Let Dak Walk

JJHLH1

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,312
Reaction score
14,627
Troy said yesterday during the broadcast that he believes in Dak and that the Cowboys need to sign him to a deal. I’ll defer to his judgement on this issue.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,054
Reaction score
84,636
And then sit on their collective butts waiting until they to lose enough games to have a premium draft pick, and hope there is a real stud QB at the Cowboy's selection.

In the mean time they sit and waste the careers of several really fine players because QuarterbacksRUs has top flight QB's on back order and it looks like years before the Cowboy's number will be called.

One last point, you do understand the agent takes all offers to the player, but also advises from the agent's self interest to get a bigger payday and to entice other players to sign with him? Right?

The culture in Dallas has nothing to do with Dak's salary.

We shouldn't have to pay a decent QB like he is elite though. That is the problem.

I'd rather move up in the draft and grab a QB then pay Dak and watch the talent around him fade away.

He is a talent dependent player and a lot of guys could go 8-8 with this roster for cheap.

I think it's obvious after the last 2 seasons that Dak's success is almost completely dependent on how well Cooper plays.
 

Eightneight

Well-Known Member
Messages
564
Reaction score
498
And then what? Rely on a washed up re-tread qb? Rely on a draft pick? I'm not saying Dak is the best qb in the league, but you never let a good qb walk if there isn't a better replacement. Unless that is....you are wishing for another decade of Chad Hutchinson, Quincy Carter, Drew Hensen qb play. Dal is better than 2/3 of the qb's currently in the league. Why in the world would you let him walk? Let's see what a new coach can do with him first.
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,721
Reaction score
60,789
You really want to just “let him walk” and get zero compensation for him?

I’m ok if they decide to move on from Dak, provides they draft a top tier first round QB prospect.

But let Dak walk and not at least get some picks for it? That sounds like a horrible idea.
 

Rockport

AmberBeer
Messages
41,372
Reaction score
41,339
Wouldn't that be something, if the front office opt to let Dak leave Dallas.

Would for sure send a message to the team that no player is safe and that playing for the greatest franchise in sports (value wise) is a privilege.

The front office tried working with him, but he has declined all the offers.

Let him leave then.

Maybe that would spark a culture change within the organization.
They’re not going to let their franchise QB walk. He’s going to be here a long time so just get use to it. I swear we have the dumbest fan base in the country.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,054
Reaction score
84,636
And then what? Rely on a washed up re-tread qb? Rely on a draft pick? I'm not saying Dak is the best qb in the league, but you never let a good qb walk if there isn't a better replacement. Unless that is....you are wishing for another decade of Chad Hutchinson, Quincy Carter, Drew Hensen qb play. Dal is better than 2/3 of the qb's currently in the league. Why in the world would you let him walk? Let's see what a new coach can do with him first.

Drafting is a good thing.

If we added Andy Dalton to this roster would we see a major drop off at the QB position?
 

John813

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,303
Reaction score
34,167
Going to assume this is just based off emotion, or some ****.

Don't like him, fine, that's cool. But to say to let a young QB to simply walk is just nonsense. I mean, a trade thread would be one thing, but an outright let him walk for a potential comp pick?smh
 

BoysForLife

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,182
Reaction score
9,275
You really want to just “let him walk” and get zero compensation for him?

I’m ok if they decide to move on from Dak, provides they draft a top tier first round QB prospect.

But let Dak walk and not at least get some picks for it? That sounds like a horrible idea.

I would agree with this.
Honest question and not trying to troll you--what do you think we could realistically get for him?

Do you think there's a team out there that would give a mid to high 1st round pick for him?
 

the_h0wey

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,156
Reaction score
2,228
Wouldn't that be something, if the front office opt to let Dak leave Dallas.

Would for sure send a message to the team that no player is safe and that playing for the greatest franchise in sports (value wise) is a privilege.

The front office tried working with him, but he has declined all the offers.

Let him leave then.

Maybe that would spark a culture change within the organization.
pretty dumb take, but thanks for playing
 

JonesBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,510
Reaction score
5,003
Even if they wanted to move on from Dak you don’t just let an asset like that walk away with nothing in return. Franchise and trade.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,054
Reaction score
84,636
You really want to just “let him walk” and get zero compensation for him?

I’m ok if they decide to move on from Dak, provides they draft a top tier first round QB prospect.

But let Dak walk and not at least get some picks for it? That sounds like a horrible idea.

Maybe you could use him to move up in the draft.

Offer up Dak and our 1st and go get someone.

If we're going to pay someone like Russell Wilson you would at least like to see them be able to carry the team.
 

aikemirv

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,220
Reaction score
9,721
You really want to just “let him walk” and get zero compensation for him?

I’m ok if they decide to move on from Dak, provides they draft a top tier first round QB prospect.

But let Dak walk and not at least get some picks for it? That sounds like a horrible idea.

I think that ship has sailed. You can't pay Dak top tier money and then hope to trade him.

Any trade option is gone IMO.

If I could get Tannehill for 15-20 mill versus Dak for 30-35, I would do it.
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,721
Reaction score
60,789
I would agree with this.
Honest question and not trying to troll you--what do you think we could realistically get for him?

Do you think there's a team out there that would give a mid to high 1st round pick for him?


Yes. I do. There’s always a team or two that gets desperate at the position.

Sam Bradford recently fetched a first round pick.

Carson Palmer was traded for first round pick.

Jay cutler was traded 2 firsts.

Matt Cassel was traded for a second round pick

Kevin Kolb was traded for a second round pick and a starting cornerback.


Dak could probably land a first rounder. At very least a second rounder.

you don’t let guys with that much trade value just walk.
 

romonumberone

Well-Known Member
Messages
305
Reaction score
393
There is no way i would just let Dak walk and not get compensation. You know the saying there is 1 born every minute.
 

BoysForLife

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,182
Reaction score
9,275
Yes. I do. There’s always a team or two that gets desperate at the position.

Sam Bradford recently fetched a first round pick.

Carson Palmer was traded for first round pick.

Jay cutler was traded 2 firsts.

Matt Cassel was traded for a second round pick

Kevin Kolb was traded for a second round pick and a starting cornerback.


Dak could probably land a first rounder. At very least a second rounder.

you don’t let guys with that much trade value just walk.

Can't argue with that.
But to do that, we'd have to have him under contract.
Kind of a sign and trade type deal. ANd Dak would have to be on board with it before hand, I would assume....

that would be a tough deal to put together.....
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,721
Reaction score
60,789
I think that ship has sailed. You can't pay Dak top tier money and then hope to trade him.

Any trade option is gone IMO.

If I could get Tannehill for 15-20 mill versus Dak for 30-35, I would do it.


The franchise tag. Any team trading for Dak would also likely be permission to negotiate an extension with him before finalizing a trade.
 
Top