank Reich has it, Doug has it when his confidence is up, Walsh had it.

Not saying Garrett is anywhere as good as those coaches. But he didn't 'accidentally' fall into 2 of the biggest QB steals of the last 20 years. Romo was already good when Garret came in. He was great when he left. Dak has been better than any 4th round pick I can remember since Jared Allen. That doesn't happen in New York, in Arizona, in Denver, in Jacksonville. It happens with Jason Garrett.

Not saying don't fire him. He's earned whatever's coming. But it may irrevocably affect Dak, especially if the next guy is not QB-centric.
Click to expand...
Very good point
 
Flamma

Flamma

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,131
Reaction score
18,903
CowboysFever1973 said:
What if keeping Jason Garrett is a better idea?

Truth is.. life with Garrett hasnt been too bad. We have had many 8-8+ seasons, have won division numerous times and Garrett is the mastermind behind our current playoff push. A new coach brings so many unknowns.

My opinion is, resign Garrett for 2020 and give Garrett an ultimatum: Win SB or go home..
Click to expand...

The mastermind? What playoff push? How is he getting credit for the rest of the division sucking? Otherwise he is the mastermind of a 6-7 team on its way to 6-10. Is that you, Brill?
 
Captain-Crash

Captain-Crash

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,520
Reaction score
33,777
Aerolithe_Lion said:
I'll be in the huge minority here, but I do believe Garrett will leave a special legacy behind after he's gone; a very positive one at that. He built 2 of the 5 greatest QBs in Cowboys history with his bare hands. I have a feeling Dak won't quite be what you have come to expect once Garrett leaves. He doesn't know winning playoff games, he doesn't seem to have that Parcells/Belichick nasty side where players become too afraid to lose. But what he does have is a special connection to the quarterback position. Andy Reid has it, Frank Reich has it, Doug has it when his confidence is up, Walsh had it.

Not saying Garrett is anywhere as good as those coaches. But he didn't 'accidentally' fall into 2 of the biggest QB steals of the last 20 years. Romo was already good when Garret came in. He was great when he left. Dak has been better than any 4th round pick I can remember since Jared Allen. That doesn't happen in New York, in Arizona, in Denver, in Jacksonville. It happens with Jason Garrett.

Not saying don't fire him. He's earned whatever's coming. But it may irrevocably affect Dak, especially if the next guy is not QB-centric.
Click to expand...
come on now you just want us to keep him because he sucks.
 

CowboysFever1973

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
2,105
Flamma said:
The mastermind? What playoff push? How is he getting credit for the rest of the division sucking? Otherwise he is the mastermind of a 6-7 team on its way to 6-10. Is that you, Brill?
Click to expand...
does bill belichicks legacy get diminishded because afc east is usually bad?
 
PA Cowboy Fan

PA Cowboy Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,766
Reaction score
50,160
Aerolithe_Lion said:
I'll be in the huge minority here, but I do believe Garrett will leave a special legacy behind after he's gone; a very positive one at that. He built 2 of the 5 greatest QBs in Cowboys history with his bare hands. I have a feeling Dak won't quite be what you have come to expect once Garrett leaves. He doesn't know winning playoff games, he doesn't seem to have that Parcells/Belichick nasty side where players become too afraid to lose. But what he does have is a special connection to the quarterback position. Andy Reid has it, Frank Reich has it, Doug has it when his confidence is up, Walsh had it.

Not saying Garrett is anywhere as good as those coaches. But he didn't 'accidentally' fall into 2 of the biggest QB steals of the last 20 years. Romo was already good when Garret came in. He was great when he left. Dak has been better than any 4th round pick I can remember since Jared Allen. That doesn't happen in New York, in Arizona, in Denver, in Jacksonville. It happens with Jason Garrett.

Not saying don't fire him. He's earned whatever's coming. But it may irrevocably affect Dak, especially if the next guy is not QB-centric.
Click to expand...
Garrett had nothing to do with developing Romo. Romo saved Garrett's bacon more times than I want to remember. Doubt he has anything to do with developing Dak either.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top